Why Man's 'Marriage Isn't For You' Essay Misses the Mark

Elise Solé, Shine Staff

The Internet is loaded with marriage advice, but rarely does one single tidbit resonate strongly with so many people. On Saturday, writer Seth Adam Smith posted an essay on his blog titled, "Marriage Isn’t for You," about his utterly selfless approach to marriage, generating both praise and vitriol.

Twitter was flooded with commentary:

Then came the backlash.

“Having been married only a year and a half, I’ve recently come to the conclusion that marriage isn’t for me,” Smith begins, before pulling a bait and switch on the reader and launching into his pro-marriage stance, which he developed after getting cold feet before his wedding to wife Kim. “Was I ready? Was I making the right choice? Was Kim the right person to marry? Would she make me happy?”

More on Yahoo Shine: Secret Reasons Married Couples Have More Sex

Smith, who works as editor in chief of a motivational website, turned to his father for guidance and says that what he learned was life-altering. "He said, 'Seth, you’re being totally selfish. So I’m going to make this really simple: marriage isn’t for you. You don’t marry to make yourself happy, you marry to make someone else happy. More than that, your marriage isn’t for yourself, you’re marrying for a family. Not just for the in-laws and all of that nonsense, but for your future children. Who do you want to help you raise them? Who do you want to influence them? Marriage isn’t for you. It’s not about you. Marriage is about the person you married.'”

His father’s words prompted him to rethink his marriage philosophy. “No, a true marriage (and true love) is never about you," he writes. "It’s about the person you love — their wants, their needs, their hopes, and their dreams. Selfishness demands, 'What’s in it for me?', while Love asks, 'What can I give?'"

More on Yahoo: Woman's Unforgettable Marriage Proposal By 'Homeless' Man

While Yahoo Shine could not reach Smith or his wife for comment, Smith addressed the controversy on Today.com on Tuesday. “Writing this post was the capstone of everything I’d been learning,” he told the site. “Hopefully someone going through a similar experience…will be able to turn around their relationship. That was my hope.”

According to Andrea Bonior, PhD, a Washington, D.C.-based licensed clinical psychologist, Smith's intention may be good, but his message is muddled. “People live crazy, hectic lives, so taking time to appreciate your partner and the commitment you made to each other is a positive thing,” she tells Yahoo Shine. “However, marriage is not just about one person's needs." Science substantiates that: One recent study conducted by Monmouth University found that couples who focus on their own personal growth, as opposed to their partner's, are more committed and enjoy longer marriages.

The message can also be confusing to women, innate providers to begin with, says Bonior. Culture encourages this maternal instinct from childhood by giving little girls dolls to care for, and this mentality often carries over into adulthood, sometimes to extreme levels. We already know that women do the lion’s share of chores and childcare, but they work longer hours outside the home, too, according to a recent study conducted by the Pew Research Center. The average number of hours per week that men spend at their jobs has declined from 42 to 37 between 1965 and 2011. Meanwhile, women have increased their office time from 8 hours to 21 hours. “If women are taught to further put their personal needs on the back burner, what would their lives look like?” asks Bonior.
















The post also left unanswered questions. Sure, marriage means for better or worse, but what are love’s limits? Should a husband prioritize the needs of a chronically selfish wife? Should an abused woman put her husband’s feelings first? Or does the rule apply only to more minor issues in marriage — for example, forgoing girls' night to watch his baseball game? There’s a natural ebb and flow to marriage and people’s needs and ability to fulfill them waxes and wanes over time. It’s common for couples to go through periods when one person gives 80 percent, while the other can muster only 20 percent. But, warns Bonior, couples who keep score of each other’s efforts don’t operate as a team and are likely to feel resentful toward each other.

Ultimately, marriage is highly individualized and Smith's marriage sounds like a happy one. The most interesting layer to this story might be less about the Smiths' union and more about what people glean from it. “Marriage doesn’t come naturally to most people; it’s a lifelong learning experience,” says Bonior. “The essay may have struck a nerve because it makes people question their own marriages — are they good partners? Should they be giving or taking more? Questioning your relationship with the intent on improving it is always a good thing."

More on Yahoo Shine: 

9 Hidden Causes of the Biggest Marriage Problems
'Today' Show Marriage Proposal Slammed by Critics
9 Unexpected Things That Could Save Your Marriage







More From

  • 40+ Things That Made Summer in the '90s All That and a Bag of Chips

    ICYMI, it's summer, summer, summertime. Time to sit back and rewind to the '90s, when the ice cream was shaped like cartoon characters and you could just yell, "Mom!" for more poolside Squeezits. We're celebrating the sweltering season the best way we know how: by reminiscing about our lazy childhood summers in the '90s. Let's relive some of our favorite things about summer in the '90s! Related: 375 Things You'll Remember If You Grew Up in the '90s

  • Some of Our Favorite Disney Princes Look Hot as Hell in This Realistic Artwork

    Hold on - is this artwork created by Jirka Vinse Jonatan Väätäinen images of actual models, new Bachelorette contestants, or Disney princes? The artist and graphic designer, who beautifully reimagined what Disney princesses would look like if they were real women, did it again - but this time with the sexy dudes of our favorite fairytales. Can we just say that Prince Eric is looking FINE? And John Smith's long-hair-don't-care look is working for us in a real way (he also definitely looks like Smith from Sex and the City). The artwork is actually a few years old, but is making the rounds on the internet again because . . . well, just look at 'em! Ahead, see the stunningly sexy photos of your favorite Disney princes reimagined in real life. Related: Disney Just Released New Princess Wedding Dresses For Your Own Happily Ever After

  • This Adventurous Elopement Involved a Long Hike to a Waterfall, but Wow, It Was Worth It

    Mira and Pearce met on a dating app. Pearce hadn't even bothered to complete his profile, so Mira didn't want to swipe right, but her friend did it for her! And thank goodness she did, because the pair were meant to be, and in late 2018, they tied the knot in a unique way that totally represented who they are as a couple. Instead of a traditional wedding, they opted for an adventurous elopement and rented a cabin in Sooke on Vancouver Island in British Columbia, Canada. On the day of their wedding, the pair were very relaxed, despite the fact that it was supposed to rain. Pearce called it "the perfect day" for their wedding. The pair upped the adventure and decided to take their wedding photos at Mystic Beach, which involved a 45-minute hike just to reach the entrance. The pair said their "I dos" and were brimming with joy. Photographer Heather Stone captured their happiness against the stunning outdoor scenery. "Once we finished, they darted across the beach then looped back and jumped straight through the waterfall and into their futures together," Heather said. She captured a few more snaps of the pair until sunset, and they turned out absolutely incredible. Take a look for yourself! Related: These Brides Eloped in the Clouds, and It Looks Absolutely Magical

  • The Love Story Behind This Couple's Marvel-Themed Wedding Is One For the (Comic) Books

    Shana and James's love story all began with a simple "like" on social media. The two messaged each other for a while and wound up going on a couple dates. Shana was late to both, but that didn't deter James. In fact, James's mom is always late, and he always thought he would marry someone with similar traits to his mother. "At the end of the second date when [we] hugged, James [said] he thought I fit him perfectly," Shana told POPSUGAR. "It was like puzzle pieces. We just went well together. It was later I found out from James that at that moment he knew he wanted to be with me for the rest of his life." When it came to popping the question, James took his time after purchasing the ring to plan the perfect, most memorable proposal. Finally, the idea came to him: first, he wrote and recorded an original song for Shana, then he filmed a music video that featured all of their friends and family with a surprise proposal at the end. Shana was told the film was for a Black love documentary, so she had no idea what James had up his sleeve. "While filming, all our family and friends jumped out of nowhere and screamed 'Shay!'" Shana said. "Looking around the corner to see everybody there, especially my best friend, who I thought was still in Michigan at the time, was totally shocking and mind-blowing. After turning back around I see James on bended knee and of course, I start to cry. He then asks me to marry him, and [I] said yes!" The gesture was sweet, romantic, and in Shana's words, the "most amazing proposal." It wasn't long after the engagement before the two started planning their big day. Shana knew what she wanted from the start, but agreed to let James have his input. As it turns out, James knew what he wanted as well - a Marvel comics-themed wedding - and immediately started purchasing the outfits and masks needed to make it happen. The couple got married in October 2019 in High Point, NC, and had a celebration of a lifetime, complete with superheroes and elegant touches. Keep reading to watch Shana and James's proposal music video, see their cute comic bookstore save-the-date photo shoot with their son, and see all marvelous wedding photos captured by photographer Temilola Ajibulu! Related: A Wakandan Wedding: This Bridal Shoot Is Inspired by Black Panther, and OMG - It's Gorgeous