"I Realized I Was Happier Without Her": Men Are Revealing When They Discovered They Needed To Break-Up With Their Girlfriends

Note: This post contains mentions of domestic violence and emotional abuse.

As many of us have probably realized in life, breakups can be complicated, and relationships can be heartbreaking.

Fox Searchlight Pictures / Via giphy.com

While that's not always the case, of course, u/lukegum69 reminded the internet of this when they asked men, "What made you realize your girlfriend isn’t the one for you?" Many men responded, so here are some of the responses that really stood out:

1."My last ex always wanted to go do her own thing, and expected me to just drop my life and go with her wherever it was. If she wanted to move across the state for a university, she expected me to come along and get an apartment close-by, or I could stay behind with no guarantee it would work between us. She never asked how I felt about her plans. It was just her way or no way. I always had this feeling that if I didn't give her attention every ten minutes that she'd want to get it from someone else. I didn't treat her wrongly or act as a controlling guy by any means, it was just a gut feeling I had that I hated."

Ripped photograph of a heterosexual couple

"Now that I'm married, she still tries to contact me and tell me she loves me and wants me back. It's like she really started trying after it was too late."


Jamie Grill / Getty Images/Tetra images RF

2."She invited me over to cook for me, and instead ambushed me with her 8 friends to interrogate my feelings in the relationship."


3."I had an ex girlfriend who tricked me into meeting her parents. I would gladly meet them if she invited me, but she faked a panic attack so I would take her home and her parents were in on it. Seems silly but looked like a sign of deeper issues so I walked away and, seeing the kind of relationships she developed with other guys after me, I’d say it was the right call."


"My ex did this to me, too. She told me to come hang out with her one weekend. I was like, cool — a day of watching Star Trek, good food, and some 'afternoon delight.' I show up and her entire extended family was there. They made me hold a baby. I'm naturally very awkward around new people, so they all thought I was weird. I could tell my girlfriend wasn't very happy about the poor impression I made. Well, there's a reason I didn't want to meet your family dude."


FOX / Via giphy.com

4."When she asked for a dude's number at a party while I left for a minute. I caught her in the act and she still lied about it..."


5."I started to realize I was happier when she wasn't around."


6."Shortly after waking from anesthesia from a major surgery, and after being administered a high dose of oxycodone, I was discharged from the hospital. As we got to my car, she turned around and asked if I wouldn't mind driving and threw me the keys. Being completely under the influence, I obliged. I drove us the 45 minutes home. After the drugs wore off, I realized she's not the one."

Young man with his hand in his head outside the car window looking worried

"During the eight-week recovery she was moody and mean and was totally dismissive of the challenges I experienced as part of recovery which was incredibly painful."


Skynesher / Getty Images

7."She told me she never, ever wanted to meet my kids. She came up with a plan that once we moved in together, she could stay at her parents house during my weekends with them. At the time, we had only been together for little over a month. I broke up with her before she took her next breath."


8."I grew out of a certain genre of music and moved on to other genres that I reckon she didn't really like. She asked 'Why can't you still like folk and country?' It struck me then that she didn't really love me for who I was. She liked me because I fit this archetype of what she wanted in a partner, and instead of growing herself, she chose to be mad at me for breaking what she wanted in a partner. She ended up cheating on me, with the dude that I gave my old CDs too."

<div><p>"In the end, I feel that I was released of two burdens." </p><p><b>—</b><a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMen/comments/s8hudw/comment/htgke2x/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank" data-ylk="slk:u/BobsRealReddit" class="link "><b>u/BobsRealReddit</b></a></p></div><span> Kentannenbaum / Getty Images/iStockphoto</span>

"In the end, I feel that I was released of two burdens."


Kentannenbaum / Getty Images/iStockphoto

9."I dated a girl for two years, and nothing I ever did was good enough for her. She became very controlling and did not want me to hang out with my friends, unless she was there. I finally got tired of the negativity and broke it off. Turned out all my family and friends hated her with a passion and were so happy when it ended."


10."I realized she could never be supportive or be there for me when I needed her, like when I had to put my dog down. An hour after it happened, she freaked out at me accusing me that I tortured my dog because I had wanted to take the night to see if things would improve. Obviously that wasn't true, but her anxiousness made her react that way — that was how she reacted to anything that wasn't rainbows and sunshine. She basically accused me of torturing my best friend right after losing her. Felt real good."


11."My friend was helping me fix my car and saving me a ton of money in the process. It was a hot summer day and we were both stranded until it was running again. I asked if she would bring us by some lemonade or whatever, and she said, 'No. This isn’t the 1950s.' So I said, 'We don’t do things for each other? I would do that for you.' And she hit me back with, 'Well that’s traditionally the woman’s role, so I’m not doing it, and I’m unhappy you asked me to do that. I’m not something you can control for your friends.' That hurt because I always went out of my way for her."

The undercarriage of a car with a pair of legs at the rear of the vehicle
Rapideye / Getty Images/iStockphoto

12."My ex once grieved for two years over her childhood dog dying. I was there for her and never minimized it. But when my dad died, it was only a few months before she was saying, 'It's been six months already!'"


13."She treated waitstaff, cashiers, and all other customer service people like shit. It was embarrassing how rude and condescending she could be. We didn’t last long at all."

Couple on a date at an outdoor restaurant, and the women is complaining to the waitress
Innovatedcaptures / Getty Images/iStockphoto

14."Anger issues are one thing but having a full-blown screaming temper tantrum when she didn't get her way was the last straw for me. The first time it happened, it lasted almost an hour and it only subsided because I called her dad and had her speak to him. That should have been the warning flag I needed but I'm patient and chill and believe in second chances. She apologized for her behavior too, so I thought maybe she would change. Then a few months later, temper tantrum again. This time a full out screaming match with both of her parents that lasted for over two and a half hours. I wasn't even involved but I knew at that moment I didn't want to be involved with a woman or a family that communicates like toddlers. Fuck that. My life has been so much more stress free since. She had a lot of great qualities, but that was one I couldn't overlook."


15."She faked a pregnancy scare just to 'test' me."

Channel 4 / Via giphy.com


16."When she came home from work, the sound of the front door opening made me feel annoyance instead of happiness. I realized that I'd felt this way for months and it never dawned on me. We broke up a few weeks later."


17."She didn’t want to come to any of my family functions, and she stopped sleeping in the same bed as me. We had sex maybe ten times in a span of the three years that we lived together. The last straw: apparently we started 'buying our own groceries' — I opened a new bag of bread that she bought and she snapped at me, even though I was paying 80% of the rent and utilities."

Sponge cake with &#39;hands off&#39; sign on a post-it note

"I came home from work that day and broke up with her." —u/xbiggz

Moodboard / Getty Images/moodboard RF

18."I kept waking up with a gut feeling that I shouldn't be in that relationship. Every morning and every night, a gut feeling screamed at me. I couldn't explain it, but I understood what I was feeling if that makes sense. It's not that she did or said anything wrong. It was just a natural gut feeling telling me what I didn't want to hear: that I couldn't see her in my future."

<div><p>"I was heartbroken, and two years later am very much alone. But I did what I had to do, and that was doing the right thing by ending it when my head and heart were not in it. I can only imagine she is doing just fine without me. It ended with mutual respect, so it was a clean break of sorts."</p><p><b>—</b><a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMen/comments/s8hudw/comment/htgfras/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank" data-ylk="slk:u/Immediate_Reality357" class="link "><b>u/Immediate_Reality357</b></a></p></div><span> Photoalto / Getty Images/PhotoAlto</span>

"I was heartbroken, and two years later am very much alone. But I did what I had to do, and that was doing the right thing by ending it when my head and heart were not in it. I can only imagine she is doing just fine without me. It ended with mutual respect, so it was a clean break of sorts."


Photoalto / Getty Images/PhotoAlto

19."My ex made fun of me for pleasure reading. She would lay in bed next to me watching Jersey Shore or some other reality TV show, then would complain that I was wasting time reading. She even went so far as to make fun of the books I was reading and me for reading them."

MTV / Via giphy.com

"Years later my wife finally asked me why I won’t allow us to put a TV in the bedroom. She had gone along with if for years, and when I told her, she’s never asked about it again."


20."I broke up with someone after two years because they would always drink and drive. I couldn’t take the thought of them killing themselves, or another person. I hated never knowing if they were safe."

Young woman staring into space behind the wheel of a car with her nose resting on the wheel

"It still trips me up sometimes and I still love them and wish them the best."


Image Source / Getty Images/Image Source

21."When my grandma was diagnosed with cancer and I needed someone to talk to, she blew it off to talk about a party she was going to instead. I called someone else and they talked me off the ledge. I realized then that my girlfriend was selfish, self-absorbed, and emotionally unavailable. I broke up with her three days later after six years. There were plenty of other signs along the way, but that was the straw that broke the camel's back."


22."After maybe a year or two, it just kinda felt like things had run their course. There wasn't much excitement anymore. We discussed some issues we were having, but didn't really change to fix it."

A boyfriend washes the dishes in the kitchen as his annoyed girlfriend storms out


"Currently like this with my wife. Been together for 13 years. Relationship is just meh. We work well together though and we always get comments on how well our kids behavior. Behind closed doors though we are just roommates."


Wong Fu Productions / Via youtube.com

23."Having to explain all of my jokes because she just didn't get them. Not being able to share humor with the person that you're with is such a deal breaker for me."


24."She'd get drunk and throw adult temper tantrums. She caused scenes at parties constantly. I'm the opposite and a very happy drunk. It was just bad energy."


25."I caught her cheating, twice, with the guy at work she started talking about a lot every day after work. Like, a lot. She'd talk about how he said or did this funny thing, blah blah blah. I caught them sexting because she left her laptop on and connected to WhatsApp in Firefox. I had the day off of work and it was dinging over and over."

Opened Laptop Notebook On Black Table With Mobile Phone And Notes Against Window At Home

"I was stupid, so decided to try and make it work between us. She broke down about two months later and pointed a kitchen knife at me, saying she couldn't take how guilty I make her feel every day."


Galina Zhigalova / Getty Images/EyeEm

26."She convinced herself that she's one of those people who should be alone. 'Forever.' She punctuated it just like that in a text, 15 minutes before breaking up with me."


27."She tried to drown me in a river. We were drinking by a river and the boys conspired to steal the girls’ alcohol cooler. My friends made a distraction while I grabbed and ran off with the cooler. Sprinting in waist-high water is exhausting. Once I managed to get the cooler to the boys’ raft, I was completely out of gas and just sort of laid down into the water. Where I was at, the water was chest-high. As I was coming up for air, I felt her hands on my face and chest holding me under. At first I was like, 'she’s joking, she’ll let me up soon.' Then I started to run out of breath. Under normal circumstances, I would have been able to throw her off, but my muscles were starting to go limp. She was super angry because, unbeknownst to me, the cooler contained the only kind of alcohol she could drink because of her mild gluten allergy."

High angle view of people on boats in river

"With everything I had left, I shoved her off. I’ll never forget the look of rage on her face when I surfaced. She eventually calmed down and became very apologetic. I foolishly accepted her apology because I’m a dude and a 120 lbs. woman can’t really hurt me right? Two years and dozens of bruises, bite marks and scratches later, I finally realized how wrong that kind of thinking is."


Florin Baumann / Getty Images/EyeEm

28."We took shrooms together and it amplified some feelings of doubt I had about her. The next day we called it quits."


29."She cooked all of my food without spices to make me think I had COVID so I wouldn't go anywhere."

TLC / Via giphy.com


30."I go to a support group every Tuesday, and one night I was famished coming home so I picked up some food. I also ordered some for her too because y'know, I wanted to be nice. I came home, gave her the food I brought her, and she went ballistic. 'Why didn't you dine with me?! Do you not love me anymore? Why don't you think of me!!!' What is so wrong with me wanting to dine when I'm hungry? And then another time, she woke me up in the middle of the night to say that she checked through my messages and didn't find anything incriminating."

"We haven broken up yet, but I know I will sometime soon."


31."She always wanted people around. Like someone would call her or text her and she'd invite them over. Someone would come over to watch the game, and she'd invite them to stay the night at our house. Or a cousin of a cousin of a friend of a cousin is getting married, and my ex would want to host a wedding brunch even though she only met this person once eight years ago at some random labor day cookout. A new co-worker moved to our city for the job and even though they don't work closely with my ex, she'd invite the co-worker, his wife, kids, and pets over for the weekend."

Fizkes / Getty Images/iStockphoto

32."When I got divorce papers in the mail while I was living in a blown out building in Samawah, Iraq, guarding two bridges so the 3rd Infantry Division could cross to go to Baghdad. She was pregnant with another man's kid. We were together for four years."


33."She wasn't able to compromise or apologize. I spent years dwelling on the thought that I was responsible for the decline of our relationship, but I realized the things that were happening to me were early signs of emotional abuse. I still try to forgive and move on by keeping what happened in the past, but often when I talk to her, I get reminded of the things that were happening and could have happened for a lifetime."

"Don't let anyone demand that you put aside your needs for them and then make you feel like you're at cause."


34."I was at my cousin's wedding and looking up at the altar and tried to picture my partner and myself there. We had been dating quite a while, it was the end of college, and I knew that marriage would be the next step soon. But I just couldn't see it. It didn't make sense to me. And that was the end."

Jack Quaid as Ben looks at couple getting married as Alice, played by Maya Eskrine, rests her head on his shoulder

35."I wanted to go hang out with my friends for a couple hours. At that point, we had been in the same apartment for two months and were always with each other. As I was about to leave, she made sure I could hear her crying. I ended up not seeing my friends again before the COVID lockdown."


36."She never initiated sex. And when she did accept my advances, it was kinda obvious it was a chore for her."

Shirtless man on bed sits far away from his partner, looking dejected
Delmaine Donson / Getty Images

37."She enjoyed doing just about everything, but wasn't passionate about anything. Like we could talk, but it was never in depth. There was no excitement. Over time, I realized it was because she wasn't a critical thinker. She wouldn't dig into an experience and analyze it. She'd do something, experience it, and move on — she didn't want more or less from it. She was a great person, super chill, but I lost interest in talking to her because there were never any further questions or insights."

FilmDistrict / Via giphy.com

"I could've been talking to a wall and came out with a similar experience, so things ended."


38."When she tried to delete the message thread of my friend that passed away because I spent too much time 'thinking' about him."


39."I had an ex that kept telling me I was bad in bed. There was always something wrong. At first it was, 'your dick's too small,' then 'sex doesn't last long enough,' and so on. Always complaining. She wanted us to see a sexologist, and even the sexologist was like 'Well, you are having orgasms...' Anyways, I'm glad she's an ex."

Hand of woman holding baby carrot
Dmitriy Bilous / Getty Images/Tetra images RF

40."She misspelled my name on her Christmas card to me. I'd known her for over a decade."


41."I was with one woman for seven years, and she completely changed the way I dressed, my hair, the music I listened to, I even stopped playing video games which I loved. I would see my family for 15 min on a Sunday morning, then spend the rest of the entire day with her family because she found my family ‘loud.' She was mentally abusive, to say the least. Every time I ‘annoyed' her, she wouldn’t talk to me for days on end so that I had time to ‘think about what I'd done.' After seven years together and arguing weekly, I walked."


42."I realized she couldn't make a decision without running it by her mom first. Anything more complicated than where to go to eat or what to do for date night, her mom was consulted. And nine out of ten times, she did what her mom said. I finally left when we were about to move in together. After going on our eighth apartment tour, we picked a place we liked and applied. Then, she backed out because her mom said she didn't think the place was a good idea."

Senior mother interfering with couple having argument at home sitting at table
Monkeybusinessimages / Getty Images/iStockphoto

43."When all my friends and family were telling me to get out of the relationship. My ex is a good person and we had a great two years together, but I increasingly found myself making big sacrifices while she never moved out of her comfort zone."

"If all your friends are telling you to break up with someone, listen carefully."


44."It took finding another person who I felt a stronger connection with to acknowledge it, though I probably knew she wasn't 'the one' for a long time beforehand. So, I’m the bad one in that relationship that wasted her time."

Young groom getting dressed on his wedding day in a traditional Indian wedding outfit
Marco Vdm / Getty Images

When did you realize that it was time to break up with your own partner? Which of these responses resonated with you? Drop your thoughts in the comments.

Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.