California Sues Trump Administration Over Census Citizenship Question
California quickly filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration after the Commerce Department announced that the 2020 census would ask people whether they were U.S. citizens.
The citizenship question, announced Monday night, will discourage people from responding to the census and will violate the Constitution’s mandate for “actual enumeration,” the state’s lawsuit argues, according to The Washington Post.
“The Census numbers provide the backbone for planning how our communities can grow and thrive in the coming decade,” California Attorney General Xavier Becerra said in a statement. “What the Trump administration is requesting is not just alarming, it is an unconstitutional attempt to discourage an accurate Census count.”
The census hasn’t included a question about citizenship since 1950. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross said the question would allow better enforcement of voting laws.
Adding a citizenship question is likely to make people more wary of filling out the survey, causing undercounts ― especially in communities with large immigrant populations, HuffPost and The Washington Post have previously reported. An undercount could cost states like California seats in Congress, federal funding based on population and electoral college votes in presidential elections.
“It is long settled that all persons residing in the United States — citizens and non-citizens alike — must be counted to fulfill the Constitution’s ‘actual Enumeration’ mandate,” California’s lawsuit states.
Eric Holder, a former U.S. attorney general who now heads the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, said Tuesday his group also will sue Trump’s administration.
“The addition of a citizenship question to the census questionnaire is a direct attack on our representative democracy,” Holder said in a statement.
Also on HuffPost
I'm an immigrant, son of a farmworker, & honored to serve as a U.S. Congressman. We should all have this opportunity. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/bi54szApXF
— Rep. Salud Carbajal (@RepCarbajal) January 27, 2017
Great love of my life, my abuelita, became a US citizen when she was in her 80s. She was so proud. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/ygJXGaTdh5
— MariaElena Fernandez (@writerchica) January 27, 2017
My dad is a Mexican immigrant who risked it all 2 live & raise a family here +start his own business.He makes America great❤️ #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/0y1SYIWXIV
— Belle (@esabelleeden) January 26, 2017
This is my Mexican fam failing @ taking a pic. We're just a family. Some are citizens some have green cards. #ImAlreadyHome #werealreadyhome pic.twitter.com/oTKiziZF6H
— Francesca Gámez (@cescathebesta) January 26, 2017
This sits on an island in my apt. A source of inspiration and strength. @DefineAmerican #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/VHfb3iuW5W
— Jose Antonio Vargas (@joseiswriting) January 27, 2017
My single mother from Mexico put all three of us through college. Her dignity & hardworking rhetoric make this country great. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/Ocra7jJsze
— alejandra l-g (@exploding_girl) January 26, 2017
#ImAlreadyHome My grandpa served for the USA NAVY from The #Philippines award The Purple Heart 💜 Great Grandparents came for #Freedom #USA pic.twitter.com/la96TaUj0Q
— Nanette Fabros (@ntfabros) January 27, 2017
Happy early-birthday to my Mexican-Immigrant father who came to America with two gallons of water and a box of crackers. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/MirFVMzcJp
— Yasmin Rey (@myasminrey) January 26, 2017
My U.S.-born grandmother got illegally deported. But nothing or no one will stop us. We persevered!! #ImAlreadyHome https://t.co/wq42Uop97O pic.twitter.com/CUWwDdhP1L
— araceli cruz (@chelipj) January 26, 2017
Worked in the CA CV fields next to my parents. Earned a BA, MS..have taught 100's of children to read. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/aWS1aP8NOB
— Solymar (@1phototeach) January 27, 2017
My mother raised 4 kids on her own. 3 went to college, the other serves in the @USMC
She works helping the community #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/E2fCEiZA6F— Susana Orozco (@SusanDelCampo) January 26, 2017
#ImAlreadyHome My Grandma, the one in the middle, is 1st generation. Her mom came to the US at age 6 in 1909. Proud to be an American Woman pic.twitter.com/jloVszt7V2
— Jo Booklover (@jolovesbooks) January 26, 2017
My 90 year old grandmother is a natural born citizen,but my father is an immigrant.#ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/YpFRKErQUl
— Summer Salazar (@slsanf) January 26, 2017
my dad is an immigrant who risked it all to give his family a better life than what he had in Mexico. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/G12hOA7Bzn
— pattie (@pattieamaranth) January 27, 2017
My grandparents left Cuba to escape a dictatorship and cleaned floors for years to help me get into school #ImAlreadyHome
— Christopher Mendoza (@DozaChris) January 27, 2017
I immigrated from Ireland and my husband from Chile.
Our kids are Chirish. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/Arnx73Vhxf— Sarnata Reynolds (@SarnataReynolds) January 27, 2017
My #Abuelitas came here in the 70s & sacrificed so we could have enough.
This year I graduate with my Masters Degree. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/qdXtyoh7ql— Daniel T. Clark (@Danieldcclark) January 27, 2017
My mom-in-law left a tiny Honduras village 48 years ago 2 raise 3 kids alone in NOLA & run her biz. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/zTaadi3RbA
— MariaElena Fernandez (@writerchica) January 27, 2017
My grandfather, Afro-cuban immigrant. Came to play baseball in a racist south. Refused to allow segregation defeat his pride. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/i5oIw4zLDw
— Thatninjajay (@julianelijah) January 27, 2017
Both my parents were first-generation middle school, high school, & college students. They graduated & gave me the best life. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/T0erRikatY
— Levi (@Levi_Har) January 27, 2017
My dad immigrated from 🇵🇪, worked 3 jobs to put himself thru college, sometimes only had enough $ to buy bag of rice to eat. #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/DOAfO8ec6u
— Paulina Vera (@Pnvera) January 27, 2017
Born to a military 🇺🇸 dad and an Argentine 🇦🇷 Syrian 🇸🇾mom who expriencd gov abuse in her own cntry that we wont allow here 🙅🏼#ImAlreadyHome
— Roxanne Krause (@rgenteeny) January 27, 2017
Born during the civil war of El Salvador 🇸🇻 worked hard to become a citizen of 🇺🇸 USA #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/php4pbXrsR
— Erika E (@evesbk) January 27, 2017
My parents came here from South Africa to live in a country that strives to value everyone #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/St2qOoXBcH
— JanksMarc (@janksmarc) January 26, 2017
My #immigrant family is from 10 countries, 4 continents. #wegetthejobdone #ImAlreadyHome #immigrants pic.twitter.com/FeKPcy5D4X
— Dr Nabil El-Ghoroury (@drnabil) January 26, 2017
My mom braved the desert to get here in search for the American Dream & raised 3 proud Americans who give back to the world #ImAlreadyHome
— Alba King (@psychenoel) January 27, 2017
Here's me with my dad, who came to the U.S. from Hong Kong seeking opportunity. Eternally grateful to be an American! #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/yny3JBDkjI
— Curtis M. Wong (@c_wong79) January 26, 2017
At my college graduation in 2014. My sister is now a sophomore @BarnardCollege my dad came to this country for this #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/tRh2EdTHlf
— Marlene (@MMarleneS) January 26, 2017
When my mom was my age (24), she took a risky 3 day bus ride with a bag chips and bottle of water in search of a better life #imalreadyhome
— Celeste Zumwalt (@celestezumwalt) January 27, 2017
My Ama came to the US legally & raised 10 kids alone & fostered many more, worked in the fields & marched with Cesar Chavez #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/svC5X7cDF1
— Jessica Carmen (@yoyeska) January 26, 2017
My parents built themselves from the ground up. Raised me to work hard & have strong core values. #ImAlreadyHome #1stGenLatinx #WeDIDVote pic.twitter.com/fUSMoekbjM
— La LuchaNora (@xdswgx) January 26, 2017
Papi. Who came to this country, fought for this country & served in this country for over 30 years! #VietnamVet USAirForce #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/GO5F3I5fIr
— Meralis Hood (@meralishood) January 26, 2017
Grandma from Ciudad Juárez, great-grandparents from MX. Laborers, educators, WWII vets. Me and my family love this country. #ImAlreadyHome
— Rob Trucha (@RobertTheJr) January 27, 2017
This woman taught herself English to become a US citizen while being a single mom of three #ImAlreadyHome pic.twitter.com/WeXgRg1tc4
— Arleene (@ArleeneValdez) January 27, 2017
my parents escaped Venezuela & its dictatorship so i could have a future full of opportunity & freedom. trust me when i say #ImAlreadyHome
— y: (@mariahernvndez) January 27, 2017
Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.
This article originally appeared on HuffPost.