Notes For Unsolved True Crime: The Perplexing Disappearance of Judge Joseph F. Crater

·12 min read


Licensed via Audio Network

SFX Provided By AudioBlocks



Vintage wedding throw - stock photo

sandoclr/Getty Images

Faces of Business - Confident Colour Image

JohnnyGreig/Getty Images

concrete polished texture background

chingraph/Getty Images

Diverse People Smiling

JohnnyGreig/Getty Images

We're all special in our own way

Yuri_Arcurs/Getty Images

Polly Adler, known as the vice queen, at resort. She was hel

New York Daily News Archive/Getty Images

Special agents collect clues in a mock crime scene room call

New York Daily News Archive/Getty Images

Luxury is the keynote in living room of the expensive three-

New York Daily News Archive/Getty Images

Portrait of business man at work

Flashpop/Getty Images

Polly Adler

Archive Photos/Getty Images

Man in full suit standing in studio, (Rear view), (B&W)

George Marks/Getty Images

Woman whistling, posing in studio, (B&W), portrait

George Marks/Getty Images

Man in full suit, (B&W), portrait

George Marks/Getty Images

Elegant woman posing in studio, (B&W), (Portrait)

George Marks/Getty Images

Young businessman sitting at desk, writing, (B&W)

George Marks/Getty Images

Senior man posing in studio, (B&W), close-up, portrait

George Marks/Getty Images

An undated portrait of US President Franklin D. Ro

AFP/Getty Images

Audience In The Newsreel Theatre

Gene Lester/Getty Images


Mike Brinson/Getty Images


Archive Holdings Inc./Getty Images

Difficult Call

Camerique Archive/Getty Images

Still From 1930s Gangster Film

Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Elderly man smiling, portrait

Jack Hollingsworth/Getty Images

Old Prospector Panning For Gold In A Western Sunset

LifeJourneys/Getty Images

Students In A Lecture Hall During A Lesson

Mondadori Portfolio/Getty Images

Topographical California map color coded by county

NSA Digital Archive/Getty Images

Postcard with Valentine's Day love puzzle message, 1871

whitemay/Getty Images

Artist's letter with blank envelope

whitemay/Getty Images

Empty Courtroom

Underwood Archives/Getty Images

Robert Young In 'They Won't Believe Me'

Archive Photos/Getty Images

Columbia University, main quad with Low Memorial Library, Upper West Side, New York, NY, U.S.A.

Barry Winiker/Getty Images

Watson hall at Lafayette college on a sunny day

CynthiaAnnF/Getty Images

1930s portrait of man, retro

NNehring/Getty Images

USA, New York, New York City, Skyscrapers of Manhattan

Gary J Weathers/Getty Images


H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty Images

Cast Members of Anything Goes

John Springer Collection/Getty Images

Policemen in Grand Central Terminal

Bo Zaunders/Getty Images

Man Selling Roadster After Stock Market Crash

Bettmann/Getty Images

Polly Adler Signing one of Her Books

Bettmann/Getty Images

Entrance to Coney Island

Bettmann/Getty Images

Robert F. Wagner Attending Governmental Finance Meeting

Bettmann/Getty Images

Judge Joseph Force Crater and Wife

Bettmann/Getty Images

Judge Joseph Force Crater

Bettmann/Getty Images

Lucky Blackiet Holding Picture of Man

Bettmann/Getty Images

Prospector Panning for Gold

Bettmann/Getty Images

New York's New Tammany Hall

Bettmann/Getty Images

Mrs. Stella In A Radio Interview

Bettmann/Getty Images

adult businessman

jaroon/Getty Images

Brown envelope.

amnachphoto/Getty Images

Mature woman

Henrik Sorensen/Getty Images

Man working in old distillery in retro style clothing

kali9/Getty Images

Man working in old distillery

kali9/Getty Images

Judge Joseph Crater

New York Daily News/Getty Images

Judge Joseph Crater

New York Daily News/Getty Images

Judge Joseph Crater

New York Daily News/Getty Images

Ready to cleaning

izusek/Getty Images

CBS Radio...

CBS Photo Archive/Getty Images

Midsection Of Male Lawyer Working With Coworker On Table

Audtakorn Sutarmjam / EyeEm/Getty Images

Drinking whiskey in an empty bar. Golden colour alcohol drink on wooden table in a pub. Relaxing after work, drinking booze

Ja'Crispy/Getty Images

Blank white vertical closed and open and upside down book cover

dmitriymoroz/Getty Images

New York Aquarium

Museum of the City of New York/Getty Images

Hotel room. chambermaid

Marka/Getty Images

Portrait Of Man Standing Against Wall

Alexsey Emelyanov / EyeEm/Getty Images

Taking Notes

George Marks/Getty Images

Detective board with photos of suspected criminals, crime scenes and evidence with red threads

André Chagas/Getty Images

Zachary Taylor House, 5608 Pache Road, formerly Blankenbaker Lane, Saint Matthews, Jefferson County, Kentucky, USA, 1933

Education Images/Getty Images

Fifth Avenue in the morning, New York City, USA

Alexander Spatari/Getty Images

City Car Taxi

Wisconsin Historical Society/Getty Images

Map of middle atlantic states USA 1895

THEPALMER/Getty Images

Lawyer holding document and speaking to jury in courtroom

Harold M. Lambert/Getty Images

Antique photograph of World's famous sites: Market Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

ilbusca/Getty Images

New York State Supreme Court Building

The New York Historical Society/Getty Images


ullstein bild/Getty Images

Antique chair on the carpet

VictorGrow/Getty Images

Love In The Elephant and Castle

Bert Hardy/Getty Images

1920s 1930s WOMAN MAKING A...

Camerique/ClassicStock/Getty Images

View up Fifth Avenue, New York

Library of Congress/Getty Images

Senator Robert F. Wagner

Library of Congress/Getty Images

Men Meeting Prostitutes Along Street

Hulton Deutsch/Getty Images

Caucasian butler holding umbrella for businessman outside car

Jacobs Stock Photography Ltd/Getty Images


H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty Images

The beautiful one

suteishi/Getty Images

Empire Theatre, Broadway, New York City

Bettmann/Getty Images

People Standing On Stage

Stevica Mrdja / EyeEm/Getty Images

Midsection Of Men Discussing On Table

Sarinya Pinngam / EyeEm/Getty Images

Detailed borough map of Manhattan New York city, monochrome vector poster or postcard city street plan aerial view

Maxger/Getty Images

Empty New York Streets

sacha waldman/Getty Images

Businessman talking with client by video call, computer screen view

fizkes/Getty Images

White Paper Sheets

fotograzia/Getty Images

Foley Square in Manhattan, New York City, USA

J2R/Getty Images

Businessman & Secretary

Archive Photos/Getty Images

Ragged Old Paper

fotograzia/Getty Images

1920s italian family portrait

lcodacci/Getty Images

Male 1940s gangster charcater standing by train tracks.

StephM2506/Getty Images

Man talking to a woman, 1951.

Science & Society Picture Library/Getty Images

Man On Phone Sitting At Office Desk Several Papers On Desk Smiling.

H. Armstrong Roberts/Getty Images

Two young businessmen talking at small desk, (B&W)

George Marks/Getty Images

The Man I Killed

Hulton Archive/Getty Images


B/W 1939 person getting into Queens taxi / NYC / documentary

Archive Films/Getty Images

B/W 1927 man panning for gold in bucket of water / Nevada / newsreel

Prelinger/Getty Images

B/W 1926 people in formalwear smoking at dinner table on cruise ship / newsreel

Archive Films/Getty Images

LOW AERIAL, Coastline at sunrise, Andrews Island, Maine, USA

Aerial HD Stock LLC/Getty Images

1958 Black and white low angle close up police station sign for "Missing Persons Bureau"/ AUDIO

Prelinger/Getty Images

Close up 'world premiere' sign on movie theater marquee / Seattle, Washington

Mr. Big Film/Getty Images

Slow motion close up American flag waving in breeze

Rob Sweeney/Getty Images

B/W 1940s high angle traffic on city street with people standing on sides at night / Los Angeles

Petrified Films/Getty Images

B/W 1942 extreme close up man whispering into other man's ear / "Divide and Conquer" (documentary)

Petrified Films/Getty Images

B/W close up man's hands counting stacks of dollar bills on table

Petrified Films/Getty Images

B/W 1930s CANTED close up over-the-shoulder woman's hands dialing early telephone

Petrified Films/Getty Images

1952 close up calendar pages go by

Archive Films/Getty Images

B/W 1939 newsboy runs up to truck, grabs stack of newspapers + starts shouting to sell papers

Archive Films/Getty Images

time lapse sunrise behind silhouettes of buildings / New York City

Mr. Time Lapse/Getty Images

close up PAN of pile of stacks of US money

Hyperfocal Film Co./Getty Images

52nd Season of the Metropolitan Opera House Opens

WPA Film Library/Getty Images

Reenactment, 1929 stock market crash panic

Onyx Media, Llc - Footage/Getty Images

1956 WS Couple sitting in round leather restaurant booth / USA

Curious Cumulus Productions/Getty Images

1940s/1950s MONTAGE B/W Cab driver standing next to and getting into his taxicab/ Greenwood, Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA

Harold Anderson Black Wall Street Collection/Getty Images

1931 B/W MS PAN TD TU Woman passing gun to undercover police officer in nightclub/ Los Angeles, California, USA/ AUDIO

Archive Farms/Getty Images

1967 MONTAGE Man drinking and smoking at bar, Los Angeles, California, USA, AUDIO

L.A. County/Getty Images

"1950s CU Man's hands packing suitcase/ St. Louis, Missouri"

Prelinger/Getty Images

1935 MS POV Car attempting to pass another car on a hill/ Oncoming car forces car back into lane

Prelinger/Getty Images

1937 FILM MONTAGE CU Man kissing wife and walking out door/ WS Man stepping off porch

Prelinger/Getty Images

B/W 1935 group of women climbing into car / doorman closing doors / car driving off / NYC

Prelinger/Getty Images

B/W 1936 high angle man with bathing suit whispering to woman with bathing suit under umbrella on beach

Prelinger/Getty Images

B/W 1935 close up hand of groom placing ring on finger of bride

Halcyon Days/Getty Images

B/W 1933 American Airlines limousine stopping at curb at airport + movie star gets out / industrial

Archive Films/Getty Images

Bank clerk opening the safe deposit box for a female customer taking out her valuables

simonkr/Getty Images

A man's hands count out two piles of twenty dollar bills.

Hearst Newsreel/Getty Images

Ziegfeld girls in costume kick up their legs in unison.

Hearst Newsreel/Getty Images

CU Shot of hand reaching into sack of money

Warner Bros. Studios/Getty Images

1952: BROADWAY: MANHATTAN, NEW YORK: NIGHT: VS West 43rd Street w/ vehicles & pedestrians, storefronts, Time Square BG, police officer on horseback stationed outside Henry Miller's Theatre Broadway show, 'The Moon is Blue.' NYC, Theatre District, play

The March of Time/Getty Images

1937: DRAMATIZATION: Radio announcer reading script into microphone (No SOT). LISTENING TO RADIO: Young adult male sitting by radio making pick list. Group of young adults, CU male finger on newspaper while other male marking pick paper.

The March of Time/Getty Images

Policemen working

The March of Time/Getty Images

1937: POLICE PROCEDURE: EXT Police Station w/ two of three lighted globes. INT Police station w/ dectective frisking male suspect. 'Detective Captain' sign on door. Two detectives at desk questioning seated witness.

The March of Time/Getty Images

Cabs, EXT Clubs

The March of Time/Getty Images

1944 Governors Conference

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

People celebrate prohibition repeal in the US

Onyx Media, Llc - Footage/Getty Images

1930's cars driving. From 1930's movie film

Bruce Hemingway/Getty Images

Power Cut

shironosov/Getty Images

1934 - men, women riding subway standing, swaying as they hang onto straps and read newspapers

Internet Archive/Getty Images

MS ZI Shot of Door of Bureau of Missing Persons

Warner Bros. Studios/Getty Images

Shaking hands

vizualis/Getty Images

MS POV Shot of Manhattan in New York City at night

Warner Bros. Studios/Getty Images

Smart city shoes, businessmen walking in rain. Feet only, rear view.

Dominic Beckham/Getty Images

Customers sitting in bar, Skid Row, Los Angeles, California, USA

Reflex Technologies/Getty Images

Hand-to-hand transfer of a white envelope

Viktar Lameika/Getty Images

A man giving bribe money to another businessman in a corruption scam

Easy_Company/Getty Images

NY Mayor Jimmy Walker in NY City on the night of his re-election

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

Elegant blonde woman beautifully looking into the camera

iD-Stock/Getty Images

Ransom money recovered in Lindbergh baby kidnapping case

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

The legs of a man walking near the cloud of a smoke. slow motion

Viacheslav Peretiatko/Getty Images

Neon Bar Sign

zxvisual/Getty Images

American citizen compares criminals to rats

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

American woman praises Attorney General Homer Cummings

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

1931 Concerned reporter calls area hospitals looking for missing elderly woman

Silverwell Films/Getty Images

Special Prosecutor Thomas E. Dewey fights organized crime in New York City in the 1930s

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

Champagne drinks and bottles

Silverwell Films/Getty Images

Driver's point of view in dark garage

janiecbros/Getty Images

1968 Scared but quick thinking man lights dead zombie on fire in front of attacking zombies

Silverwell Films/Getty Images

Office employee walking down corridor and turing to the left

iD-Stock/Getty Images

Carmarthen by-election

ITN/Getty Images


RubberBall Productions LLC/Getty Images

MONTAGE Housewife reading her shopping list aloud to grocer over telephone, grocer loading goods into box, and another housewife wearing heavy fur coat wandering along city park carrying shopping bundles / England, United Kingdom

BFI HD Collection/Getty Images

1940s MS Two officers sitting in the back seat of a car while one of them writes down information on a pad of paper / United States

Petrified Films/Getty Images

Panning shot of cars driving on street in city, Park Avenue, New York City, New York State, USA

Paramount Pictures/Getty Images

Making two shots of hard liquor

invizbk/Getty Images

Cars leave New York City's Grand Central Station at night in a vintage film.

Paramount Pictures/Getty Images

Lester Brocklehurst and Bernice Felton arraigned in Lonoke County Arkansas for murder

Grinberg, Paramount, Pathe Newsreels/Getty Images

1930's - car driving on driveway front of mansion

Reflex Technologies/Getty Images

Background mask with damaged frame effect of old film with scratches and flicker 4k

Alexander Bashkirov/Getty Images

1940's Panning shot of waiters serving diners in luxury restaurant

Reflex Technologies/Getty Images

1939 High angle view of people buying tickets at Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York State, USA

Reflex Technologies/Getty Images

Dropping ice cubes. Whiskey Being Poured Into A Glass on Black Background. Close Up.

herraez/Getty Images