Daytona considering new fees to fund affordable housing

DAYTONA BEACH — There's no question Daytona Beach needs more affordable housing, and lots of it.

The city's median annual income is $44,500, about $15,000 lower than Port Orange, Ormond Beach, Deltona and Palm Coast. For Daytona Beach's renters, who live in more than half of the city's housing, it's even worse: $34,000.

Daytona Beach's housing stock is also old. About 71% of the city's housing is more than 40 years old, and almost 30% is at least 50 years old.

Daytona Beach city commissioners have vowed to do what they can to spark affordable housing development.

As commissioners work toward a plan to get hundreds – maybe even thousands – of affordable housing units created in the coming years, a community meeting was held at City Hall Wednesday night to hear what residents have to say about the issue.

More than a dozen residents shared their views, and several of them said they want the city to start charging linkage fees on new development and putting the money into an affordable housing trust fund.

Daytona's need for affordable housing: How will Daytona help residents pay their rising rent?

Affordable housing top Daytona priority: Daytona commissioners focusing on affordable housing, flooding for next budget

FAITH group wants affordable housing: Flooding, affordable housing top priorities for FAITH group

For the past few years the local FAITH organization, an activist coalition of 30 Volusia County houses of worship, has been urging both city and county officials to charge linkage fees and start an affordable housing trust fund. FAITH reaffirmed that priority at the group's annual action assembly Monday night.

If Daytona Beach decides to try linkage fees, the city could raise millions of dollars every year.

How can affordable housing be financed?

Daytona Beach city commissioners are considering charging linkage fees when new development creates a demand for labor, but construction workers and people who will work at the new business or apartment complex can't afford local housing.

The fees can be collected from commercial development as well as market-rate residential development and placed in a trust that's tapped to pay for construction and maintenance of affordable housing.

A consultant the city hired, Strategic Planning Group, has recommended various linkage fees for different types of development ranging from $1.23 per square foot for new hotels to $23.35 per square foot for new office space. The city could choose rates lower than those suggested by the consultant.

If Daytona Beach charged $10 per square foot for 1,500 new residential units averaging 1,400 square feet each, that could raise $18.2 million in linkage fees over 10 years.

A non-residential linkage fee of $10 per square foot on developments that created 10.64 million square feet of new space could tally $53.2 million in linkage fees over 10 years.

Combined, that could come to $71 million in revenue for affordable housing in Daytona Beach.

The Framework Group, a Tampa-based developer, is building a six-story apartment complex on north Beach Street on a 3.5-acre site between the new Brown & Brown insurance company headquarters and the Main Street bridge. The apartments will be top quality and overlook the Halifax River, but they'll also be leased at monthly rates low-wage earners won't be able to afford.

If Daytona Beach decides to impose linkage fees, state law will require the city to come up with ways to make a developer whole for its linkage fee charge. That could mean providing the developer more floor space than would normally be allowed, density bonuses, flexible design standards, zoning variances, reduced parking requirements, accelerated approvals, reduced fees and tax incentives.

Daytona Beach could also look at requiring developers to sell or rent 10% to 30% of their new residential units to lower-income residents.

Other tools to spur creation of more affordable housing could include waiving or reducing impact fees and building permit fees, expediting permitting at no additional charge, allowing additional building height or square footage and allowing manufactured housing.

'Affordable housing is not charity'

Housing is considered affordable when the monthly cost for utilities and rent or a mortgage payment is 30% or less of a household's income, according to the federal government's definition.

Nearly 60% of Daytona Beach's renters are pouring more than a third of their income into rent and utility bills. Nearly 40% of Daytona homeowners are burning through more than 30% of their income on mortgage payments and utilities.

Rising house prices and interest rates will make the financial load even heavier for new homeowners, and some people will be priced out of homeownership entirely.

Those who spoke at Wednesday's meeting said they've seen how tough it is for some people, and they offered ideas to relieve that burden.

One man said some local restaurants are struggling to stay open because they can't find enough employees who can cover their housing costs on what they would be paid as a waitress or cook.

FAITH member Joan Campanaro said there are people working 60-80 hours per week to keep up with their bills, but they're leaving their children alone for long stretches to keep money coming in.

"We've got to do something better for our community," said Campanaro, who supports linkage fees and a housing trust fund.

Campanaro, a member of the First Step Shelter Board, said Daytona Beach could use 640 new affordable housing units per year to help both low-wage workers and people coming out of the homeless shelter.

Kevin Scott grew up in the government-subsidized Villages at Halifax apartment complex in Daytona Beach. He became a homeowner eight years ago by using a first-time homebuyer's program, and he hopes the city will use linkage fees and a housing trust fund to help other people improve their living situation.

Pictured is a construction crew last summer clearing land next to the Clyde Morris Landing affordable apartment and senior housing complex being built out at 1381 N. Clyde Morris Blvd., a mile south of LPGA Boulevard in Daytona Beach.
Pictured is a construction crew last summer clearing land next to the Clyde Morris Landing affordable apartment and senior housing complex being built out at 1381 N. Clyde Morris Blvd., a mile south of LPGA Boulevard in Daytona Beach.

Daytona Beach resident Anne Ruby suggested the city donate some of its small lots to provide places for prefab, modular and tiny homes.

Saralee Morrissey said the affordable housing that is created should be spread around the city and not all clustered in one area. She also wants to see a mix of multi-family, single-family, rental and owner-occupied affordable housing.

Charles Woodyard, CEO of the Daytona Beach Housing Authority, said a more formalized partnership between his agency and the city could produce good things for local housing.

A man at the meeting suggested using money from the affordable housing fund to fix up some of the city's subpar rental properties. Better housing that supports the workforce could help attract more companies to Daytona, he said.

"Affordable housing is not charity," the man said. "It's a good economic tool."

You can reach Eileen at Eileen.Zaffiro@news-jrnl.com

This article originally appeared on The Daytona Beach News-Journal: Daytona Beach residents weigh in on city's dearth of affordable housing