Children's poem advising little girl not to kill her brother slammed: 'Absolutely disgusting'
A tongue-in-cheek children’s poem which advises a little girl against killing her brother has been blasted as “absolutely disgusting” and “horrifying” by angry moms. They’re demanding that the book in which it appears be pulled from retailers like Costco.
The poem “Brotherly Love” is from No More Poems!: A Book in Verse That Just Gets Worse, which is billed as a Shel Silverstein-inspired, “riotous collection of irreverent poems for modern families” written by musician Rhett Miller of the Old 97’s, with illustrations by Dan Santat.
A screenshot shared by a concerned mom reveals verses referencing different ways — drowning, smothering, etc. — in which the girl might kill her sibling.
“Darling little girl / I know exactly who they’d blame / If you go pouring gasoline / And setting him aflame / You’re much too young to shoulder / Such responsibility / I’m the one they’d car off / To the penitentiary,” reads one verse.
The macabre imagery has caused an uproar. One mom, Kayla Sykes, called on Costco to stop selling the book, which, according to Amazon.com, is targeted at children aged 7 to 10.
“I don’t see how anyone can justify this,” Sykes said in a second post. “Perhaps the author was instructing certain children not to do these things, but he’s also influencing children and teaching children the capabilities of these horrific scenarios. Taking a pillow and smothering someone, setting someone on fire, pushing someone from a window ... these are not normal thoughts. These are not things that enter the heads of my children.
“As a teacher, I understand children on a larger spectrum, and perhaps some have been exposed to these things. There is a potential for ... relatable humor, maybe. But I also have had students that can be easily influenced and manipulated — and just the simple idea of these dark events could make them act (influenced events) out impulsively.”
Many parents have agreed with her, calling the poem’s dark humor “disturbing” and a “bit graphic.”
“I am in total agreement with you,” wrote a mom. “I feel that it was very thought-provoking. Putting sick thoughts in a child’s mind. Very evil as far as I am concerned. I did not find it funny at all.”
Another tweeted that it “made her sick to my stomach.”
"No More Poems” by Rhett Miller & Dan Santat should be sold as an adult book, yet it’s targeted towards children. The poem, “Brotherly Love” literally made me sick to my stomach. The first line is, “Please don’t push your brother out the window.” Our dyslexic kiddos are LITERAL! pic.twitter.com/6MwHLdzm44
— Dyslexia with Ease (@SelaSchneider) April 29, 2019
If you shop at Costco please don’t buy the children’s book “No More Poems.” It includes a horrifying poem on how to kill your younger sibling. I’m not sure how the publisher allowed this to slip by, talk about putting ideas in a kids head. #parenting #momlife #parentingproblems pic.twitter.com/Ar36dAXQrf
— Stephanie ✌🏽 (@Mommin8Easy) April 29, 2019
But other parents have accused critics of overreacting.
“We used to watch Looney Tunes and didn’t murder anyone,” one Facebook commenter argued.
“The Bible has some violent stories in it as well and I read them to my children,” added a mom. “My children haven’t tried to kill their siblings yet.”
“As a teacher, we need to encourage children to think for themselves,” read another comment.
“OMG y’all need help,” one commenter said of the backlash. “Ever read Dr. Seuss? If you didn’t look it up and understand the concept of the book, that's your own fault. Don’t blame stores and authors.”
“Oh, I'm buying it ASAP,” a commenter wrote. “Shel Silverstein was my absolute favorite growing up. This is so up that alley. So sad that we live in a culture now that can't recognize satire in the simplest form. Obviously this is NOT instructions on how to kill your sibling!”
Miller, who wrote the controversial poem, is also citing Silverstein’s influence. He tweeted a verse from the beloved children’s writer’s satirical poem “Little Abigail and the Beautiful Pony,” in which a little girl dies because her parents won’t buy her a pony.
From “Little Abigail And The Beautiful Pony”
By Shel Silverstein
And Abigail felt so bad
That when she got home she went to bed,
And she couldn’t eat,
And she couldn’t sleep,
And her heart was broken,
And she DID die—
All because of a pony
That her parents wouldn’t buy.— Rhett Miller (@rhettmiller) April 29, 2019
He also referenced “getting some vitriol from a humorless few on the internet.”
I woke up today feeling glum after getting some vitriol from a humorless few on the Internet.
But then I went to a mountaintop course and threw my first ever hole-in-one. Sending love and joy to all of you on this beautiful day. pic.twitter.com/NLGhCS0J32— Rhett Miller (@rhettmiller) April 29, 2019
Yahoo Lifestyle has contacted the book’s publisher, Little, Brown and Company, for comment.
Read more from Yahoo Lifestyle:
Mom says judge threatened to take her baby away because she was breastfeeding in the courtroom
Mother says nurse saved her baby’s life on flight: ‘She’s a rock star’
Kim Kardashian mom-shamed over photo of North staring at a phone: 'Give her a book'
Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day.