So, How Is It Really? Wearing A Scarf Top In 2022

·3 min read

When I was growing up, scarf tops were a defining trend for cool kids. It was the early 2000s, an era when celebrities like Beyoncé and Christina Aguilera often sported bandanas and scarves as tops, baring a lot of skin and inspiring teens and young adults to do the same. I can still remember the first time I asked my mom if I could wear one when I saw a girl sporting a royal blue scarf top at the supermarket, to which she replied: “You’re too young for that.”

So, when the trend came back around this summer — now thanks to celebrities like Bella Hadid and Rihanna, as well as designers like Versace and Blumarine — I was excited to finally get to live out my Y2K fashion dream. But, while wearing a makeshift top badly tied around your chest seems like a great idea to a 9-year-old kid, putting it to practice as a 27-year-old professional is an entirely different game. Still, in the name of Britney, Christina, and Beyoncé — the holy trinity of my childhood — I was determined to try it.

I had a few big-enough scarves at my disposal to test the trend without having to actually invest in it. For the first look, I went for a scarf featuring a boob print from one of my favorite Puerto Rican designers Amanda Forastieri. I paired it with a classic black blazer, denim shorts, and low-heeled sandals for a work day (my current office is a coworking space, so dress codes are not an issue). While the outfit was comfortable at first, I quickly found myself pulling up the top throughout the day to avoid a mishap in public, and wondered many times why I hadn’t thought about using some body tape to make up for the slippery nature of the silky scarf. This made me realize that this trend has no place in my office-ready closet.

The next look involved a Marimekko silk scarf in earth tones for a casual dinner. I went for a coastal grandmother vibe by pairing it with white linen pants from Onia, a straw handbag, and gold hoop earrings. While I may have worn this one only for a few hours, I once again kicked myself for not investing in body tape as I continued to tug and pull on the top, this time in fear of a slip in the restaurant.

For my final look, I channeled Versace’s baroque-style prints, which have been highly popular over the past few years as the brand has tapped into its signature house code. I chose a black chiffon scarf with a floral print that I was gifted years ago, and paired it with wide-leg trousers and black sandals for a night out at a bar. To make the all-black outfit more summer-appropriate, I added a straw clutch. This one made me second guess my initial reservations about the scarf top. Not only did it feel like a grown-up version of the ’00s look, but the chiffon fabric stayed on much better, making it a lot more comfortable to wear.

Perhaps the biggest takeaway I got from this experiment is that adopting old trends isn’t about going back in time, but rather modernizing them for your current lifestyle. Even though I know silk scarf tops may not be my cup of tea — they’re too uncomfortable to wear for long periods of time — I’m now a pro in the art of styling one as an adult.

I did my holy trinity — and my inner child — proud.

At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.

Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

12 Silk Bandanas To Battle The Heat In Style

Why Some Millennials Are Embracing The Y2K Trends

A Case For The Return Of The Arm Cuff