The panel, the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis, is divided about how to reopen schools and businesses, mirroring divisions among Americans.
In a heated exchange during a U.S. House subcommittee hearing about the coronavirus pandemic on Friday, Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan repeatedly goaded Dr. Anthony Fauci into taking a stance against the ongoing protests to end police violence.“Should government limit the protesting?” asked Jordan, a Republican. Dr. Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), correctly replied that it is not his position to determine how government can use force. “I don’t understand why you’re asking me as a public health official who should get arrested or not,” Dr. Fauci said, according to CBS News.Dr. Fauci added that people should generally continue to avoid crowds because it can lead to transmission of the virus, particularly in cases where people are not taking the necessary precautions like wearing masks. “I don’t judge one crowd versus another crowd. When you’re in a crowd, particularly if you’re not wearing a mask, that induces the spread,” Dr. Fauci said.Jordan pointed to canceled church services nationwide and state governments shutting down the economy — with the exception of essential businesses — to then ask Dr. Fauci why the regulations are seemingly inconsistent when it comes to protests. Dr. Fauci replied that there is “no inconsistency.” For the record, church services have emerged as a major source of coronavirus spread, while protests have not.Jordan’s inappropriate line of questioning is just one example of how Republican lawmakers are launching aggressive attacks on the right to protest, using the disproven talking point that racial justice protests are contributing to the spread of coronavirus. Despite efforts to push a narrative that protests are to blame for the spread of COVID, a study published in the National Bureau of Economic Research last month found “no evidence that net COVID-19 case growth differentially rose following the onset of Black Lives Matter protests.” Experts say this is likely because protestors are outside and most of them wear masks. Demonstrators at actions nationwide have commented on the ways people are keeping each other safe in the streets by handing out masks and hand sanitizer. Likewise, experts say people are more likely to spread the virus at parties and in workplaces than at protests.But Republicans — who have repeatedly downplayed the deadly virus when it’s convenient for them — are now using it to curtail the rights of Black Lives Matter protestors, who have been harassed, assaulted, and criminalized since the uprisings first started across the country in late May. Jordan himself has been inconsistent on the matter of protests, seemingly preferring some over others. The congressman seemed to express support for those largely mask-less protestors who wanted to reopen the economy in April, calling sensible restrictions like those of Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer an “attack on freedom.”Both parties have attacked Black Lives Matter protestors over the last few months, making distinctions between “good” and “bad” protestors, and pushing dangerous narratives about “outside agitators” and “anarchists.” (It is neither illegal to be an agitator, nor an anarchist.)These talking points have had harmful material consequences. In New York state, for example, anti-protest legislation was introduced last month that would heighten the legal penalties for rioting, and we’ve seen the ways that limiting the legal protections of demonstrators can lead to further violence against them. From Portland to New York City, law enforcement have both kidnapped and detained protestors without record. That a Republican congressman would demand for a top public health official to take a stance on the legality of protesting is alarming, to say the least. It’s equally alarming that Jordan seems hellbent on injecting a culture war — pointedly bringing up churches and denouncing racial justice protests — into a public health discussion. Based on the level of repression we’ve seen at protests in the last few months, it’s imperative to push back against a line of thinking that will only put more people in danger.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Melania Trump To America: "Let Them Eat Cake"Protests Haven't Led To A Spike In COVID-19 Cases"The Police Are More Dangerous Than COVID-19"
- Meredith Videos
Dr. Fauci suggested wearing eye coverings, but how much will this really help?
- Good Housekeeping
Both Dr. Fauci and Dr. Birx have touted face shields' potential benefits.
- Scary Mommy
Schools can’t open until we have paid leave for all families and workers who might get sick, health experts say Despite the ongoing coronavirus pandemic (and the fact that more than 150,000 Americans have died from COVID-19, more than in any other country), America is the only developed nation on Earth that doesn’t guarantee paid 
- Yahoo Life Shopping
Doctors say wearing goggles in public is a good idea.
- Meredith Videos
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said Sunday that she has no confidence in Dr. Deborah Birx, the White House coronavirus response coordinator.
- The Mighty
Alex Jurani discusses mental health takeaways from The Mighty's recent panel of LGBTQIA+ Asian American voices.
These plans sure aren't consistent.
- Yahoo Life Videos
During an interview with CNN this week, Dr. Deborah Birx added a new layer of guidance for mask wearing, suggesting those who live in COVID-19 hotspots — or with high-risk individuals — should think about wearing masks in their living space.
- Scary Mommy
Apparently, the county didn't get Trump's memo about reopening.
- Yahoo Life
Conspiracy theories around COVID-19 continue to spread. Experts weigh in on why people believe them.
There is plenty of scientific evidence available that shows COVID-19 is a real threat to public health. There is also research that shows wearing a mask in public can help prevent the spread of COVID-19. Still, conspiracy theories persist.
The White House coronavirus response coordinator told CNN that current outbreaks in the US are "different from March and April."
Update: Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan issued an order blocking the mandate to close Montgomery County private schools, saying the decision is for schools and parents, not politicians, to make. However, the school has not yet made an independent decision.This story was originally published on Monday, August 3, 2020, at 5 p.m.President Trump’s insistence on reopening schools across the country amid the coronavirus pandemic is coming under fire once again amid reports that his 14-year-old son Barron Trump’s private school will stay safely closed. St. Andrew’s Episcopal School, the Montgomery County, MD, school where Trump’s youngest child will be enrolled as a high school freshman in the fall, will reportedly be closed through at least October 1. The school year is scheduled to begin on September 8.The decision, which affects all of Montgomery County’s private schools, was made to “protect the health and safety of Montgomery County residents as well as parents, students, teachers, and staff from the spread of COVID-19,” according to a press release from Montgomery County Health Officer Dr. Travis Gayles. Trump has been consistently vocal about the alleged necessity of reopening U.S. schools as the 2020-2021 school year has drawn closer, going so far as to threaten to defund schools that don’t reopen in the fall. He continued to double down as recently as early Monday morning, when he tweeted, “Cases up because of BIG Testing! Much of our Country is doing very well. Open the Schools!” Many on Twitter pointed out the hypocrisy in the fact that the president’s son will be safe at home while others are being forced to return to in-person learning. (That’s when “Barron” started trending.) > Barron’s school will be closed because it’s not safe, but he’s perfectly fine risking other people’s children as long as he is insulated and has daily testing. https://t.co/R7N4srza2r> > — Amee Vanderpool (@girlsreallyrule) August 3, 2020> This is so typical of Trump: > > Trump votes by mail, but doesn’t think anybody else should. > > Trump thinks all schools should open up, but it’s appropriate that Barron’s school remains closed.> > — Bill Madden (@maddenifico) August 3, 2020The Trump administration has issued guidelines on reopening schools “safely and carefully,” including the utilization of teaching methods that include “flexible schedules, cohorting, and master teaching” and $70 billion of the next coronavirus relief bill to “directly support K-12 education.” But many teachers and parents have pushed back, saying they don’t feel safe about going back to work or sending their kids back to school while coronavirus cases are still spiking across the country.According to CNN, only one out of the 15 biggest school districts in the U.S. will let students return for in-person classes this fall, and at least 10 have decided to start the semester with online-only learning. Three schools have opted for hybrid models.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?A Texas Teacher On Going Back To SchoolWhat It's Like To Be A Teacher Right NowWhy Trump Is REALLY Trying To Ban TikTok
More FromMeredith Videos
- Meredith Videos
Aerial video filmed Wednesday showed the full scale of the destruction caused by a massive explosion in Beirut.
- Meredith Videos
Australian State of Victoria Imposes Curfew and Closes Most Stores and Factories as It Hits New Coronavirus Record
Victoria has reported a record daily coronavirus case total as Australia’s second-most populous state enters its strictest lockdown since the pandemic began.
- Meredith Videos
At least five people were killed as Tropical Storm Isaias spawned tornadoes and dumped rain Tuesday along the U.S. East Coast after making landfall as a hurricane in North Carolina, where it caused floods and fires that displaced dozens of people.
- Meredith Videos
President Donald Trump said U.S. military generals have told him that they “seem to feel” the massive explosion that rocked Beirut on Tuesday, killing at least 70 people, was a “terrible attack” likely caused by a bomb.