Are Costco's Sheet Cakes Already Back in Stores?

Justina Huddleston

There are a lot of things that have happened during the pandemic that we never expected, from travel bans to film release date delays (we’re getting desperate to see the new Mulan!). But one thing that we truly didn’t see coming was when Costco announced it had stopped selling half-sheet cakes, one of the best Costco desserts for large groups, in an announcement that came at the end of June. And yet, just a month later, there are now reports of sheet cake ordering stations re-appearing in stores. So what’s the deal?

Initially, Costco said that the reason why they would cease selling half-sheet cakes was two-fold. One reason was safety. “To help limit personal contact and create more space for social distancing, Costco has reduced service in some departments,” Costco told its Facebook followers.

Secondly, it seems that they may have been dwindling in popularity. Apparently, customers were gravitating toward the warehouse store’s 10-inch cakes.

It’s no secret that shoppers feel passionate about their favorite Costco items, so we weren’t even that surprised when we found out someone had started a Change.org petition to bring the half-sheet cakes back.

So, did it work?

Starting less than a week ago, there were reports that Costco half-sheet cakes were back, selling for $19.99 each, with cake ordering stations reappearing in some stores.

An NBC News reporter found that the half-sheets were available at stores in Santa Clara and San Jose, Calif.. But when they reached out to Costco for confirmation, the store responded with the same statement they had given in June when they initially canceled half-sheet production: “We are currently not selling our 1/2 sheet cakes at any US locations and as of right now, we have no immediate plans to bring them back.”

So which is it? Did the chain permanently cancel half-sheets? If so, why did it install new cake-ordering stations at certain Costco locations? Are they testing a new ordering system before a national roll-out? Will life eventually return to normal? WILL THE MADNESS EVER END?

We may never know the reason why cake ordering stations are sneakily popping up again at Costco. But if there’s a store near you and you’ve got a craving for a big old cake it might be worth checking to see if half-sheet cakes have returned to your Costco, too.

Before you go, check out our gallery below:

Launch Gallery: 16 Incredibly Gourmet Foods You Can Score at Costco

Best of SheKnows

Sign up for SheKnows' Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

More From

  • Are Any Schools Reopening Safely? Here Are the Facts & the Unknowns

    Making the decision to send your children back to school in August or September is starting to feel like the most complicated choice parents have ever made for their kids. As we watch the bad news pour in from the first districts to try reopening, the debate rages on in households, state capitals, school district […]

  • EXCLUSIVE: Rosie Huntington-Whiteley's Lifeline Is Her #MomSquad & It Includes Kylie Jenner

    Rosie Huntington-Whiteley is many things: an actress, an entrepreneur, a makeup obsessive, a former Victoria's Secret model. But when she's around a fellow mom like Kylie Jenner, she immediately melts down to the role that consumes her mind most these days: mom to 3-year-old Jack, the son she shares with fiancé Jason Statham. Huntington-Whiteley chatted […]

  • Kristen Wiig Has One Regret About Going Through IVF & Surrogacy

    When we hear about celebrities like Kristen Wiig having their babies through surrogacy in secret, sometimes our minds go to an uncharitable place: Here are women who can have it all because of their fame and money. That, of course, is not the real story with most parents. And as Kristen Wiig herself revealed in […]

  • Pink's 9-Year-Old Daughter Willow Is Mom's Lookalike in This Sweet New Picture

    Lookalike alert! Pink's Instagram is one of our favorite places to go if we want a smile, not just because of the singer's take-no-prisoners attitude, but also for all the adorable content that she shares of her 9-year-old daughter Willow. Pink gets the biggest smile on her face when she's with young Willow, and it's […]