Where I Shop for Real Jewelry That's Almost Cheaper Than Costume

Allyson Payer

Disclaimer: When speaking of fine jewelry, the term "affordable" is very much relative. Metals like 14-karat gold and diamonds and other genuine gemstones really don't come cheap, but a few jewelry brands have figured out how to streamline the process, whether they utilize direct-to-consumer manufacturing or have figured out other ways to keep their overhead costs down, therefore keeping their price points down.

Over the past several years, I've made an effort to save the money I would've normally spent on costume jewelry and invest it in fine jewelry. Even though fine metals seem to get more and more expensive, the jewelry brands I've bought from lately all have pieces that are cheaper than some costume jewelry. And even though some aren't, it makes me feel good knowing that I'm spending a little more on high-quality pieces that I'll possibly wear for decades as opposed to ones I might toss or donate after a couple of seasons.

With that, keep scrolling to shop my nine favorite fine-jewelry brands with stylish, relatively affordable pieces.

Mejuri

There's a good chance you're already familiar with Mejuri (it's popular), but I'm going to sing its praises anyway. The Mejuri pieces I own are some of the most-worn in my jewelry collection, including the chain ring and gold hoops pictured below. The brand introduces new pieces weekly, so there's always plenty to choose from. 

Shop my picks:

Mejuri Bold Chain Ring ($220)

Mejuri Croissant Knocker Earrings ($70)

Mejuri Bold Hoops ($150)

Stone and Strand

Stone and Strand is one of my favorite places to shop for wallet-friendly diamond pieces. It typically uses a lot of pavé stones, which makes for a ton of sparkle but not a ton of money. See what I mean below.

Shop my picks:

Stone and Strand 14-Karat Gold Diamond Ring ($645)

Stone and Strand Alphabet 14-Karat Gold Diamond Necklace ($325)

Stone and Strand Gold Diamond Hoop Earrings ($350)

Wolf Circus

Wolf Circus is what you'd call demi-fine jewelry, meaning it uses sterling silver and 14-karat gold plating for its pieces and genuine gemstones and pearls (but no diamonds). The Canadian brand's pieces are particularly stylish and the prices particularly low.

Shop my picks:

Wolf Circus Penelope Ring in Peridot and Gold ($162)

Wolf Circus Lola Earrings Gold Plated ($110)

Wolf Circus Isla Ring in Sterling Silver ($146)

Completedworks

Completedworks is another one of my favorite demi-fine brands, although it also has stunning fine-jewelry pieces (including engagement rings). I can't even tell you how many compliments I get when I wear its pieces. They're just so cool and unique. You'll see…

Shop my picks:

Completedworks Deep State 14kt Gold-Vermeil Hoop Earrings ($280)

Completedworks Twisted Phone Charger Cables Gold-Vermeil Ring ($295)

Completedworks Silver Encounter Earrings ($132)

White/Space Jewelry

White/Space Jewelry is an L.A.-based brand that I recently discovered, and I'm thoroughly obsessed. The pieces are modern and sculptural yet still wearable for everyday, and the brand uses sustainable practices and materials. 

Shop my picks:

White/Space Jewelry Diamond Hug Earrings ($295)

White/Space Jewelry Continuity Ring ($275)

White/Space Jewelry Baby Lagniappe Pearl Studs ($164)

Vrai & Oro

Vrai & Oro's prices are so good I sometimes have to double-check to make sure a piece is 14-karat gold. (They all are.) The sustainable brand's engagement rings and fine jewelry are delicate yet substantial and would be an excellent addition to a jewelry collection.

Shop my picks:

Vrai & Oro Cuban Link Bracelet ($175)

Vrai & Oro Solitaire Pear Diamond Necklace ($500)

Vrai & Oro Pave Line Ring ($450)

Kinn

Kinn is one of my favorite new discoveries, and I think it's about to be yours too. Scrolling through its stock, I can't find one piece I wouldn't wear, from the dome rings to the pretty chain necklaces.

Kinn Amelia Dome Ring ($480)

Kinn Colette Tapered Necklace in Diamond ($380)

Kinn Petite Link Chain Bracelet ($200)

Wwake

Wwake is another brand that you might have heard of, as it's famous for making opals cool again and for its stunningly delicate constellation-inspired pieces. The NYC-based brand is also sustainability-minded, and if you're looking for a special engagement ring, consider this your hot tip.

Shop my picks:

Wwake Dewdrop Gold Pearl Earrings ($270)

Wwake Dimple Diamond Ring ($270)

Wwake Pearl Collage Bracelet ($270)

Après Jewelry

Après Jewelry is one of my favorites for the basics. I wear the brand's tiny diamond-encrusted hoops in my second and third piercings every single day, and it has many other items that are comfortable enough to even sleep in, not to mention beautiful and timeless. It also makes engagement rings that you can custom design.

Shop my picks:

Après Jewelry Metal Dome Band ($350)

Après Jewelry Star Diamond Studs ($375)

Après Jewelry Mini Lucca Hoops ($95)

Next up, 15 jewelry brands for minimalists.

This article originally appeared on Who What Wear

Read More from Who What Wear

More From