By Kate Kelland LONDON (Reuters) - Two major studies into how bees are affected by a group of pesticides banned in Europe gave mixed results on Thursday, fuelling a row over whether the chemicals, called neonicotinoids, are safe. The studies, one conducted across three European countries and another in Canada, found some negative effects after exposure to neonicotinoids in wild and honeybee populations, but also some positives, depending on the environmental context. Scientists who conducted the European research - in Britain, Hungary and Germany - told reporters their overall findings suggested neonicotinoids are harmful to honeybee and wild bee populations and are "a cause for concern". But scientists representing companies who funded the work - Germany's Bayer and Switerland's Syngenta - said the results showed "no consistent effect". Several independent experts said the findings were mixed or inconclusive. The European Union has since 2014 had a moratorium on use of neonicotinoids - made and sold by various companies including Bayer and Syngenta - after lab research pointed to potential risks for bees, crucial for pollinating crops. But crop chemical companies say real-world evidence is not there to blame a global plunge in bee numbers in recent years on neonicotinoid pesticides alone. They argue it is a complex phenomenon due to multiple factors. A spokesman for the EU's regulator, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), said it is assessing all studies and data for a full re-evaluation of neonicotinoids, expected in November. EFSA's scientific assessment will be crucial to whether the European moratorium on neonicotinoid use remains in place. The two studies published on Thursday, in the peer-reviewed journal Science, are important because they were field studies that sought to examine the real-world exposure of bees to pesticides in nature. Researchers who led the Canadian study concluded that worker bees exposed to neonicotinoids - which they said often came from contaminated pollen from nearby plants, not from treated crops - had lower life expectancies and their colonies were more likely to suffer from a loss of queen bees. On the findings of the European study, researchers told a briefing in London that exposure to neonicotinoid crops harmed honeybee colonies in two of the three countries and reduced the reproductive success of wild bees across all three. They noted, however, that results from Germany showed a positive effect on bees exposed to neonicotinoids, although they said this was temporary and the reasons behind it were unclear. "This represents the complexity of the real world," said Richard Pywell, a professor at Britain's Center of Ecology and Hydrology who co-led the work. "In certain circumstances, you may have a positive effect ... and in other circumstances you may have a negative effect" Overall, however, he said: "We are showing significant negative effects on (bees') critical life-cycle stages, which is a cause for concern." Several specialists with no direct involvement in the study who were asked to assess its findings said they were mixed. Rob Smith, a professor at Britain's University of Huddersfield, said the results were "important in showing that there are detectable effects of neonicotinoid treatments on honeybees in the real world", but added: "These effects are not consistent between countries and ... appear to be both positive and negative in different places." Norman Carreck, an insect expert at Britain's Sussex University, said: "Whilst adding to our knowledge, the study throws up more questions than it answers." (Reporting by Kate Kelland; Editing by Janet Lawrence)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- Kansas City Star
Upon closer inspection, the hunter quickly noticed something was amiss.
Aaron Carter announced the split on Twitter, and claimed Melanie Martin had "been lying to me the whole time"
Accuser says Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein picked her up at summer camp when she was 14 years old and sexually abused her for 5 years
"I felt very ashamed, I felt disgusted, I was confused. And I didn't know whether it was my fault," the accuser said.
- Lebron Wire
Here is what the NBA had to say about the Indiana Pacers fans that LeBron James told referees to eject.
- The Daily Advertiser
LSU football pulling Brian Kelly out of Notre Dame one-upped USC's hiring of Lincoln Riley in a manner that should be shocking for college football.
- Fighting Irish Wire
Not always the easiest to take the high road...
- Fighting Irish Wire
All the best to Brendon Clark!
- Bengals Wire
Some interesting thoughts on the Joe Burrow vs. T.J. Watt encounter.
An Oxford High School student shared video with father, who shared it with FOX 2, about the scene inside the building as a gunman opened fire, leaving three people dead.
- Best Life
As you dream, your brain sifts through your memories, thoughts, and feelings. And while most people are aware that dreams can serve as a window into our cognitive states, fewer realize that they can also shed light onto aspects of our physical health. Experts from the Sleep Cycle Center (SCC) say that in particular, your dreams may be able to alert you to a potentially dangerous disorder that occurs in sleep. That's because as your brain subconsciously processes your physical symptoms, it can co
- Detroit Free Press
The Detroit Tigers signed Javier Baez and fans don't know how to feel.
Jennifer Eakins is here to help you rip off that proverbial band-aid and decide who’s no longer serving your fantasy team the way fresh blood has the potential to.
As Thanksgiving approached, the New York Mets kept an open line with Javier Baez.
Leah Newman, a former Harpo Entertainment executive and daughter of WME partner Robert Newman, died Nov. 24 in Los Angeles at the age of 33, two days after giving birth to a daughter. In an unbelievably tragic turn of events, Leah Newman died at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, just two days after the birth of her […]
- Business Insider
Trump's lawyers fumble as judges grill them about whether Trump has the right to dictate which Jan. 6 documents Congress gets
"We have one president at a time under our Constitution," one judge on the panel told Trump's lawyers.
A 39-year-old mother has been missing from Los Angeles for more than 6 weeks. Her ex-husband believes her disappearance may be connected to her job in finance.
On Monday, detectives turned their search to a landfill where they were looking for human remains in Heidi Planck's disappearance.
The weapons expert who supplied firearms for use on the movie “Rust” told investigators he believed he knew how live rounds got mixed in with dummy rounds, according to an affidavit released on Tuesday. The Santa Fe County Sheriff’s Office has been investigating the cause of the shooting on the set of the film on […]
On Monday, the Texas Rangers signed All-Star shortstop Corey Seager to a 10-year, $325 million contract, a deal that his former team, the Los Angeles Dodgers, likely could have matched. Valued at $4.62 billion, the Dodgers are MLB’s third most valuable franchise, behind the New York Yankees ($6.75 billion) and the Boston Red Sox ($4.8 […]
- Daytona Beach News-Journal
If Ryan Newman's Cup career is indeed over, it was one of the more unique trajectories in NASCAR history.
- Fighting Irish Wire
That didn't take long...