5 Things You Should Know About Pumpkin Ale

Questions you might be asking yourself in October if you pay attention to the beer selection at your local market: What is pumpkin ale? When did it become so darn popular? And do they really make beer out of squash?


America is the land of DIYers and our founding fathers were no exception. George Washington, Ben Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson are all said to have brewed beer from pumpkins. They had to: Barley and other ingredients used to make liquor in the Old World were scarce in America. So settlers used whatever they could get their hands on, including parsnips, molasses, squash, corn, and apples. (This also explains why applejack brandy was so popular back in the old days.) But truth be told, the craze for pumpkin beers didn't really take off until the late 20th century, when craft brewers started playing with the genre.

What exactly is in pumpkin ale? Brewers can hand-cut (and roast) pumpkins and leave them in the mash as it ferments, or add pumpkin puree or even artificial pumpkin flavorings. Most breweries also add spices such as nutmeg, ginger, clove, allspice, and cinnamon. Note: No one makes pumpkin beer exclusively out of pumpkin any more. For a palatable beverage, you also need malt, hops, yeast, and water. Expect average potency: 5-6% ABV. And for those wonder: Is it always pumpkin ale? The answer is no. Though rare, beer makers have experimented with other beer styles. Witness: Lakefront Pumpkin Lager, Four Peaks Pumpkin Porter, and Fisherman's Pumpkin Stout.

What does it taste like? Some pumpkin beers feature subtle hints of the squash. Those are the good ones. Others taste like boozy pumpkin pie, often too sweet, cloying, and rich. The vast majority of companies play up the pumpkin-friendly spices more than anything else: cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, clove, caramel, and ginger. Tasters may also detect notes of molasses, caramel, earthiness, and hazelnut.

When are they sold in stores? Generally speaking, you won't see any pumpkin ales until September/October; this is an autumnal beer. Bottles stay on store shelves through the holiday season (end of December).

Who makes pumpkin ales? The top ten brands on BeerAdvocate.com are:

1) Pumking Pumpkin Ale (Southern Tier Brewing Company)
2) Big Black Pumpkin Ale (Flossmoor Station Restaurant & Brewery)
3) The Great Pumpkin Ale (Elysian Brewing Company)
4) Schlafly Pumpkin Ale (Saint Louis Brewery)
5) Kuhnhenn All Hallows Pumpkin Ale (Kuhnhenn Brewing Company)
6) Great Pumpkin Ale (Cambridge Brewing Company)
7) Punkin' Ale Pumpkin Ale (Dogfish Head Craft Brewery)
8) Cottonwood Pumpkin Spiced Ale (Carolina Beer Company)
9) Night Owl Pumpkin Ale (Elysian Brewing Company)
10) Imperial Pumpkin Ale (Weyerbacher Brewing Co.)

Other popular pumpkin ale makers include Blue Moon (from Coors), Bison Organic, Post Road (from Brooklyn Brewery), Southampton, Smuttynose, Shipyard, Buffalo Bill, Mavericks, and Jack's (from Anheuser-Busch).

by James Oliver Cury


Watch bartender Eben Freeman mix a bubblegum cocktail

The Epicurious guide to entertaining featuring lifestyle expert Clinton Kelly

Get ready for fall with recipes for cooking with the best fall ingredients

How best to pair beer with food

Amy Sedaris gives us a Halloween party to scream about