This Gucci Mascara Is Like Falsies in a Tube

Gucci Beauty isn’t afraid to cause a stir. When the brand relaunched under creative director Alessandro Michele in the spring of 2019, it put out bold ’80s-style ads that showcased not only its beautiful new lipsticks but also model Dani Miller’s imperfect teeth. The comments section was a mix of reactions both criticizing and praising the images, and almost a year later the brand launched its first-ever mascara, which once again had the internet divided.

One of the images in the campaign for the Gucci Mascara L’Obscur was a close-up of Miller’s eyelashes, which were covered in a clumpy coat of mascara to the point of looking like spider legs. I’m personally extremely into it, but the comments were divided. While there were tons of heart, prayer-hand, and fire emojis, there were also comments accusing the brand of joking or telling it to “rethink the concept”—plus spider emojis galore.

Personally, I find Gucci to be one of the most interesting makeup brands in the current market. I love the subversive advertising paired with the traditionally feminine packaging, and it feels as though the brand is actually doing something fresh and cool in an oversaturated space. I’m also obsessed with mascara, so I was excited to put L’Obscur to the test for Glamour's Beauty Awards and see what all the fuss is about.

It’s impossible to talk about Gucci Mascara L’Obscur without mentioning the packaging. The pink and gold is beautiful and feminine, the tube is extremely heavy so it truly feels expensive, and I love the way the etched cap matches some of the lipstick cases. The brush is much smaller than I expected, with tiny rubber bristles and a pointed tip that’s designed to grab the smallest lashes at the top and bottom corners of your eyes, which also lengthens and separates, so you can get a minimal look or really load it on.

Gucci global makeup artist Thomas de Kluyver likes to use the brush to create two distinct looks, which he demonstrated on the brand’s Instagram. For the classic look—traditional length and separation—he recommends holding the brush horizontally and sweeping it through your lashes.

For the punk-rock-inspired bold look, start with the classic look, then apply another coat, this time holding the brush vertically and loading product onto clumps of lashes. No matter which look you try, know that it will stay put. The brand claims its mascara wears for up to 12 hours and “is near impossible to smudge, flake, feather, or migrate once dry.”

I started with the classic look and applied a few coats, holding the brush horizontally as usual. It’s easy to build up volume with no clumps, and my super-short lashes touched my eyebrows, which never happens. I love the way it fans out my lashes so they look super full, and the tiny brush grabs every single lash so it looks like I’m blessed with Disney Princess–level lashes. Despite being inky black, it didn’t smudge or flake, and I got tons of compliments on my lashes, which again, never happens.

The classic look

bella gucci

The classic look
Bella Cacciatore

Considering how well it defined my lashes, I was skeptical I could achieve the bold look shown in the video, but it was really easy to get a cool, clumpy look. This one’s not for everyone, but I love how grungy and witchy it looks while still emphasizing my eyes. I don’t think I’ll be rocking this every day, but it’s nice to have the option, and I love that it pushed me out of my comfort zone.

The bold look
The bold look
Bella Cacciatore

I generally say not to spend more than $12 on mascara, but Gucci changed my mind. I’m already dreading my tube running out.

Gucci Mascara L'Obscur

$35.00, Gucci

BUY NOW

Looking for more incredible product recommendations? Check out all 265 winners from the 2021 Glamour Beauty Awards.

Bella Cacciatore is the beauty associate at Glamour. Follow her on Instagram @bellacacciatore_.

Originally Appeared on Glamour