Gaza ceasefire advocates urge NY Dem voters to snub Biden with blank ballots

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

President Joe Biden's glide to victory in New York's primary next Tuesday could be scuffed by a wave of blank ballots cast by Democrats who want to signal disapproval of Biden's support for Israel during its war against Hamas in Gaza.

A coalition of groups incensed by the toll on Palestinian civilians launched its "Leave it Blank" before early voting began last weekend, enlisting supporters through its website, phone banks, emails and by passing out flyers at events. As of Wednesday afternoon, more than 1,200 people had pledged online to cast blank ballots, approaching the group's goal of 1,600 pledges.

The election itself is little more than a formality: Both Biden and Donald Trump have clinched their party's nominations and shed their last rivals weeks ago, even though several dropout candidates from both parties remain on the ballot for Tuesday's election.

The results on both sides will be notable mostly for signs of opposition that could dampen turnout for the nominee in November.

What's the vision behind 'Leave it Blank' effort?

The "Leave it Blank" organizers hope to show Biden he's ignoring an important part of his base and to spur a "course correction" by the White House in its stance toward Israel on the war, said Alicia Singham Goodwin, political director for New York-based Jews for Racial & Economic Justice, one of at least two dozen groups pushing for blank ballots.

Several thousand pro-Palestinian supporters rally in Union Square in New York City Jan. 27, 2024. After the rally, the protestors marched down Broadway towards lower Manhattan.
Several thousand pro-Palestinian supporters rally in Union Square in New York City Jan. 27, 2024. After the rally, the protestors marched down Broadway towards lower Manhattan.

Singham Goodwin said the goal is not to hobble Biden's re-election but to bolster it, by demonstrating a wave of unrest over Israel's military action that could cost Biden votes — and the election — in November.

"For us, a Trump presidency is really scary, and we're taking that seriously," Singham Goodwin said.

President Joe Biden takes the stage at Westchester Community College in Valhalla on Wednesday, May 10, 2023, to discuss the partisan standoff over the nation's debt limit and the economic crisis that will occur if it isn't resolved within the coming weeks.
President Joe Biden takes the stage at Westchester Community College in Valhalla on Wednesday, May 10, 2023, to discuss the partisan standoff over the nation's debt limit and the economic crisis that will occur if it isn't resolved within the coming weeks.

As of Tuesday, about a quarter of the blank-ballot pledges had been made through her group's website. Other groups involved in the campaign include the New York Muslim Action Network, various chapters of the Democratic Socialists of America and the New York Progressive Action Network.

There's no comparable Republican effort to snub Trump with blank ballots. But plenty of disaffected GOP voters may cast protest votes for Nikki Haley — or Chris Christie or Vivek Ramaswamy, both also on the ballot — as they have in other states since Haley ended her campaign on March 6. Haley won 155,000 votes — 14% of those cast — in Florida on March 19 in a primary limited to only Republican voters.

Is this happening in other states' primaries?

New York's blank-ballot push mirrors earlier efforts by ceasefire supporters that prompted large "uncommitted" vote tallies in Democratic primaries in Michigan, Washington and Minnesota, all aimed at sending Biden the same message. More than 100,000 Michigan voters cast "uncommitted" votes in the Democratic primary, which was open to Republican voters as well.

The dissent strategy differs in New York because its ballot has no "uncommitted" or write-in lines. The stakes are also different, since closely divided Michigan could tip either way in November while New York is a safe Biden state.

Jeremy V., a Yonkers resident who belongs to the Hudson Valley Democratic Socialists of America, told the USA Today Network by email that New York, while not an election swing state, is a "stronghold for the pro-Israel lobby" and an important place to signal support for Palestinians' human rights.

"Biden is at risk of losing in the General Election to Trump," he said, declining to give his full last name. "If he refuses to listen to the growing number of everyday working class people who support a permanent ceasefire, he will bear responsibility for another Trump presidency."

Israel supporters: Pro-Israel and local donors power Latimer to big lead over Bowman in funds for primary

When will NY's primary results be known?

The state Board of Elections plans to disclose candidate tallies only on election night, not the number of blank ballots. That blank count will be included in the official results after counties review them and the board certifies them, which has no fixed date but will take place at least two weeks after the election.

The Leave it Blank campaign threatened this week to sue the Board of Elections to force it to post all tallies on Tuesday night, including the blank ballots or at least the total votes cast. Attorney Emad Ansari argued the public is entitled to a full accounting of the election results when the polls close.

"The practical and very real effect of the policy is that it discourages voters, who in this instance are disproportionately young people and people of color, from fully participating in the electoral process," Ansari wrote in a letter to the election commissioners on Monday.

Supporters of Congressman Jamaal Bowman march to the Westchester Board of Legislators headquarters in White Plains where County Executive George Latimer was preparing to give his State of the County address March 14, 2024.
Supporters of Congressman Jamaal Bowman march to the Westchester Board of Legislators headquarters in White Plains where County Executive George Latimer was preparing to give his State of the County address March 14, 2024.

Kathleen McGrath, a Board of Elections spokeswoman, told the USA Today Network the board includes only candidate votes in its unofficial tallies for presidential primaries because their percentages are what determines how delegates are allocated, the real thrust of the primary.

Blurred lines: Latimer's call for military pause in Gaza shifts battle lines in primary against Bowman

Blank votes are not relevant for that calculation, and state law doesn't require they be included in unofficial results on election night, she said.

"Let the Board’s position be clear: all votes are relevant, and we encourage all eligible voters to vote in the upcoming Presidential Primary and cast a ballot however they choose," McGrath said.

Chris McKenna covers government and politics for The Journal News and USA Today Network. Reach him at cmckenna@gannett.com.

This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News: Israel-Hamas ceasefire activists urge NY voters to cast blank ballots