As Millions Suffer From Unemployment, The Catholic Church Gets $1.4 Billion In Relief Funds

Sarah Midkiff

The U.S. Roman Catholic Church successfully lobbied government officials to make an exception from federal rules to include the church in the Paycheck Protection Program, despite not meeting specific requirements. Because of this exemption, at least $1.4 billion in taxpayer-backed coronavirus aid has been awarded to the church. And, there is reason to believe that the total payout may have exceeded $3.5 billion, making the global religious institution one of the biggest recipients in the U.S. government’s pandemic relief efforts

According to an analysis of federal data conducted by the Associated Press, millions of dollars are “going to dioceses that have paid huge settlements or sought bankruptcy protection because of clergy sexual abuse cover-ups.” Data shows that the majority of the church’s money was approved during the loan program’s first two weeks. However, in that same time, many local businesses were unable to receive loans from the initial $349 billion funding to the program because it was first-come, first-served. In total, nearly 500 loans exceeding $1 million each were approved for Catholic entities. At least eight reached the maximum payout range of $5-10 million. Among the listed recipients are the offices of bishops, major churches, headquarters of leading religious orders, schools, and chapters of catholic charities. 

Faith-based organizations that promote religious beliefs aren’t usually eligible for money from the U.S. Small Business Administration, reports the Boston Globe. When the coronavirus hit and millions became unemployed, Congress made an exception to let faith groups and other nonprofits apply for the Paycheck Protection Program under the same parameters as other businesses. The PPP’s 500-employee cap qualification for applicants would have otherwise meant that many Catholic dioceses would have been ineligible; however, religious groups reportedly lobbied the Trump administration for an exception. 

The Archdiocese of New York, for example, received 15 loans totaling at least $28 million that just goes toward its top executive offices. Forty dioceses that have spent hundreds of millions of dollars over the past few years paying settlements to those coming forward about their experiences of sexual abuse in the church. The AP’s review found that these dioceses were collectively approved for about $200 million, though the total could be higher because the government’s data – released after multiple news outlets sued Congress – didn’t name recipients of loans under $150,000.

The exact amounts are difficult to quantify because the government released only ranges of loan amounts. The Diocesan Fiscal Management Conference reported that about 9,000 Catholic entities received loans. That is nearly three times the number of entities AP could identify, reports the Boston Globe. AP’s analysis showed that 407,900 jobs within the Catholic church and its affiliated organizations were retained with money awarded through the loan program.

“The government grants special dispensation, and that creates a king of structural favoritism,” Micah Schwartzman, a University of Virginia law professor who studied the Paycheck Protection Program told the AP. “And that favoritism was worth billions of dollars.” The PPP was open to all religious groups, and many applied, including evangelical advisers to President Donald Trump and many big-name churches.

At the same time, the U.S. Department of Labor reported unemployment claims have surpassed 44 million since the start of the coronavirus shutdowns. A study conducted by a Columbia University professor estimated that homelessness in the United States could grow as much as 45% in the next year as a result of the coronavirus and its crippling effect on the economy. 

Upon the news breaking, some publicly criticized the payouts claiming that scores of dioceses faced self-inflicted financial pressure as a result of hiding rampant sexual misconduct. 

It is difficult to ascertain the total wealth of the Catholic church, but reported estimates and investigations estimate that just within the United States, the entity is valued at tens of billions.

Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

Here’s When All The COVID-19 Relief Measures End

How Teachers Benefit From The Education Bailout

Celebrities Who Got A PPP Loan From The Government

More From

  • Comfy-Shoe Lovers: Cole Haan’s On Super Sale At Nordstrom Rack

    We’re starting to realize that Cole Haan is kind of a big deal. As we researched a story about the brand’s sleeper-hit status (more on that coming soon), we heard seriously sky-high praise for the heritage footwear imprint. Given this frenzied fandom, we’re now on high alert for any sales or markdowns on the beloved brand’s wares. So when we caught wind of a three-day, 60% off flash sale at Nordstrom Rack, we dropped everything to comb the site for the best deals on Cole Haan's most coveted styles. From an impassioned online reviewer following to a die-hard fanbase right here at Refinery29, Haan-heads that praise its shoes for their chic and practical qualities are everywhere — heralding the brand as “my everything,” “ridiculously good quality,” and “Doc Martens for the workplace.” Reviewers on the company’s website highlight features like “divine cushioning” and aesthetic “wow” factor on everything from its more classic loafers to its newer sleeker sandals and sublimely comfortable street sneakers. This sale will end this Saturday, August 15th — and, if the high levels of Haan-hype are any indication, inventory won’t last long. Click through for the best of the brand’s sought-after styles before they’re gone for good. At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. The product details reflect the price and availability at the time of publication. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?ICYMI, Lululemon's Secret Sale Section Is So CheapVerishop’s Warehouse Sale Is Too Good Not To ShopThe Epic Beauty Deals From Nordstrom's Major Sale

  • Companies Don’t Need To Just Recognize Black Women’s Equal Pay Day — They Need To Do Better

    Black women are severely underpaid, and as we navigate a pandemic that has incited a caustic economic crisis, that harrowing reality burns even more deeply. Last year, LeanIn.org’s 2019 Women in the Workplace study revealed that 44 percent of companies have three or more women in their C-suite. Of those, just 1 in 25 of C-suite executives identified as women of color, while only 58 Black women were reported to be promoted for every 100 entry-level men who receive promotions to manager.  Now, amid the crisis of COVID-19, the bleak narrative continues. In June, 54 percent of Black women reported they were facing some sort of economic hardship — including being laid off from their jobs — amid the rapid rise in unemployment seen in response to the pandemic. And though the economic inequalities captured have long existed, the crisis of this pandemic shines a stark light in a way that makes them especially pronounced. “We know that Black women are twice as likely as white men to have been either laid off, furloughed, or have their hours reduced because of the pandemic, and they’re twice as likely to worry about finding a new job,” Rachel Thomas, Lean In co-founder and CEO, tells R29Unbothered. “And women, especially Black women, are more likely than men to be concerned about paying for basic necessities like rent, medical bills, and groceries.” This is one of many reasons Lean In found this Black Women’s Equal Pay Day, which Thomas notes as “just a chip of a much larger iceberg of systemic issues that Black women face,” to be an especially critical moment to put out an in-depth study about said injustices. Comprised of data based on five years of the organization’s Women in the Workplace research — which is done in partnership with McKinsey & Company — Lean In’s 2020 State of Black Women in Corporate America study serves as a call to action to companies to understand that, if the workplace is to be equal for women, the focus needs to be on those who are most marginalized. “This is a story of Black women facing more barriers, being promoted more slowly, getting less from both managers and senior leaders, less access to senior leaders, less of a sponsorship that opens doors, and then having a worse day-to-day experience because they’re on the receiving end of both racism and sexism,” Thomas states. “That’s double discrimination that creates a unique experience that is morbidly worse.” And it becomes especially difficult to navigate such an unforgiving economic landscape when Black women, who are often breadwinners for their families, are relied upon to cover the necessities of their households, such as rent and groceries — two things whose accessibility have become scarce for many families during a time that profoundly threatens their financial stability. In July, USA Today reported about the economic hardships faced by Black and Latina women, also noting the mental health implications that come with pandemic-induced stressors. Looking at data from a survey commissioned by the Time’s Up Foundation and done by PerryUndem, a research and communication firm, they found that 44 percent of all women are regularly experiencing feelings of distress compared with 31 percent of men. Many women have also reported dealing with other mental health issues such as anxiety as a result of the hardships brought on by the pandemic, including 37 percent of Black women. “When I look at … the number of women who are crying themselves to sleep, that’s the reality of what women are going through as they do the uncompensated care at home and try to figure out what to do with their jobs,” Tina Tchen, head of Time’s Up, told USA Today. “Over the long term, that’s going to take a real toll if we don’t address it.” So how can this be alleviated — at least from a corporate standpoint? As Lean In covers in their latest study, the onus falls upon employers to ensure that those who need the most support — Black women, women of color, women with disabilities, LGBTQ+ women, women who, because of their intersecting identities, are having worse experiences than white women — are being prioritized. “That really requires company leaders saying, ‘We’re explicitly focusing on advancing Black women and here’s why,’” and approaching said focus with an intersectional lens, says Thomas. “Very few companies look at representation and set targets or goals for themselves at the intersection of gender and race, so they know how many women they have at every level versus men, they know how many people of color they have at every level versus white people, but they don’t know how many women of color and Black women they have at every level,” Thomas continues. “If you want to do better by women, do better by Black women, and that means explicitly saying you’re focusing on Black women.” Check out key findings from Lean In’s 2020 State of Black Women in Corporate America study below, then read the report in its entirety here. – Starting at just 16, Black girls are paid less than boys who are the same age. – On average, Black women in the U.S. are paid 38 percent less than white men, and 21 percent less than white women. – Black women are paid just $0.61 cents for every $1 that a white man makes, while white women are paid $0.79. – Black women who have Bachelor’s degrees or other advanced degrees face an even larger pay gap. – 53 percent of Americans are unaware of the pay gap that exists between Black women and white women. Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Today Is Black Women's Equal Pay DayWhy Black Women Still Face Workplace InequityIt’s Black Women’s Equal Pay Day

  • OPI Just Dropped Its Fall Nail Collection — & Every Shade Is Bellissima

    Following the success of OPI's 2019 fall collection — inspired by the moss greens of an idyllic Scottish countryside — the just-released 2020 assortment brings us to a new global locale: Milan, Italy. Beyond the rich shades inspired by recognizable Italian tones, the color story woven through this destination assortment feels especially meaningful in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, which disproportionally impacted Milan's Lombardy region. "Last year, before the pandemic hit, we traveled to Milan to source inspiration for this collection," explains OPI Co-Founder Suzi Weiss-Fischmann. "We ate fresh pasta, spent hours walking the city streets, and drank Campari while admiring the incredible street style. Of course, at the time, we had no idea the hardships Milan would soon face. But through this collection, we pay homage to the magical city that showed its loving spirit, even at the height of the coronavirus outbreak." From a pearlescent blue inspired by balcony choirs to a burgundy sourced from Italian wine, scroll ahead for 12 new shades that will transport you to a balmy fall evening in Milan, and bring some joy to your fingertips in the process. At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?The Mismatched Manicure Trend Just Got An UpgradeMeghan Markle's Bridal Mani-Pedi Broke TraditionCharli & Dixie D'Amelio Launch Nail Polish Collab

  • An Astrologer Analyzes Joe Biden & Kamala Harris’s Chance Of Winning The Election

    If you’re anything like me, you look to the stars to find meaning in all events that occur in the world. The 2020 Presidential Election is no different. When Kamala Harris was picked as Joe Biden’s running mate, I was excited — and I took a look at her chart (and his) to peep the deets of what’s to come, politically. Kamala Harris was born on October 20, 1964 at 9:28 p.m. in Oakland, CA. She came into the world during the Full Moon in Aries, which means she has a Libra Sun and an Aries Moon. Her Sun-Moon opposition means that she is a purveyor of truth, justice, peace — and she won’t stop on this pursuit until she achieves her goals. Her Gemini ascendent means that she’s very open to growth and bringing people together. Her opinions are based on facts and truths. As a leader, she’s fair-minded, passionate, and someone who wants to change the world through universal healing. Joe Biden was born on November 20, 1942 at 8:30 a.m. in Scranton, PA. He was born during a Waxing Full Moon, which means the Moon was just about to be at its peak luminescence. Like Harris, Biden is a person who cares about the people of the world. He’s not a person who puts politics first; he genuinely wants to help others (which is probably why he entered politics in the first place). As I took a gander at their charts separately, I marveled at their synastry  (aka their relationship astrology, a comparison of their birth charts). Their ascendants are in opposite signs to each other. This means that they were born to be in each other’s lives. They compensate for each other’s qualities and flaws — especially when it comes to their political and public views. Being that they are both born on Full Moons and Waning Full Moons, they have larger-than-life personalities which may add flavor to their candidacy together. Harris’s North Node of Destiny in Sagittarius falls on his ascendant in Sagittarius, which means that their pairing is fated in the stars. Regardless of your political leanings, astrologically speaking, Harris and Biden are literally the ideal pair to run together in the upcoming election.I also worked up a birth chart for the public announcement that was made about their decision to run together in the election, their “event chart.” This is also known as electional astrology, and was famously used by Ronald Reagan in the 1980s to use them to map out the safest times for public announcements after his assassination attempt.Their chart is very fortunate. The announcement came at 4:15 p.m. EST on August 11, 2020, during the Last Quarter Moon, which is the ideal time to make a transformative announcement. The Sun was in passionate Leo, the Moon was in charming Taurus, and the ascendant was in expansive Sagittarius. > Regardless of your political leanings, astrologically speaking, Harris and Biden are literally the ideal pair to run together in the upcoming election.In an event chart, astrologers only really look at the placements and signs of the Moon, the ascendant, and the Sun. In Biden and Harris’s chart, the Sun is strong in Leo and the Moon is at its best in Taurus, in the fifth house of self-expression. The ruler of the ascendant is Jupiter, which is located in the first house. This will yield a positive outcome. At the time Harris announced her run for VP, her Sun was in the Midheaven of the event chart, which means she’s making a very public statement that will alter her life forever. Transiting Saturn was squaring her natal Sun and Moon. Known as the karmic taskmaster of the zodiac, Saturn — who is retrograde in Capricorn — was telling her to boss up and accept her new role, even if it’s awkward and uncomfortable to be sprung into the public like that. The transiting Nodes of Destiny were gracefully galvanizing her natal Sun and Moon, and the North Node of Destiny was on her ascendent. This tells us that she’s meant to shine now. Does she have a chance at winning the election? This question yields an interesting answer. Transiting Neptune is backpedaling through her natal Midheaven in Pisces until November 28. There will be uncertainty about what endeavors she wishes to support. Still, this Neptune placement allows one to enchant others with their words; people will be drawn to Harris’s charisma. She is also having a nodal opposition this year, meaning the Nodes of Destiny oppose each other. This transit brings luck, which could be an indicator that her campaign will be successful. Another good sign: On Election Day, the Moon will be in Gemini, on Harris’s ascendant, and on the transiting North Node of Destiny. The Moon, however, will be on her natal South Node, which can indicate an emotional loss. Still, it’s my professional opinion that this team has a high chance of winning the election. Both of their charts support a win — particularly hers, which indicates that Biden made a smart pick if he hopes to crush the election. The only caveat is that she needs to be clear on their incentives. If she’s decisive, then her chances are high. This isn’t a grand slam win, but their odds are looking up. Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Susan Miller Tried To Warn Us About Wedding SeasonUranus Retrograde Will Finally Bring Us LiberationKamala Harris' Record As A Prosecutor, Explained