These Eyebrow Pencils Will Make Your Brows Fluffy and Thick

IMO, filling in your eyebrows is the most important part of your entire makeup routine (after applying mascara, of course). I mean, take it from celebrity makeup artist Brandy Allen, who says she begins with the brows first because they frame the face. The key to getting thick and full eyebrows? The best eyebrow pencil. The right pencil will literally take your arches to new heights and fill in even the sparsest of brows. Meanwhile, an eyebrow pencil with a subpar formula will have you legit looking like you drew them on with a colored pencil.

But with so many eyebrow pencils on the market, where TF do you even start? That's where I come in. I found the very best eyebrow pencils that will make your brows thicker and fuller without budging. So stop wasting your money on crappy formulas and try out one of these 12 pencils below. But first, here's a little sneak peek of what's to come.

Our top picks for the best eyebrow pencils in 2022:

Ready for the rest of the eyebrow pencils guaranteed to give you some holy-wow brows? Cool, because I handpicked the best—with the help of an expert makeup artist—from brands like Anastasia Beverly Hills, E.l.f. Cosmetics, Benefit Cosmetics, Hourglass, and more.