'When Calls the Heart' Sparked a Ton of Crazy Theories About Elizabeth’s Secret Admirer

From Country Living

  • Elizabeth (Erin Krakow) receives a surprise flower delivery on the upcoming When Calls the Heart episode, "An Unexpected Gift."

  • Fans are having a lot of fun guessing who sent the sweet present.


Longtime Hearties have always supported Elizabeth Thatcher’s love life.

The main character on When Calls the Heart, played by Erin Krakow, has certainly been through the ringer in that department. She had formerly found happiness with the handsome Mountie, Jack (Daniel Lissing) but her life was thrown when he died right before she had their baby.

Recently, though, a little blossom of hope has started to grow. It seems a triangle has taken shape between Elizabeth, Lucas (Chris McNally), and Nathan (Kevin McGarry), and we’re not sure a.) who we’re rooting for or b.) who we see her with in the end.

All of the speculation was further flamed thanks to a preview for the upcoming episode, “An Unexpected Gift.” Someone sends Elizabeth a bouquet of flowers, and as Bill Avery (Jack Wagner) blatantly put it, “If this were an investigation there’d really only be two suspects.”

A secret admirer in Hope Valley! Who could it be? Don’t worry, fans have a few thoughts. Most people, like Bill, suggested Lucas or Nathan, but there were a couple other theories we think have legs.

Some predicted the florals were from Lee (Kavan Smith) for “helping with Rosemary.” On the flip side, one fan noted they could be from Rosemary (Pascale Hutton) as a way to push Elizabeth into deciding which man she likes better. Another person guessed one of her students, which does make a lot of sense. Many fans didn’t know exactly who the sender is, but they're convinced it's not as obvious as Lucas or Nathan.

Finally, there was this wild idea, which probably won’t happen but we’re entertaining it all the same: “Just imagine if those flowers were from Jack wouldn’t Hallmark have a ratings bonanza!”

We wish! Who do you think the culprit is? Let us know in the comments!

You Might Also Like