New documents back theory that Covid outbreak started in Wuhan lab

·4 min read
Scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology were collecting viral samples from bats in Laos, emails show - Reuters/Thomas Peter
Scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology were collecting viral samples from bats in Laos, emails show - Reuters/Thomas Peter

Wuhan scientists were studying viral samples of high-risk bat species living in Laos - the country where the closest relative to Covid-19 has been found, leaked documents show.

In September, researchers discovered a viral strain called Banal-52 in Laos, which shares 96.8 per cent of its genome with Sars-CoV-2 - boosting claims that the pandemic was caused by a natural spillover event, rather than a laboratory leak.

However, it remained unclear how a bat-borne virus from Laos could have ended up sparking an outbreak in Wuhan, more than 1,000 miles away.

Now, leaked emails between EcoHealth Alliance and US government funders show viral samples were being collected from bats in Laos and sent back to the Wuhan Institute of Virology for study.

The emails, uncovered in a Freedom of Information Request by the US-based White Coat Waste Project, suggest that viral DNA from “bats and other high-risk species” were sent to Wuhan between June 2017 to May 2019.

Before Banal-52 was found, the closest relative to Covid-19 was discovered in cave bats in Yunnan, China, where EcoHealth Alliance had also been looking for viruses and sending samples back to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

The genetic sequences collected from both Yunnan and Laos were kept in an online database at the Wuhan institute. However, that was removed in September 2019, leaving experts unsure of exactly what strains were studied at the lab.

Viscount Ridley, co-author of Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19, said the emails added more weight to the theory that the virus leaked from a lab in Wuhan.

Speaking at the Institute of Economic Affairs in London, the peer said: “Banal-52 is not close enough to be the progenitor, it's still not the smoking gun, but it's pretty good. So maybe this virus started in Laos, not China. Interesting possibility.

“But we got a leak of a document showing that the EcoHealth Alliance was sampling bats in Laos.

“They say in the document that because it would be complicated to come back and ask the US Government for permission to give some of the grant to a Laotian lab, they’d like to send all these samples to a lab that can analyse it for them. It was in a place called Wuhan.

“So the outbreak happened in a city with the world’s largest research programme on bat-borne coronaviruses, whose scientists had gone to at least two places where these Sars-CoV-2-like viruses live.”

‘Plausible’ explanations on how Covid -19 emerged

Advocates of the lab leak theory said that emails give “plausible” explanations for how Covid-19 could have emerged.

Gilles Demaneuf, a researcher and member of the web pandemic origins group Drastic, wrote in a recent blog: “Now we have a very plausible direct route from Laos to Wuhan, a route with two options.

“Number one, a Wuhan bat sampler infected on a field sampling trip. Number two, a research accident in Wuhan when manipulating a Laos Banal-like bat coronavirus”

Mr Demaneuf points out that such manipulation of viruses had already been discussed in a grant application by EcoHealth Alliance, which was collaborating with the Wuhan institue

Proposals to the US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, which were leaked to Drastic earlier this year, show the scientists were hoping to introduce “human-specific cleavage sites” to bat coronaviruses which would make it easier for the virus to enter human cells.

The team also planned to take sequences from naturally occurring coronaviruses and use them to create a brand new sequence that was an average of all the strains.

Genetics experts have said that if Covid-19 had been produced in this way, it would explain why a close match has never been found in nature.

Pleas to discover origins of pandemic

Lord Ridley said it was “staggering” that more was not being done by governments around the world to find out the true origin of the pandemic.

“We need to find out because we need to prevent it happening, and be willing to deter the bad actors who are watching this and saying: ‘Oh, I could cause mayhem and get away with it,’” he said.

“The fact is that when the World Health Organization breezes into Wuhan and says “well, nothing to see”, that will be noticed in North Korea and by ISIS and things like that.

“I mean, that's me being ultra scary, and I don't necessarily think there is a viral lab being set up in North Korea as we speak, but it does need to be said.”

EcoHealth Alliance was approached for comment but had not responded at the time of publication.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting