I Couldn't Find a Good Buffy Comforter Review, So I Wrote One
"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."
As someone who always runs hot, finding bedding that I can feel comfortable in is an absolute nightmare. My room doesn't have a radiator or heat (yes, that is illegal in New York, and yes, I have complained about it numerous times to no avail), yet my partner and I still sleep with both a standing fan and the air conditioner on in below-freezing conditions because, as he calls me, I'm "a living radiator." A friend recommended I invest in a Buffy comforter because she told me her night sweats disappeared after sleeping with one, so I figured "why not?" and bought the Cloud comforter. When I was initially deciding between the Cloud and the Breeze option though, there was no Buffy comforter review I could find that actually stated what I needed to learn as a hot sleeper, so I just rolled the dice and went with one.
For those not familiar with the bedding company, it specializes in pillows, sheets, comforters, and other linens with a focus on sustainable practices and cooling technology. As mentioned, Buffy currently has two different comforters for sale: the Cloud and the Breeze. I bought the Cloud in size full/queen a few months ago and was using it with a duvet cover until the beginning of February. I initially chose the Cloud over the Breeze as it generally had better reviews from customers, my partner likes a fluffier blanket, and it was cheaper than the Breeze. I actually wrote about the bedding in another comforter review.
Cloud Comforter
Cloud Comforter
buffy.co
$123.25
Breeze Comforter
Breeze Comforter
buffy.co
$175.00
And while I generally enjoy the Cloud and could tell it trapped less of my body heat upon using it, there were things about it that I thought could be improved. Though I was cooler, I wasn't cool enough, which is a common problem with comforters marketed this way. So, when a fellow House Beautiful editor asked me to review both comforters for work, I happily obliged!
I figured I would put the Cloud and the Breeze comforters to the ultimate test for my fellow hot sleepers, and write out my honest review of each to give you better, more personalized insight on which to buy for your sleeping situation. I've been sleeping with the Breeze for just over a month now, and while I thoroughly enjoy both, I definitely have a favorite. Keep reading to find out all you need to know about each Buffy comforter, so you can figure out which one is right for you.
[table-of-contents] stripped
Why Buffy's Comforters Stand Out
It starts with the brand's sustainability efforts. It's no secret that the textile industry creates a lot of waste, and while Buffy does, of course, produce waste, the company is committed to transparency when it comes to the environmental footprint it leaves behind with each product. A study with Ecochain revealed that the carbon footprint produced by Buffy's comforters "is almost nine percent lower than the conventional comforter made from PET & cotton." (PET fibers are polyester.)
When it comes to materials, Buffy tries to be as responsible as possible. The company uses recycled plastic bottles to create the fluff in the Cloud product line, which it claims is what makes these products perfect cooling options. "One of the key benefits of Recycled Plastic Fill is that it retains a just-right level of heat to stay snug during a movie marathon in bed, but not so hot you have to kick off the covers," the website notes.
For both comforters, Buffy use TENCEL™ eucalyptus lyocell to create the shell, which doesn't cause as much water waste as cotton and doesn't require pesticides. According to the brand's FAQ section, the "eucalyptus lyocell is a man-made cellulosic fiber derived from a combination of eucalyptus and other wood pulps. The fibers we source for our products have FSC® and PEFC™ certifications for their sustainable forestry practices." So while the comforter isn't organic, it is a more sustainable option than regular polyester. Buffy also ships the products in boxes made from FSC-certified recycled materials that you can recycle after receiving, and they offset their carbon emissions from freight and customer shipments.
Sustainability efforts aside, Buffy's at-home trial is another aspect that makes them unique. After ordering your comforter, Buffy won't charge your credit card until eight days after the order is placed, giving you time to see if you like the comforter before actually buying it. Since it takes three to five days to get your hands on it, you really only have a few days then to test it out, which is kind of annoying. However, if you need more than seven nights to collect your thoughts, you still have 50 days to initiate a free return for a full refund.
The Differences and Similarities Between the Breeze and Cloud
When I unwrapped the Breeze, the first thing I thought to myself was, "Wow, this is a lot thinner than the Cloud." You can see in the photo (and don't mind the Ouija board on my wall) that I folded the comforters the exact same way, and it's so easy to identify which is which. Though the Breeze is noticeably thinner than the Cloud, it's naturally weighted via the fiber fill. It won't feel like a normal weighted blanket that uses metal or microfiber beads to provide the calming sensation, but it provides just enough pressure where I did notice it felt heavier than it looked. The Cloud is, well, meant to feel like a cloud, so it makes sense as to why it feels so lightweight considering how fluffy it is.
The Breeze is filled with eucalyptus lyocell, which is more breathable and makes it better for hot sleepers than the Cloud (though, again, both are meant to be cooling), whereas the Cloud is filled with the recycled PET (rPET) fiber fill. The rPET fiber fill traps more heat than the lyocell fill.
Both comforters' shells are made from the eucalyptus lyocell and are designed with "fill-lock" engineering, which means the fiber fill isn't just loosely stuffed in there. I've had comforters before where the fill migrated to one area, leaving empty spots in its wake, but this feature prevents that in both comforters. They also both come with little loops on the corners to secure duvet covers, so you can style them any way you want.
The Cloud Comforter's Pros and Cons
The Cloud comforter comes in only one color, white, and three sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/California King. Again, I have a full size bed, so I got the Full/Queen and feel very happy with how it lays over my mattress and fits in my duvet cover. Even when my partner is tugging the blanket to his side, I'm left with a lot of comforter, so he has more time to hog it before I get annoyed.
The Cloud is machine washable as long as you're using only cold water on the gentle cycle and drying on low heat. I will say though, the dryer in my apartment does a questionable job at best, so after one low-heat cycle, I did have to throw it back in because it was still damp and ran it on high heat. It came out extra wrinkly, but it didn't shrink at all!
Pros:
Very fluffy thanks to the rPET fiber fill
Comfortable when sleeping alone
Machine washable
Feels super soft thanks to the sateen weave
Cheaper than the Breeze comforter
Cons:
Traps too much heat when there's another body in the bed
Bunches up in the duvet cover even though it has corner loops to tie the cover down
So fluffy that it's hard to store when it's not being used
The Breeze Comforter's Pros and Cons
The Breeze comforter comes in the same single color and three sizes as the Cloud: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/California King. Though I received the same size in the Breeze as I did the Cloud (Full/Queen), the Breeze almost felt larger because it was that much thinner than the Cloud. However, it fits in my duvet cover exactly the same way, so I know that it is the same size.
Unlike the Cloud, the Breeze comforter can't be machine washed, which is a bummer in my book, as I am too lazy to take a comforter to the dry cleaner. Let's just hope I don't spill anything on it, as the Breeze is more expensive too!
Pros:
Is very breathable, to the point where I'm not sweating nearly as much in the night
Naturally weighted to make for a cozier night's sleep
Is fully biodegradable and compostable
Easy to store thanks to the fact that it's relatively thin
Cons:
Doesn't trap enough heat when sleeping alone
Bunches up in the duvet cover even though it has corner loops to tie the cover down
Dry clean or spot clean only
Is the Breeze or Cloud Better for Hot Sleepers?
Buffy Cloud comforter
Buffy Breeze comforter
For me, the self-proclaimed hottest sleeper in the world, the Buffy Breeze comforter is the way to go. Though I do feel a little chill when sleeping alone under the Breeze, that isn't something that really matters to me because I do so rarely sleep by myself. Plus, I'd much rather be too cold than too hot. I generally like the feel of the Breeze better—the gentle weight of it makes me fall asleep much faster than normal.
However, this is not to say that I won't be keeping the Cloud. It's still a wonderful comforter, and my partner actually prefers it to the Breeze—as long as I'm not radiating too much heat that night. I think if you tend to get a little cold at night, the Cloud would definitely work for you.
Are Buffy Comforters Worth Buying?
Yes. I think my REM cycle has definitely improved since switching over to Buffy from my cheaper Amazon duvet insert. I also just love that the brand allows a free trial for the products, because sleep and finding bedding really is such a personal experience. You deserve to be able to test your sheets or comforter before fully committing to what you just bought. Even if you're not a hot sleeper, Buffy's products are simply good—in quality, in feel, even in the messaging. Before switching to the Breeze specifically, I don't remember the last time I woke up and wasn't slightly sweaty, so I'd definitely recommend the brand.
Follow House Beautiful on Instagram and TikTok.
You Might Also Like
