DOJ Admits It Isn't Legal To Keep Prosecuting Washington State Medical Marijuana Users
The Department of Justice has agreed with defense lawyers that five Washington state residents ― including members of the same family ― who said they grew and used marijuana for medical reasons had complied with state law and that the U.S. government shouldn’t have pursued federal charges against them.
In a brief filed late Monday in the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, DOJ lawyers acknowledged that the department “was not authorized to spend money on the prosecution of the defendants after December of 2014 because the defendants strictly complied with the Washington state medical marijuana laws.”
The defendants became known as the Kettle Falls Five, because of the region in eastern Washington where they live. Three have been facing prison time, following the death from cancer in 2015 of Larry Harvey ― the patriarch of the family in the case ― and a plea deal taken by family friend Jason Zucker to testify against the other defendants.
The remaining three were sentenced in 2015. Rhonda Firestack-Harvey, 59, the wife of Larry Harvey, was sentenced to a year and a day in prison. Her son, Rolland Gregg, 35, was given a 33-month prison sentence, and his now ex-wife, Michelle Gregg, 38, was sentenced to a year and a day. All three also were sentenced to three years of probation.
The trio have remained free as they appealed their sentences.
The case received national attention as critics of the federal government’s ban on marijuana blasted the DOJ for prosecuting state-registered medical marijuana growers and patients in a state where pot is legal for both medical and recreational purposes.
“This case has turned the justice system completely on its head,” said Kari Boiter, who became a spokeswoman for the Kettle Falls Five. “Here we have prosecutors admitting that it’s the DOJ who is breaking federal law, not the other way around.”
State authorities raided the Harvey family home in 2012 and found more than 70 marijuana plants growing nearby. The defendants maintained that the marijuana patch complied with state law and the plants were for their own medical use. Washington state legalized marijuana use for medical reasons in 1998 and allows the growing of it for that purpose. The state legalized recreational marijuana use in 2012.
The five were originally charged with distribution of marijuana, conspiracy to distribute, and a violation of firearm laws ― all of which carried harsh prison sentences. Charges were dropped against Larry Harvey because of his terminal illness, and Zucker took his plea deal right the trial started.
In 2015, a jury cleared the three remaining defendants of all the charges except illegal cultivation of marijuana.
Twenty-nine states, the District of Columbia, and the U.S. territories of Guam and Puerto Rico have enacted laws legalizing marijuana growth and use for medical purposes (17 other states have laws allowing limited use of cannabidiol, or CBD, the non-psychoactive ingredient in pot that holds promise for therapeutic use).
Meanwhile, a federal marijuana provision that lawmakers have been renewing since it first passed in 2014, known as the Rohrabacher-Farr amendment, prohibits the DOJ from prosecuting medical marijuana operations that are legal under state laws. In 2016, the ninth circuit appeals court ruled unanimously that the Rohrabacher-Farr amendment blocks federal officials from prosecuting state-legal marijuana operators and patients.
The DOJ lawyers cited that ruling in the brief filed Monday.
“This court determined that [Rohrabacher-Farr] prohibits the Department of Justice from spending funds for the prosecution of individuals who engaged in conduct permitted by the state medical marijuana laws and fully complied with the laws,” the brief said.
That prohibition, the lawyers said, extends to expenditure of DOJ funds even if the prosecution was properly initiated prior to the enactment of the Rohrbacher-Farr provision, the brief said.
Despite the admissions by the from DOJ, the brief did not recommend charges be dropped against the three defendants. Instead, it urged that further proceedings in the case be bumped back to a federal district court. Still, lawyers for the family are expected to seek the case’s dismissal.
“Let’s not forget that Larry Harvey gave his life fighting for his family’s freedom ― and spent his final months on Earth working to pass the federal law that is cited in the prosecutors’ new motion,” Boiter said. “The federal government can’t give Larry back, but they can start to right this wrong by fully exonerating the surviving defendants, once and for all.”
Also on HuffPost
Because Most Americans Are Unenthusiastic About It
Because The U.S. Won't Control The Flow Of Guns Into Latin America
Because The United States Leads The Hemisphere In Drug Consumption
Because The U.S. Ignores Latin American Calls For A Rethinking Of Drug Policy
Because Of The Fast And Furious Scandal
Because American Politicians Refuse To Candidly Lead A Debate On Reforming Our Laws
Because The U.S. Tortures Detainees In Cuba
Because The U.S. Has The World's Largest Prison Population
Because The U.S. Jails Undocumented Immigrants Guilty Of Civil Violations
Because The Border Patrol Kills Kids Who Throw Rocks
Because The U.S. Recognized An Illegal Government In Venezuela
Because U.S. Extradition Undermines Justice In Colombia
Because The U.S. Helped Create Today's Cartels
Because The U.S. Backed An Argentine Military Dictatorship That Killed 30,000 People
Because The U.S. Helped Topple The Democratically Elected Government Of Salvador Allende
Because the U.S. Backed A Military Coup In Brazil In 1964
Because The U.S. Funded A Terrorist Group In Nicaragua
Because The U.S. Helped Finance Atrocities In Colombia
Because The U.S. Maintains A Trade Embargo Against Cuba Despite Opposition From The Entire World
Because The U.S. Engineered A Coup Against The Democratically Elected Government Of Guatemala In 1954
Because The U.S. Backed The Salvadoran Military As It Committed Atrocities In The 1980s
Because The U.S. Invaded Haiti and Occupied It For Almost 20 Years
Because The U.S. Invaded Haiti Again In 1994
Because The U.S. Trained Military Leaders Who Committed Atrocities In Latin America
Because The U.S. Backed Dictator Rafael Trujillo
Because The U.S. Invaded Cuba And Undermined The Island's Independence
Because The U.S. Colonized Puerto Rico
Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.
This article originally appeared on HuffPost.