• Home
  • Mail
  • News
  • Finance
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Search
  • Mobile
  • More
Yahoo
    • Skip to Navigation
    • Skip to Main Content
    • Skip to Related Content
    • Mail
    Lifestyle Home
    Follow Us
    • Style
    • Beauty
    • Wellness
    • Shopping
    • MAKERS
    • Holiday Guide for Guys
    • Pets
    • Video
    • Horoscopes
    • Pop Culture

    After Kavanaugh's Confirmation, One Word Ignited A Massive Debate About Feminism

    Ja'han Jones
    HuffPostOctober 12, 2018
    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share

    Jasmin Kaur wrote her poem “her voice” in December 2016.  At a time predating the official start of the Trump presidency, her words were meant as a guiding principle for Sikh women like her, who struggle against racism and the feeling of invisibility that accompanies it.

    In her poem, she writes:

    Scream,

    So that one day a hundred years from now

    Another sister will not have to dry her tears

    Wondering where in history she lost her voice

    But in an ironic turn, last week Kaur saw her poem go viral in the days following Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation to the Supreme Court despite sexual assault allegations against him — only now, her words were edited.

    “Scream,” as she’d written, was replaced with the word “Vote,” with the editor repurposing a poem about willful, emotional expression into a poem about dutiful, civic expression.

    (Photo: Facebook)
    (Photo: Facebook)

    Though Kaur does not know who originally edited the poem, the altered version was shared widely by white feminists. Kaur’s followers alerted her to the alteration, which ignited a debate about how those with privilege adapt the language of resistance to their preferred narrative.

    Kaur told HuffPost this week that the very invisibility her poem was intended to combat ended up being reinforced when her work was repurposed and popularized.

    “When you write specifically to counter your feelings of invisibility and smallness within a white supremacist society,” she wrote in an email, “it’s disconcerting to see white people change your words to suit their own immediate needs.”

    Kaur says wanting to use her poem to rally women voters is understandable, but she argues it is ignorant to do so without acknowledging the barriers to voting that have been instituted to bar communities of color from participating.

    “I understand the sentiment of people needing to vote within the current political climate,” she said. “I also recognize all the ways that voting has been (and still is) inaccessible to many communities of colour.”

    In its original form, “her voice” was intended as a time capsule. Kaur was setting out to “reflect the voices that are missing from the pages of history.” And in using the word “scream” specifically, she said she “was coming back to the present moment in which I have the opportunity to document my life and thoughts in ways that women of previous generations may not have had access to.”

    Kaur is well aware of the burdens that come with being Sikh in a society that so heavily favors Christianity above other religions, particularly Islam and Sikhism.

    “When you exist within a Sikh body and have a visible Sikh identity (such as wearing a dastaar - turban), public spaces make you feel both hyper-visible and completely invisible,” she said. “Glares from strangers become the norm. People shouting “terrorist!” at you through their car windows bring you to outrage until you can’t carry the hurt anymore.”

    In giving Sikh women permission to scream, Kaur was acknowledging the righteousness of their anger without demanding they find a solution for it. She was affirming their entitlement to anger for their own purpose — intimate, painful, perhaps cathartic anger, rather than anger used solely in service of others.

    The appropriation of Kaur’s words, then, invigorated conversation about allyship, political responsibility and who ought to be tasked with reversing America’s racist and sexist history.

    Her view of anger doesn’t fit neatly with the widely preferred methods of social activism during the Trump Era, which are often intersectional, typically result-driven and widely carried out by well-intentioned people (many of whom are white) who may be realizing the oppressive forces in America for the first time.

    There was a palatable air of hopelessness among the discourse surrounding Kavanaugh’s Supreme Court confirmation. Those who thought numerous corroborated claims of sexual assault levied against Kavanaugh would stifle his elevation to the court were stunned — albeit probably not shocked — when conservative senators cast the allegations aside and confirmed him anyway.

    There was and remains a sense among many that the confirmation of an historically unpopular nominee defied democratic principles. And while there was a chorus of responses opposing his confirmation, the rewriting of Jasmine Kaur’s poem reveals that that chorus is not always harmonious. 

    Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

    RELATED COVERAGE

    D.L. Hughley Turned A Fox News Segment Into A Biting Satire About Racism

    This 'Einstein Visa' Recipient Tells The Story Of Trump In One Tiny Painting

    Botham Shem Jean's Killing Reveals A Deadly American Lie

    This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share

    What to Read Next

    • Walmart Canada pulls 'Let It Snow' Christmas sweater featuring a cocaine-using Santa

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Michelle Obama weighs in on President Trump impeachment hearings: ‘It’s surreal’

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Swe Zin Htet on being the first openly gay Miss Universe contestant: 'People in Myanmar are not accepting of this'

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Mother passionately defends son who beat up bully: 'The school did nothing'

      In The Know
    • Bella Hadid Just Hit the Beach in a Seriously Revealing One-Piece Swimsuit

      Harper's Bazaar
    • Woman asked to leave American Airlines flight over ‘ironic’ T-shirt: ‘People usually laugh at it’

      In The Know
    • Catherine Zeta-Jones Posted an Emotional Tribute to Kirk Douglas on His 103 Birthday

      Country Living
    • Two Women Landed in the ER After Using a Vacuum to End Their Periods, According to a Nurse's Scary Viral Tweet

      Meredith Videos
    • Um, An NFL Reporter Found Out Her Boyfriend Was Cheating Because Of His Fitbit

      Women's Health
    • A Brewery Pulled Cans Of Its Holiday Beer After Someone Complained The Reindeer On It Were NSFW

      Delish
    • 'Blue Bloods' Sparked a Wild Fan Theory About Eddie and Jamie After the Tense Fall Finale

      Country Living
    • Tarek El Moussa and Heather Rae Young Snap 'Family' Holiday Pic with Kids

      House Beautiful
    • Lizzo's Lakers Game Outfit Exposed Her Butt and People Have Mixed Feelings

      Teen Vogue
    • Cardi B wants an ‘extremely holy’ president: ‘I don’t want my president to entertain me’

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Miley Cyrus Got Two New, Super Meaningful Tattoos

      Marie Claire
    • Lizzo sparked a Twitter debate after wearing a revealing outfit to a Lakers game

      Hello Giggles

    North Korea resumes insults of 'erratic old man' Trump

    gail: I guess Donald Trump isn’t the only leader calling other people names. How has it all come down to this?

    Join the Conversation
    1 / 5

    518

    • Cardi B Covers 'Vogue' with Her Daughter Kulture

      Fashionista
    • How I Responded When a Child Commented on My Body Size

      The Mighty
    • Sorry, But If You Notice Any Of These Signs, Your Partner Is Emotionally Cheating On You

      Women's Health
    • Kendall Jenner's Nude Minidress Looks Like It's Dripping in Tinsel

      Harper's Bazaar
    • Miley Cyrus's new tattoo looks like a callout to her spilt with Liam Hemsworth

      Hello Giggles
    • Kelly Ripa and Daughter Lola Stepped Out in Complementary Mini Dresses

      InStyle
    • We Got to Peek Inside Giada De Laurentiis' LA Home & It Wasn't at All What We Expected

      SheKnows
    • Jamie Otis Says She's Been Diagnosed With HPV and Has Cervical Dysplasia—Here's What That Means

      Meredith Videos
    • This local hardware store’s $130 commercial is being dubbed ‘the best Christmas ad of the year'

      In The Know
    • Dr. Pimple Popper Is Back With New Episodes — & We Have The Exclusive Trailer

      Refinery29
    • Meghan Markle Was Unrecognizable During an Early Charity Visit in a Baseball Cap and Jacket

      InStyle
    • Your Blood Pressure Reading May Be Inaccurate, According to Experts

      Woman's Day
    • Camila Cabello Just Joked That Shawn Mendes Might Break Up With Her

      Seventeen
    • Lizzo Twerked in a Thong on the Jumbotron at an LA Lakers Game

      Elle
    • Abandoned 5-Year-Old Carries Toddler in Extreme Cold After Adult Allegedly Left Them in Home

      People
    • Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds' Wedding Photos Are Now Banned from Pinterest

      Harper's Bazaar