Federal agencies appeal suspension of abortion pill rule

MICHAEL KUNZELMAN

SILVER SPRING, Md. (AP) — The Trump administration has asked a federal appeals court to reinstate a rule that has required women to visit a hospital, clinic or medical office to obtain an abortion pill during the COVID-19 pandemic.

A federal judge in Maryland agreed earlier this month to temporarily block enforcement of the rule. Justice Department attorneys asked U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang to suspend his July 13 order while they appeal, but the judge refused on Thursday.

The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday docketed the government’s appeal of Chuang’s decision.

Chuang concluded that the “in-person requirements” for patients seeking medication abortion care impose a “substantial obstacle” to abortion patients and are likely unconstitutional under the circumstances of the pandemic.

The judge’s ruling will allow health care providers to arrange for mifepristone to be mailed or delivered to patients during the public health emergency declared by the secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved mifepristone to be used in combination with a second drug, misoprostol, to end an early pregnancy or manage a miscarriage.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and other groups sued HHS and the FDA in May to challenge the rule. American Civil Liberties Union attorneys represent the groups.

Chuang didn’t set any geographic limitations on the preliminary injunction that he issued. However, the judge said the federal case would not eliminate any state’s ability to continue to regulate abortion medication “above and beyond” the FDA’s requirements.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys argued that the FDA’s in-person requirements infringe on women's constitutional rights to an abortion and violate the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment.

Government lawyers have argued that the requirements are necessary to ensure that patients safely use mifepristone. Justice Department attorneys also claim the plaintiffs have no evidence that the rule has forced patients to forgo a medication abortion or undergo a riskier procedure due to pandemic-related delays.

“The Court was wrong to conclude that Plaintiffs are likely to show that the in-person requirements pose a substantial obstacle to abortion access,” they wrote in a court filing last Friday.

Meanwhile, on Wednesday, plaintiffs' attorneys asked the judge to clarify whether his order allows clinicians to dispense mifepristone through mail-order pharmacies.

“If all deliveries of mifepristone must originate from a certified prescriber’s office and cannot originate from a designated mail-order pharmacy acting under the prescriber’s supervision, some medication abortion patients will continue to be forced to undertake needless travel and risk during this pandemic,” they wrote.

More From

  • LGBT protesters decry rising homophobia, arrests in Poland

    A large crowd of LGBT rights supporters gathered in Warsaw on Saturday to protest the arrest of a transgender activist who had carried out acts of civil disobedience against rising homophobia in Poland. Saturday's protest comes a day after LGBT rights supporters scuffled with police who arrested the activist, Malgorzata Szutowicz, known best as “Margot.” “The police were aggressively pushing the protesters out of the way, knocking people to the ground and holding them down with their boots,” the group said.

  • Bradshaw to visit every Tennessee county in Senate run

    U.S. Senate candidate Marquita Bradshaw said Saturday that her campaign fundraising is in full swing and she plans to visit all 95 Tennessee counties as she tries to flip the seat from Republican to Democrat. Bradshaw won Thursday’s Democratic primary election in the contest to replace Republican U.S. Sen. Lamar Alexander, who is retiring.

  • Protest at Copacabana Beach highlights pandemic

    Protest at Copacabana Beach highlights pandemic

  • Thousands throng central Jerusalem in anti-Netanyahu protest

    Thousands of demonstrators thronged the streets near the official residence of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in central Jerusalem on Saturday night, in a renewed show of strength as weeks of protests against the Israeli leader showed no signs of slowing. Throughout the summer, thousands of Israelis have taken to the streets, calling for Netanyahu to resign, protesting his handling of the country’s coronavirus crisis and saying he should not remain in office while on trial for corruption charges. Self-employed workers whose businesses have been hurt by the economic crisis also joined Saturday's march.