Julian Schnabel’s Controversial Movie
"I make portraits of people. I don't like it when
people say I make biopics because I don't," Julian Schnabel said to me
this week. "The question is, does a Palestinian girl get to have her
As an artist, Schnabel is no stranger to controversy. His
paintings -- big, brash, imposing affairs -- have elicited some wildly
divergent opinions. Yet as a filmmaker, none of the handful of movies that he's
made, including the Oscar-nominated "The Diving Bell and the
Butterfly," has generated quite as much controversy as his latest movie,
When the film had its US premiere earlier this month at
the United Nations building, David Harris of the American Jewish Committee
slammed the movie, calling it "blatantly one-sided" arguing that it
portrayed Israel in a "negative light." And the AJC has not been shy
about lambasting the movie on other occasions. During its world premiere at the
Venice Film Festival, the AJC wrote: "Without exception, the IDF [Israeli
Defence Force] is stereotyped as an army of inhumane villains.... It is worthy
to note that no one seems to be aware that civilians are simultaneously being
blown up on Israeli streets by Palestinian 'activists.'"
The Palestinian girl in question is author Rula Jebreal.
Her novel on which the movie is based is a strongly autobiographical account of
her youth in West Bank.
She struggles between the indignation over the
Israeli army's actions against her people during the first Intifada and her
longing for peace. Not surprisingly, Israel
doesn't come off looking good in the movie. But Schnabel, who is Jewish, is
"It's not my job to make a balanced story. I'm not
trying to get elected. I'm telling the story that's in her book. I'm telling
the story that she wrote...I think that people feel the threat of Palestinian
people being considered as human beings, which is ridiculous. It's a really a
civil rights film."
"Miral" first came to his attention in 2007
during an art show at Rome's
Palazzo Venezia. Jebreal, who looks uncannily like her on-screen alter ego
played by Frieda Pinto, approached him with a script. "When I met her, I
said to her, are you Indian?," he recalled. "She said to me, no I'm
Israeli." "So you're Jewish?" "No, I'm Palestinian."
At that moment, I must have had a strange look on my face, because she said
"Are you scared?" I said, "Should I be?"
Schnabel wasn't terribly fond of the script, which was
written by somebody else, but he loved Jebreal's book. He had her re-write the
screenplay, which hewed much closer to the novel. The first hour of the movie
details the life, not of the main character, Miral, but of Hind Husseini, the
woman who founded the Dar Al-Tifel Institute, the all-girls orphanage where
Jebreal was raised. Miral's worldview is very much informed by Husseini.
Schnabel felt that this inclusion was important for the movie.
"As a storytelling device, I thought anybody who was
human and sane and young that had been surrounded by this supportive
environment created by Hind would try to help their own people. Anybody would
try to help their own people."
His collaboration with Jebreal soon extended beyond the
movie: they are now in a relationship. "She's very pretty," he told