Valentine’s Day POPsessions: Karmin Ace Our Compatibility Questionnaire

Lyndsey Parker
Yahoo Music

Amy Renee Heidemann and Nick Noonan, aka Karmin, are proof that the couple the plays (music) together, stays together. Though they first broke through to the mainstream with their frothy hit "Brokenhearted," the engaged couple's love is going strong in real life. And this year, they're celebrating Valentine's season with their current tour and new single, "I Want It All," with a new album, "Pulses," to follow in late March.

Pop's cutest couple recently completed, via email from the road, our rapid-fire, Valentine-themed "POPsessions" questionnaire about the most loved-up aspects of pop culture. How much did they agree when it came to these important issues? We think the proof of their compatibility lies in their adorable answers.

Who was your first musical crush?
Amy: Justin Timberlake, or Brandy
Nick: Britney Spears

What song was playing during your first kiss?
Amy: Oh my God, I actually can't remember! Must have been too focused! LOL
Nick: "All My Life," K-Ci & JoJo

What is the best makeout song of all time?
Amy: "Pony," by Ginuwine
Nick: Clearly, "All My Life" by K-Ci & JoJo

What's the best breakup song ever?
Amy: "Since U Been Gone," Kelly Clarkson
Nick: "She Hates Me," Puddle of Mudd

What song would you want playing during your first wedding dance?
Amy: "Gold Digger," Kanye West
Nick: I have to say the same, "Gold Digger." haha

What love song makes you cry?
Amy: "Say Something," from our buddies in A Great Big World
Nick: Cry?? I had my tear ducts removed long ago.

Who is your favorite romantic singer?
Amy: Sade
Nick: John Legend

What is your fave album to listen to on a lonely Valentine's Day?
Amy: Brandy, "Full Moon"
Nick: John Mayer, "Continuum"

Does the idea of a couple making out to your music flatter you, or just freak you out?
Amy: Flatter me.
Nick: A little of both. Mostly flatter, though.

What's the sexiest music video of all time?
Amy: D'Angelo, "How Does It Feel?"
Nick: Britney Spears, "I'm a Slave 4 U"

Who's the coolest couple in music?
Amy: Beyoncé and Jay Z
Nick: Besides us? Haha. Beyoncé and Jay Z

What's the most romantic moment in movie history?
Amy: "Titanic." Minute one until the end.
Nick: "Forrest Gump," when he's talking to Jenny's grave.

What romantic movie role do you wish you could play?
Amy: Any movie where I'm Denzel Washington's wife.
Nick: Any movie where I'm Denzel Washington.

Who is your favorite fairytale princess?
Amy: Jasmine ("Aladdin") or Ariel ("The Little Mermaid")
Nick: Pocahontas

What is the most romantic city to visit?
Amy: Boston
Nick: Boston in the fall

Describe your ideal Valentine's Day date.
Amy: Shopping, and amazing Italian food, with a great movie at the end!
Nick: Hanging low, planning a surprise dinner or date with presents.

Flowers or chocolates?
Amy: Chocolate
Nick: Chocolate

Do you watch/hate-watch "The Bachelor"?
Amy: Nope, we don't have cable!
Nick: Same as Amy.

Overall, are you pro- or anti-Valentine's Day?
Amy: Pro!
Nick: I'd say I'm pro.

If someone did that "Say Anything" boombox thing outside your window, would you be into it, or call the police?
Amy: I'd be into it!
Nick: I'd secretly be into it, but also be a little embarrassed.