Why Have Pro-Lifers Been So Quiet About Tear Gas Causing Miscarriages? Because They’re Hypocrites.

Erin Corbett

Police are escalating tensions at peaceful Black Lives Matter demonstrations across the country, and they’re using chemical weapons to do so. At protests in New Orleans, D.C., Atlanta, Minneapolis, and in other cities, police have used pepper spray and tear gas to disperse crowds of protesters. 

Many people have pointed to the dangerous impacts of using a chemical irritant against protestors in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic. The highly-contagious disease can lead to a severe or fatal respiratory illness. But the tear gas that police are deploying can also cause miscarriages, and the so-called pro-life movement has had little to say about it. 

Several studies have shown that tear gas can cause miscarriages and fetal harm. One from the University of Chile made the connection in 2011. The study determined that “chemical substances in tear gas can affect reproductive function,” according to Andrei Tchernitchin, a toxicology expert. As a result of these findings, the Chilean government suspended the use of tear gas temporarily, though it has been used during protests as recently as last year. United Nations officials also reported as early as the 1980s that tear gas deployed by Israeli soldiers in Palestine had caused “dozens of miscarriages.”  

But no such action was taken in the U.S., particularly in the wake of our current uprising. In response to the ongoing nationwide uprisings against racist police killings, anti-abortionists have been mostly silent on police use of force. Some anti-choicers, like Candace Owens, have only spoken out with the racist and also misleading talking point that abortions kill Black people at higher rates than police do. But if the so-called pro-life movement truly cared about the unborn, they would treat the ongoing police aggression of Black activists on the frontlines of demonstrations as a pro-life issue. 

Instead, they are also actively choosing to ignore the harm police cause to already traumatized communities when they target people with an abortifacient chemical weapon. 

According to an organizer with the Austin, Tx. Mutual Aid Collective, the “anti-abortion people aren’t saying shit about” the police use of tear gas against protestors because “they’ve never cared about life,” she wrote on Twitter. “They care about control of the masses. Using tear gas on protestors fighting for justice is very much within that. And that’s why we don’t call the pro-life” 

But this should come as no surprise. The abortion movement has a long history of racism, and has been known to collaborate with racist far-right movements. In the 1980s, the KKK created “WANTED” posters publicizing the personal information of abortion providers, The Nation reports. According to the same report, the head of the white nationalist group Aryan Nation said, “Lots of our people join [the anti-abortion movement]…. It’s part of our Holy War for the pure Aryan race.” More recently, neo-Nazi and white supremacist chat logs revealed their membership’s plans to infiltrate and recruit more people around anti-choice organizing. 

As uprisings against the police continue to spark across the globe, anti-choicers have made their message perfectly clear, and it has nothing to do with the right to life.

Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

When Police Reform Isn't Enough, We Must Defund

The Truth Behind The Myth Of "Outside Agitators"

These Artists Are Making Art As Political Protest

More From

  • As Millions Suffer From Unemployment, The Catholic Church Gets $1.4 Billion In Relief Funds

    The U.S. Roman Catholic Church successfully lobbied government officials to make an exception from federal rules to include the church in the Paycheck Protection Program, despite not meeting specific requirements. Because of this exemption, at least $1.4 billion in taxpayer-backed coronavirus aid has been awarded to the church. And, there is reason to believe that the total payout may have exceeded $3.5 billion, making the global religious institution one of the biggest recipients in the U.S. government’s pandemic relief efforts. According to an analysis of federal data conducted by the Associated Press, millions of dollars are “going to dioceses that have paid huge settlements or sought bankruptcy protection because of clergy sexual abuse cover-ups.” Data shows that the majority of the church’s money was approved during the loan program’s first two weeks. However, in that same time, many local businesses were unable to receive loans from the initial $349 billion funding to the program because it was first-come, first-served. In total, nearly 500 loans exceeding $1 million each were approved for Catholic entities. At least eight reached the maximum payout range of $5-10 million. Among the listed recipients are the offices of bishops, major churches, headquarters of leading religious orders, schools, and chapters of catholic charities. Faith-based organizations that promote religious beliefs aren’t usually eligible for money from the U.S. Small Business Administration, reports the Boston Globe. When the coronavirus hit and millions became unemployed, Congress made an exception to let faith groups and other nonprofits apply for the Paycheck Protection Program under the same parameters as other businesses. The PPP’s 500-employee cap qualification for applicants would have otherwise meant that many Catholic dioceses would have been ineligible; however, religious groups reportedly lobbied the Trump administration for an exception. The Archdiocese of New York, for example, received 15 loans totaling at least $28 million that just goes toward its top executive offices. Forty dioceses that have spent hundreds of millions of dollars over the past few years paying settlements to those coming forward about their experiences of sexual abuse in the church. The AP’s review found that these dioceses were collectively approved for about $200 million, though the total could be higher because the government’s data – released after multiple news outlets sued Congress – didn’t name recipients of loans under $150,000.The exact amounts are difficult to quantify because the government released only ranges of loan amounts. The Diocesan Fiscal Management Conference reported that about 9,000 Catholic entities received loans. That is nearly three times the number of entities AP could identify, reports the Boston Globe. AP’s analysis showed that 407,900 jobs within the Catholic church and its affiliated organizations were retained with money awarded through the loan program.“The government grants special dispensation, and that creates a king of structural favoritism,” Micah Schwartzman, a University of Virginia law professor who studied the Paycheck Protection Program told the AP. “And that favoritism was worth billions of dollars.” The PPP was open to all religious groups, and many applied, including evangelical advisers to President Donald Trump and many big-name churches.At the same time, the U.S. Department of Labor reported unemployment claims have surpassed 44 million since the start of the coronavirus shutdowns. A study conducted by a Columbia University professor estimated that homelessness in the United States could grow as much as 45% in the next year as a result of the coronavirus and its crippling effect on the economy. Upon the news breaking, some publicly criticized the payouts claiming that scores of dioceses faced self-inflicted financial pressure as a result of hiding rampant sexual misconduct. > AP: After lobbying, Catholic Church won $1.4B in virus aid with much of it going to ones who’ve filed bankruptcy to protect themselves from sexual abuse settlements 🤯🤬🤮 https://t.co/K2RVLAzpwp> > — Bobby Berk (@bobbyberk) July 10, 2020> BREAKING: The Roman Catholic Church in the US received a staggering $1.4 billion in taxpayer-backed coronavirus aid, according to the AP. > > Why are those who don’t pay taxes getting to raid the bank that was built by taxpayers? > > Imagine if our schools got this money instead.> > — Mrs. Krassenstein (@HKrassenstein) July 10, 2020> Millions of struggling Americans have lost their jobs, lost their health insurance, can’t get a Covid test, can’t go to school, and can’t pay their rent, and we’re spending billions of dollars to support the multi-billion-dollar Catholic Church.https://t.co/rDdBuljHvv> > — Keith Boykin (@keithboykin) July 10, 2020It is difficult to ascertain the total wealth of the Catholic church, but reported estimates and investigations estimate that just within the United States, the entity is valued at tens of billions. Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Here’s When All The COVID-19 Relief Measures EndHow Teachers Benefit From The Education BailoutCelebrities Who Got A PPP Loan From The Government

  • 13 Buzzy Lip Balms That Will Replace Your Cherry Chapstick

    Neon-bright eyeshadows in the summer. Moody black nail polishes in the winter. Floral fragrances for spring. We know, groundbreaking. But in 2020 — when we've all been stuck inside for so long that the seasons have all sort of blended together — fashion and beauty trends are following suit. The recent rise in loungewear clothing has led to a rise in loungewear makeup, including comforting lip-care products that you'd typically see in the colder months. But these tinted glosses, cushiony balms, and glossy oils are far more appealing than the half-used tub of Carmex buried in the pocket of your winter coat. From Summer Fridays to KNC Beauty, some of your favorite skin-care brands have taken on the lip-care category with gorgeous results. Whether you're looking to keep your mouth moisturized under your face mask or you want shiny, plump lips for your next FaceTime date, we've rounded up some of the best launches hitting the beauty aisle, ahead. At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

  • Valentina Sampaio Just Became The First Trans Sports Illustrated Model

    For the first time in the 56-year history of Sports Illustrated’s Swimsuit Issue, the annual special edition will feature a trans model: Valentina Sampaio. The 23-year-old Brazilian-born model previously made history by starring on the cover of French Vogue’s March 2017 issue, and later, in 2019, as Victoria’s Secret’s first-ever trans model. But the model hasn’t always experienced the kind of acceptance and praise that she’s garnering now. In an essay written by Sampaio for the issue, she shared her story of being born in a remote fishing village in Brazil, where trans people are subject to the world’s highest rate of violent crimes and murders — “three times that of the U.S.” “Being trans usually means facing closed doors to peoples’ hearts and minds,” she wrote. “We face snickers, insults, fearful reactions and physical violations just for existing.”For these reasons and so many more, Sampaio’s inclusion in this year’s swimsuit edition is monumental. “Thank you SI for seeing and respecting me as I truly am,” she wrote. “For understanding that more than anything, I am human. Thank you for supporting me in continuing to spread a message of love, compassion and unity for ALL.”Despite this being the first time that Sports Illustrated has included a trans model in the edition, it isn’t the Swimsuit Issue’s first historic casting. In fact, it’s, in part, responsible for catapulting the career of model Ashley Graham who, in 2016, became the Swimsuit Issue’s first-ever plus-size model. The magazine also selected model Halima Aden — who wore a hijab and burkini during her SI shoot — for its 2019 issue. This move by Sports Illustrated arrives following calls for justice for the trans community. In May, Tony McDade, a Black trans man, was shot and killed by police in Tallahassee, Florida. At the time, McDade was the 11th reported trans and/or gender non-confirming death by shooting of the year. A month later, news followed of the murder of a Black trans woman named Dominique “Rem’mie” Fells in Philadelphia. A few days later, people gathered together in Brooklyn to honor Black trans lives, with nearly everyone in attendance wearing white.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Victoria's Secret Has Hired Its First Trans ModelFrench <em>Vogu</em>e's First Transgender Cover ModelHalima Aden Models A Burkini In <em>Sports Illustrated</em>

  • Customers Are Boycotting Goya Foods After The Company’s CEO Openly Praised Trump

    Goya, a popular food brand known as the premier source for authentic Latinx food, has been trending on Twitter since yesterday — but not in a good way. After Goya Foods CEO Robert Unanue spoke at the White House Rose Garden on Thursday afternoon and praised President Donald Trump, loyal customers of the brand created the hashtag Goyaway.During a gathering for the launch of the White House Hispanic Prosperity Initiative on Thursday, President Trump signed an executive order to expand “efforts across all the federal government to deliver educational and economic opportunity for Hispanic Americans.” Trump honored Unanue, whose grandfather founded Goya, by appointing him one of the leaders of the initiative. “We are all truly blessed to have a leader like President Trump who is a builder. And that’s what my grandfather did, he came to this country to build, to grow, to prosper, and so we have an incredible builder, and we pray. We pray for our leadership, our president,” Unanue said during his speech. Trump, who was standing several feet away from him, seemed pleased with the praise and thanked him afterwards. This led to particular online backlash against the company from their supporters in the Latinx community. Goya Foods is the largest Hispanic food company in the United States and was founded in 1936 by Don Prudencio Unanue and his wife Carolina, who both came from Spain. It has always been considered a family company and a staple brand in many Latinx households. Despite the fact that Unanue announced that the corporation would be donating 1 million cans of Goya chickpeas and a million pounds of food to those in need during the coronavirus pandemic during that same speech, customers have responded to the CEO’s pro-Trump remarks by promising to stop buying the company’s products altogether. Julián Castro, the former Housing and Urban Development Secretary, tweeted his disappointment and called for people to boycott, saying, “Now their CEO, Bob Unanue, is praising a president who villainizes and maliciously attacks Latinos for political gain. Americans should think twice before buying their products. Goyaway.” Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez also quote-tweeted Unanue’s comments, saying, “Oh look, it’s the sound of me Googling ‘how to make your own Adobo.’”  Major constituents in the community have rebuked Unanue’s speech, too. United We Dream (UWD), an organization that serves young immigrants, also tweeted that it supports boycotting Goya for working with the White House, and started a petition for people to sign. “We don’t support companies who endorse and comply with a White Supremacist regime. Under capitalism, know the power of the dollar in their eyes. We’re using it to make a statement,” UWD said.This response comes as little surprise given Trump’s track record with attacking the Latinx community. The president began his 2016 campaign by calling Mexicans “rapists” and saying that they bring drugs into the United States, and has spent the last several years working to build a wall at the Southern United States border, perpetuating heavy anti-immigrant rhetoric. In addition, he’s continued to separate children from their parents at the border. For Goya’s once-loyal customers who have been affected by Trump’s cruel policies and attacks on the Latinx community, there’s no way to support the brand now in good conscience. Refusing to buy Goya products, however, is an act of protest against the harm done by the administration. Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?What It Means When Brands Boycott Social Media AdsWhy Harvard & MIT Are Suing TrumpThe Chaotic Beauty Of A Latinx Family Group Chat