The Insurrection Act Is A Historic Tool For Racist Violence — No Wonder Trump Likes It

Sarah Midkiff

On the seventh evening of protests sparked by the death of George Floyd, President Donald Trump was set to address the press and the people in the White House Rose Garden. In the minutes leading up to his address, reportedly peaceful protestors were doused with tear gas and hit with flash-bang explosions by police, before the city’s 7 p.m. curfew, in order to clear a path for Trump to walk to St. John’s Episcopal Church to pose with a Bible. Then, during his speech, the president vowed to end “the riots and lawlessness.” Hw called protestors “thugs,” and threatened to invoke a centuries-old law that allows him to deploy the U.S. military known as the Insurrection Act.

“If a city or state refuses to take the actions that are necessary to defend the life and property of their residents, then I will deploy the United States military and quickly solve the problem for them,” said Trump in his short statement before he made his way to his photo-op.

The protestors which Trump denounced were gathered in response to the police killing of George Floyd and other unarmed Black people. But the moment where officials charged at demonstrators to pave room for Trump’s announcement that he will institute the Insurrection Act felt surreal, and left a lot of questions about what this meant and how far the president was willing to go to stop the Black Lives Matter movement.

It’s been centuries time since the Insurrection Act first came into law. In 1807, President Thomas Jefferson signed the Insurrection Act in an effort to squash civil disorder and rebellion. The Act gives the sitting president authority to deploy the military within the United States and was last used in 1992 to suppress the Los Angeles riots which erupted after four white police officers were acquitted for the brutal beating of Rodney King, a Black man, that was caught on video. It was also used during the 1968 riots sparked by the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.

The law’s clear history of attacks on racial movements have left many wondering what kind of violence this would insight if enacted. There are some caveats, however, such as a section which states that in order for a president to deploy troops without the direct request from a state’s governor, they must make an announcement ordering protestors to disperse within a limited timeframe. Without such a proclamation, Trump cannot move forward with his unilateral decision.

Governors were quick to express their disagreement. Shortly after Trump’s comments, Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker told CNN: “I reject the notion that the federal government can send troops into the state of Illinois. The fact is that the president has created an incendiary moment here. He wants to change the subject from his failure over coronavirus, a miserable failure and now see a moment when there’s unrest because of the injustice that was done to George Floyd that he now wants to create another topic and something where he can be the law and order president.”

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, who has dealt with numerous verbal attacks from Trump, also issued a statement following a call between Trump and governors across the country: “The president’s danger comments should be gravely concerning to all Americans, because they send a clear signal that this administration is determined to sow the seeds of hatred and division, which I fear will only lead to more violence and destruction. We must reject this way of thinking.”

Though many states with active protests have issued curfews, Trump has made no formal announcement demanding protestors disperse and go home by a specific time. Advocates who have spoken out against Trump’s Insurrection threat say that the message of this particular act, and the history of when it’s been instituted, is a clear attack on activism in defense of Black lives in America.

Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

The Real Reason Trump Is Afraid Of ANTIFA

What The White House Blackout Says About Trump

Twitter Labels Trump's "THUGS" Glorified Violence

More From

  • Amy Schumer Wants To Help You Learn How To Use A Tampon

    “It took me years before I understood that you’re supposed to press it in all the way in until you don’t feel it,” Amy Schumer tells me over the phone. “I didn’t even know if I was supposed to leave the applicator in.”She’s talking about tampons. “You know, if you don’t have that older sister, or that best friend who has an older sister, or that super-cool mom… A lot of people never learned how to apply a Tampax. It’s like, trial and error. I don’t remember anyone teaching me,” the stand-up comedian says.It’s a funny and relatable thing for Schumer to be sharing, and it reminds me of my own now-hilarious, then-angst-ridden fumblings with my first tampon. Learning how to use one involved tears, hands-on instruction from my mother (I guess she qualifies as a super-cool mom), a compact mirror, and a looming deadline in the form of an end-of-year class trip to the beach.But the implications of both of our stories are, well, kind of sad. Read between the lines, and it’s clear that neither of us learned how to use a tampon at school as part of a sexual health education curriculum. And that’s why Schumer’s teamed up with Tampax on their new TimeToTampax period education campaign, which aims to normalize conversations about periods — in part by airing a series of funny-but-informational videos. As of June 2020, public schools in just 30 U.S. states (and DC) are required to teach sex ed; about 17 of those require the content to be medically accurate (a definition that varies by state), according to the Guttmacher Institute. The lack of information is part of the reason people feel embarrassed about their periods. It can also contribute to a stigma around menstruation that’s actively harmful.“When we don’t offer even the basic information, like where to get a pad or how to use a tampon, we leave girls feeling scared and unprepared when they start their first period. Avoiding conversations during these pivotal development years leads to shame and embarrassment that extends well into our adult years, often causing self-esteem and relationship problems,” says Lyndsey Harper, MD, OB/GYN, founder and CEO of sexual wellness company Rosy.Mary Jane Minkin, MD, OB/GYN, professor at Yale School of Medicine, says that menstrual education should include myth busting — women should be told that using a tampon doesn’t make you not a virgin, for instance, which she says many young women mistakenly believe. “I would also emphasize that if periods do become uncomfortable that the person should not be afraid to speak with someone, because there are things that one can do to help,” she says.Dr. Harper likes resources including The Period Game, an educational board game about menstruation. Most of all, she says, it’s important to talk more openly about periods — without using cutesy code words or whispers. “Don’t make periods ‘a thing,’” she says. “Use the words tampon, pad, and periods in everyday language. Have positive conversations about these products, and use them as an approachable tool to educate girls and boys about puberty, health, and the magic of our reproductive systems.”Talking more openly about periods is the first step in breaking down the stigma that harms so many people. So when Schumer, for instance, talks about how much she loves period underwear or jokingly proposes sending “tamp pics” in Growing, her 2019 Netflix special, it’s not just funny — it’s kind of groundbreaking.“I’ve never felt shame about having my period, and I’ve always been really passionate about not feeling shame about it. It’s been really upsetting to me to see that other women, even women that I’m close to, feel shame connected to it,” she says, toward the end of our call. “I’m hoping to be more people’s older sister, and explain what took me so many years to learn.”Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?"The Crown" Is Cutting This Royal Tampon StoryAmy Schumer & Whitney Cummings On Chris D'EliaiMercury Retrograde Might Be Coming For Your Period

  • Square Toe Sandals Might Be Our Favorite ’90s-Inspired Trend

    Anymore, it feels impossible to look around without getting the feeling that the '90s have taken over. From mini skirt suits à la Cher Horowitz to Kelly Kapowski-inspired scrunchies, you'd be hard-pressed to avoid slipping past '90s fashion trends of late. So instead of hiding from the past, we've decided to embrace the era full force. First stop: square-toe shoes. If you're still wearing round toes, you're so stuck in the '00s. With the help of indie shoe brands like Rafa, By Far, and Loq, the square toe sandal has gone through a major revamp. These aren't the Nine West strappy heels you'll find sitting on a shelf at your local vintage shop (okay, maybe they kind of are). Since the new square toe heel inception, dozens of new designer takes on this vintage-inspired trend have popped up from the likes of Bottega Veneta and Neous. Basically, square toe shoes are beloved by all, despite their origins. Since you may not be convinced of bucket hats and tracksuits quite yet, the 23 sandals ahead will give you all the throwback vibes you need to master the era in style. At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?16 Black-Owned Swimsuit Brands To Shop This SummerHow Poofy Dresses Became Summer's Go-To Silhouette31 Looks To Jumpstart Your Summer Style

  • Bridal Masks & Taffeta Bows Reign Supreme At Giambattista Valli

    It is day two of fashion’s first-ever virtual couture week, and while the much-anticipated occasion is only just beginning, Giambattista Valli is already strides ahead of its fellow brands. For the Italian designer’s fall ‘20 haute couture collection, Valli dressed supermodel Joan Smalls in 18 gowns, each one bigger and more tulle-adorned than the one before. The collection was Giambattista Valli at its finest, with petticoat-like bubble waists, voluminous skirts, and plenty of dresses of the mini variety, most of which include an eye-catching train and a taffeta bow to boot.Mixed in with a palette of pastel pinks, reds, and blacks are five ivory ensembles perfect for brides-to-be. For the final look (which is often a bridal one in couture), he designed a polka dot-like embroidered veil — secured with a black silken bow — that blankets the accompanying strapless gown and its three-tiered skirt. Smalls also models a two-piece look which includes a taffeta bow bodice paired with a sweeping waterfall skirt, a delicate tulle mini dress with a similar bow centerpiece, and a vintage-inspired ivory number that could easily double as a couture nightgown with the right pair of satin slippers.His fifth white look featured a face covering fit for the modern bride who wants to take COVID-19 safety precautions: a silk chiffon headpiece with cutouts around the eyes. For any non-brides looking to participate, the accessory also appears in red, pink, and black. It’s not exactly PPE, but it’s very pretty.According to the show notes, this season’s collection is an ode to the city where it was conceived, or as Valli calls it, “La Ville Lumière.” The red gowns are meant to mimic the lipstick left around the rim of empty café cups, while black is an ode to iconic LBDs. Pink represents the city’s many rose gardens, and white symbolizes French architecture, specifically the decorative white molding present in most Parisian apartments. Like us, Valli’s been inside for most of 2020, appreciating the indoor spaces that surround him and dreaming of the beautiful city he recalls from simpler times. “In the horror of what we’re passing through, there was beauty blooming at the same time,” the designer told Vogue, a lesson that he brought to life for fall ‘20. Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?The Giambattista Valli x H&M Collection Is HereThe Giambattista Valli X H&M Lookbook Is HereH.E.R. Is The New Face Of Giambattista Valli x H&M

  • 50 Black-Owned Fashion Businesses To Support

    This story was originally published on June 1, 2020. The fashion industry has a long history of exploiting Black creatives — and it’s not a problem that only exists in the past. While some of today’s most prominent fashion designers are Black — including Kerby Jean-Raymond of Pyer Moss, Aurora James of Brother Vellies, Carly Cushnie of Cushnie, and Christopher John Rogers — they don't always have the same support. As James noted in a recent Instagram post, it is imperative for both long-established brands and everyday consumers to do the work of helping Black-owned businesses. James calls for brands like Net-A-Porter, Target, Whole Foods, Sephora, and Saks Fifth Avenue to commit to buying 15% of their products from Black-owned businesses, explaining that companies of this magnitude have the power to offset existing racial disparities — they just have to use it.  As important as it is for corporations to support and encourage Black-owned businesses, it’s just as crucial that we as consumers also uplift the Black fashion community. Ahead, we’re helping you put your money where your supportive Instagram post is, by highlighting Black-owned businesses where we love to shop and think you should, too.  To help bring attention to the police killing of George Floyd, you can sign the Change.org petition here, or donate to local organizations like Black Vision Collective or Reclaim the Block via the Minnesota Freedom Fund here.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Brands Lay Out Plans To Help The Black CommunityThis Is What Real Allyship Looks Like10 Books About Race You Should Be Reading