New Bodycam Footage Reveals George Floyd Pleading With Police Before He Was Killed

Britni de la Cretaz
HOUSTON, TEXAS – JUNE 08: Joshua Broussard kneels in front of a memorial and mural that honors George Floyd at the Scott Food Mart corner store in Houston’s Third Ward where Mr. Floyd grew up on June 8, 2020 in Houston, Texas. The funeral and burial for George Floyd will be held June 9. Floyd died on May 25th while in Minneapolis police custody, sparking nationwide protests. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
HOUSTON, TEXAS – JUNE 08: Joshua Broussard kneels in front of a memorial and mural that honors George Floyd at the Scott Food Mart corner store in Houston’s Third Ward where Mr. Floyd grew up on June 8, 2020 in Houston, Texas. The funeral and burial for George Floyd will be held June 9. Floyd died on May 25th while in Minneapolis police custody, sparking nationwide protests. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

On Wednesday, body cam footage from two of the officers involved in the death of George Floyd were made public. The footage, which comes from the body cams of officers Thomas Lane and J. Kueng, shows Floyd pleading for his life before fellow officer Derek Chauvin knelt on Floyd’s neck for nearly eight minutes. Until this week, the only available footage of Floyd’s death was from the bystander’s perspective, and investigators say that this is crucial to the case at large.

On Wednesday, journalists and members of the public were able to view the video by appointment, but according to judge Peter Cahill, the footage will not be publicly released. The videos show a distraught and terrified Floyd, CBS News reports. Floyd tells the officers that he’s “not a bad guy” and that he has just recovered from COVID-19. He also says he’s been shot before after Lane pulls his gun on Floyd when he fails to make both his hands visible quickly enough. The New York Times describes Floyd as “visibly shaken, with his head down, and crying, as if he were in the throes of a panic attack” at this time.

The officers have argued that Floyd was resisting, and according to reports, the footage does show Floyd not instantly complying with the request to get in the squad car. However, it appears to be because Floyd is afraid and because, as he plainly tells the officers over and over again, he is claustrophobic. “I can’t breathe. I don’t want to go in there,” Floyd reportedly says on the footage, according to CBS News. “Throughout the video, he never appeared to present a physical threat to the officers, and even after he was handcuffed and searched for weapons, the officers seemed to be more concerned with controlling his body than saving his life,” The New York Times writes.

It is after Floyd goes into the back seat of the car and out the other side that the officers wrestle him to the ground. When Floyd says he cannot breathe, the Times reports that Chauvin responds, “takes a heck of a lot of oxygen to say that.”

From there, bystanders express concern for Floyd’s condition as he continues to say he cannot breathe, but the officers don’t appear overly concerned. Once Kueng says he cannot find a pulse, Lane and the EMTs do chest compressions and work on Floyd for several minutes instead of bringing him to the hospital in the ambulance they parked several blocks from the scene, even though CBS News reports that dispatcher audio reveals they all knew Floyd was in full cardiac arrest at that time.

The footage brings new evidence to Floyd’s case, as all officers involved in his killing face charges. Body cams are often cited as a reform measure for reducing instances of police violence. But as this case shows, along with the case of Elijah McLean, who can be heard pleading with the officers who killed him, they’re not often effective in terms of violence reduction. The idea behind making police wear body cams is that they’ll be less likely to commit acts of violence if they know they are being recorded. But in reality, that’s not how things have played out.

A 2017 study by The Lab @ DC worked with the Metropolitan Police Department to design a randomized control trial of over 2,000 officers, which found that wearing body cameras had “no statistically significant effects on any of the measured outcomes.”

Meanwhile, a 2016 analysis of 10 previous studies on the efficacy of body-worn cameras also found that they had “no discernible effect” on use of force by officers. It can also be nearly impossible to get access to the body cam footage, as it is not public and police departments like to fight as hard as they can against releasing it. Data like this is the reason activists believe abolition — not reform — is the only solution to eradicating police violence.

All four officers were fired the day after Floyd’s death. Chauvin is charged with second-degree murder, while Lane, Kueng, and officer Tou Thao are charged with aiding and abetting. The cameras they wore did not stop them from killing George Floyd, though, and new footage provides a new call to action in the fight against police violence.

Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

We Are All George Floyd

Black Moms React To George Floyd’s Death

3 Other Officers Charged In George Floyd Killing

More From

  • Ted Cruz Is The Only Person Still Using Soy Lattes As A Punchline

    Republican Texas Senator Ted Cruz is nothing if not a beacon of truth telling. Unless that truth doesn’t benefit him directly. Amid stalled negotiations between Congressional lawmakers hoping to secure a relief package for Americans struggling under the economic challenges wrought by the COVID-19 pandemic, Cruz took to Twitter on Monday to make light of the dire situation.After Democratic Massachusetts Senator Ed Markey suggested that every American receive “$2000/month for the duration of the pandemic, $2000/month for 3 months after that, and $2000/month retroactive to March,” in order to offset the economic challenges caused by the pandemic, Cruz derided the plan by invoking a tried-and-true Republican trope: the soy latte.“Why be so cheap?” Cruz asked. “Give everyone $1 million a day, every day, forever. And three soy lattes a day. And a foot massage. We have a magic money tree — we should use it!”Cruz, who made light of mass economic despair plaguing millions in America, is, of course, just among the many Republicans to push back against any sort of reform aid. Conservatives have long used sensationalist rhetoric around the spending of middle and working class Americans to sidestep inconvenient truths about just how hard it is to stretch a dollar in today’s current economic climate. And it’s not just politicians who rely on dangerous ideas about laziness and frivolous spending in order to dismiss concerns about wage stagnation: In a widely ridiculed “sample budget” designed to show how its employees could easily sustain themselves on a minimum wage salary, McDonald’s famously allotted only $20 a month to health insurance spending, and also used money earned at a second job to calculate net income.During the COVID-19 pandemic, Republicans have fallen back on one of their most-relied on talking points to suggest that “government handouts,” like the $600 weekly federal stimulus benefit that expired in July, disincentivizes people from getting back to work. But that’s far from the truth of the matter. In fact, research has repeatedly shown that direct cash transfers — sometimes referred to as universal basic income, or “mincome,” for short — have no impact on an individual’s propensity to perform labor.“It’s not a goddamn joke Ted,” Markey, who is currently campaigning against Rep. Joe Kennedy III ahead of Massachusetts’ September 1 primary election, replied. “Millions of families are facing hunger, the threat of eviction, and the loss of their health care during a pandemic that is worsening every day. Get real.”Cruz, for his part, is one to talk about money growing on trees, especially when considering that he supported the Republican-backed plan to earmark $500 billion in loans from the Treasury Department and the Federal Reserve to be used in order to revive struggling businesses. It’s also worth noting that Cruz himself even personally spearheaded an initiative to expand that program to include much larger companies, and sought to increase the maximum loan amount from $150 million to $200 million for struggling companies.As for the line about the foot massages, yes, of course it’s disgusting coming from Ted Cruz, but as history tells us, that’s not really his thing anyway. Plus, who drinks soy lattes anymore? A word to Ted: next time if you want to make a joke at the expense of millennials, oat milk is the superior punchline.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?AOC Schooled Ted Cruz On Twitter Over CoronavirusKellyanne Conway Is Loudly Anti-"Big Tech"So, Who Is The Lincoln Project Even For?

  • Katie Hill Is Reclaiming Her Story After The Worst Year Of Her Life

    In 2018, Katie Hill achieved a goal that she had been thinking about ever since she was chosen “Most Likely to Become the First Woman President” in preschool (right after being labeled “too bossy” by her teacher). At 31, she was elected as the first woman and youngest person to represent California’s 25th District in Congress, flipping the long-red area blue. The daughter of a cop and an ER nurse, Hill was part of the 2018 Blue Wave of “regular” women whose entry into politics hadn’t felt preordained and who ran in response to Donald Trump’s election. Although she had once considered becoming a nurse like her mom and grandmother, Hill felt like the electoral victory was a dream come true.  Once she started her term, Hill quickly ascended to leadership positions in Congress and worked closely with Speaker Nancy Pelosi. However, even as her professional life was flourishing, Hill’s personal life was spinning out of control. Back home in California, her relationship with her husband, Kenny Heslep, had started unraveling as he became increasingly abusive, erupting in frequent angry outbursts, monitoring her whereabouts and phone calls, and even walking around with a loaded gun during their fights. Hill and Heslep are now separated, but, as Hill reveals in her new book, She Will Rise, anytime she tried to leave him, he told her, “I will ruin you.” A few months after Hill moved out and said she wanted a divorce, Heslep allegedly made good on his threat. In October 2019, hundreds of Hill’s intimate photos and private text messages were leaked to a right-wing tabloid and quickly spread across the internet. Hill says Heslep sent the photos as revenge against her for leaving him. Heslep claims he was “hacked.”The publication of these photos and texts resulted in weeks of gratuitous, lurid coverage of Hill’s private life that also revealed she had been in a polyamorous relationship with Heslep and a woman who worked on her campaign. Hill says she regrets that relationship and has also apologized for it, acknowledging its imbalanced power dynamic. Still, she was furious and humiliated. Hill says she discovered that Heslep had, without her consent, created profiles for them on sites like Cruise Ship Mingle, and, during her congressional campaign, posted pictures of her on the subreddit “r/wouldyoufuckmywife.” Amid this personal nightmare, Hill had to make painful deliberations about her dream job. She eventually decided that the only way to make things right would be to resign from Congress, despite many, including her mentor Pelosi, urging her to stay. Hill gave a powerful resignation speech that slammed society’s sexist double standards, which allow men who have been accused of sexual assault (hi, Donald Trump) to stay in power. “I’m leaving because of a misogynistic culture that gleefully consumed my naked pictures, capitalized on my sexuality, and enabled my abusive ex to continue that abuse, this time with the entire country watching,” Hill said. “Yes, I’m stepping down, but I refuse to let this experience scare off other women who dare to take risks, who dare to step into this light.”Hill’s detractors — an online horde of misogynist trolls, Republicans interested in her House seat, and, of course, her ex — undoubtedly wanted her to run away in shame after her resignation, never to be heard from again. But Hill has not given them that satisfaction. With She Will Rise, she has reclaimed her narrative, telling her story the way that she wants the world to know it — not the way The Daily Mail told it. The book is both autobiographical and instructive, serving as an exhaustive primer on the recent history of feminism, including reproductive rights, the MeToo movement, and women running for office — it’s no coincidence it comes out near the 100th anniversary of the passage of the 19th Amendment, which gave women the right to vote. In it, Hill devotes plenty of space to give her audience tools and resources so they, too, can help change the way women are treated in society. Her goal, it seems, is to prove that while many women’s stories become erased or written over, women have the power to write them all over again. “I hope that by me being so transparent and vulnerable, it helps some people understand what happened and others can learn from my experience,” Hill told Refinery29 in a recent interview. And she does get vulnerable: Not only is she unflinching in her descriptions of the painful, guilt-ridden days after her public resignation, but she is also open in discussing moments of suicidal ideation, years of abuse, and other viscerally painful experiences.Even though she says that writing this book felt triumphant and cathartic, Hill is candid about the fact that she still struggles with the aftermath of years of trauma. “It’s something that takes continual work and I think anyone who’s been through trauma, whatever kind it might be, knows that all too well,” Hill, who is in therapy, told me. Terrible nightmares about her ex, which often cause her to wake up in terror, haunt her nightly. “I got into this relationship when I was 16 years old,” she said. “I’m constantly trying to figure out who I am as a person on my own, without this relationship defining me — it played a part in defining me for so long, for half of my life.” > I got into this relationship when I was 16 years old. I’m constantly trying to figure out who I am as a person on my own, without this relationship defining me — it played a part in defining me for so long, for half of my life.> > katie hillHill’s resignation did not signal the end of her personal troubles. In January of this year, Hill’s mother was hospitalized and underwent brain surgery; she has since recovered, and gone back to work as a trauma nurse in L.A. “She’s being so brave and strong for so many people in spite of everything that she’s been through,” Hill said. Three days after the surgery, while her mother was still in the hospital, Hill found her younger brother, Danny, dead from a drug overdose. Danny, a U.S. sailor who was training to become a Navy SEAL, was 20 years old. They were extremely close, just like she is with her mother.Another person who has helped give Hill the strength and confidence to share her story is her late grandfather, who is a central figure in the book. He taught her about politics and to be a “warrior,” which gave her the courage to run for office — and to speak out after scandal threatened to ruin her. It turned out, though, that her grandfather was a much more complicated figure than the hero she’d always seen him as. After he passed away in 2011 after a battle with Alzheimer’s disease, she slowly began to learn how he had abused her grandmother Sarah, who he had divorced when Hill was 2. Learning about this forced Hill to reckon with their relationship and what it meant that her grandfather had a history of abuse, just like her own ex.“As I was writing, to me it just became so clear that there was this complex human dynamic where it doesn’t erase the fact that someone was so important to you, it doesn’t erase whatever has been meaningful in your relationship or what they’ve done in their lives, but they can be flawed and they can have done terrible things to people,” she told me. “And so, I think it is something that we have to reconcile for public figures but also for people in our lives, kind of on a daily basis. Forgiveness and being able to hold those two truths in your mind is part of the healing process for me.”Hill says she has spent a lot of time thinking about redemption — who gets to have it and who doesn’t, who gets to own their narrative and who doesn’t. Many of the men originally outed in the MeToo movement either returned to their jobs or found different, equivalent ones. Would she be afforded the same redemption arc? Ultimately, Hill doesn’t have a neat answer to that question. Nor does she have an answer to questions that she poses in her book, like: “Did I unintentionally perpetuate any of the abusive behaviors I myself had endured for so long?” And: “How many people did I hurt because of it all?” Hill’s grief and guilt linger — about the relationship with her staffer, about her brother, about the fact that her House seat has gone to a Republican again — even though she is working on herself every day. But she has been able to turn these depths of despair into action, which has helped her heal. One of the ways she’s working through her trauma is helping other women find their voices and speak out against injustice. Since resigning, Hill has launched a PAC called HER Time, through which she is helping women candidates run for office, particularly young women and women of color. She is also at work on the Naked Politics podcast, which launches later this month. But will she ever run for office again? “I’m not writing anything off,” she said, but also made it clear that now is not the time. She is, however, living in D.C. and has been seen around Capitol Hill, an indication that she could be sticking around politics for the long haul.Through telling her story in her book, launching her PAC, and starting a podcast, Hill is slowly learning about who she is as a person without her ex. She knows there are people who want to stop not only her, but also all women who are vocal about their experiences. But she also knows that her fight is bigger than her opponents. “I think what some people want is for me to disappear,” Hill told me. “That’s a decision I’ve chosen not to make.” Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Katie Hill Rips Republicans Who Flipped Her SeatKatie Hill Talks Her Mental Health StrugglesKatie Hill Slams Congress' Sexist Double Standard

  • Trump’s Plan To Deliver A Speech At Gettysburg Has Incurred Twitter’s Wrath

    Twitter, as it often does, had some questions for Donald Trump on Monday when “Gettysburg” began trending on the social media platform thanks to the president’s latest election-related tweet. Trump announced that the location of where he would accept the Republican Party’s nomination for his reelection was coming soon, tweeting that “We have narrowed the Presidential Nomination Acceptance Speech, to be delivered on the final night of the Convention (Thursday), to two locations — The Great Battlefield of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, and the White House, Washington, D.C. We will announce the decision soon!”The suggestion that he might host his acceptance speech at Gettysburg — the site of a literal war brought on by Confederates in the South — naturally left room for wide criticism. At Twitter’s obvious behest, many pundits pointed out how Trump’s gross choice of location speaks to his recent defense of confederate behavior (like protecting monuments and denouncing the Black Lives Matter movement), as well as just his general fascist-like conduct. The results? Well, here are some pointed criticisms:> Gettysburg would be quite the choice, given the president’s recent defense of generals from the side that lost that battle> > — Jonathan Lemire (@JonLemire) August 10, 2020> He knows his side lost at Gettysburg, doesn’t he?> > — Jed Shugerman (@jedshug) August 10, 2020> If he gives the speech at Gettysburg he absolutely should be required by law to put on a fake beard> > — Seth Mandel (@SethAMandel) August 10, 2020> but gettysburg is the site of one of your base’s greatest defeats> > — Oliver Willis (@owillis) August 10, 2020While Trump’s behavior and defense of white supremacy is always shocking, it should come as little to no surprise at this point. Trump has gone to bat numerous times over the years for the preservation of the Confederate Army’s past: from threatening to veto bills seeking to rename military bases after generals like Gen. Robert E. Lee, to his long standing defense of the presence of Confederate statues around the U.S., which dates back to at least 2017. His ardent defense of the symbols and names made famous because of the Confederate Army has raised eyebrows for years considering the Confederacy was infamously pro-slavery and compiled of white supremacists. He has also championed the lives of famous Confederate generals, whether he fully has a grasp on what they stood for or not. But tweeting that Gettysburg is in the running for where he wants to give his acceptance speech is especially ironic given that the Confederate Army lost against the Union Army during the Battle of Gettysburg in 1863. Calling it the “Great Battlefield,” Trump is now just blatantly supporting the bigoted beliefs that mounted into the Confederate Army, and he is doing so at a time when the country is seeking justice for violence against Black people. But some onlookers voiced more serious concerns with Trump’s possible presence at Gettysburg, given that more than 3,500 Union soldiers are buried at the Gettysburg National Cemetery. Many noted that Trump giving the speech atop their many graves is a sign of disrespect, given what the Union stood for. Others likened his possible presence as the beginnings of another Civil War.The Republican National Convention takes place on Monday, August 24 and ends on Thursday, August 27, when Trump will make his announcement. Until then, one can only hope he picks literally anywhere that wasn’t the site of a Confederate-induced war for his acceptance speech.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Trump Wanted His Face On Mount Rushmore. OK!Trump Gives TikTok 45 Days To Sell To U.S. CompanyTrump: Joe Biden Will "Hurt God" If Elected

  • Ganni Just Collaborated With Levi’s In The Best Possible Way

    Copenhagen Fashion Week is usually a highlight of summer and not just because of the city’s laid-back feel, effortlessly cool crowd, and sun-soaked canals. Compared to Fashion Month’s Big Four – New York, London, Paris, and Milan – Copenhagen is a much smaller affair and has thus written its own rules. Operating at a luxuriously slower pace, the shows are spaced out; lazy lunches punctuate the schedule, and brands’ evening events feel more like family gatherings than corporate functions (guests often end up dancing on tables into the early hours). The Danes have always done it differently but spring ’21, kicking off in the capital today, is a world away from seasons past. Back in January, Ganni, Scandinavia’s most successful sartorial export, used its fall ’20 collection to ask: “What will 2020 bring us?” The decade began with catastrophe — bushfires ripped through Australia; news of a contagious virus was rumbling across the West; tensions between the US and Iran reminded us how close nuclear conflict could be — but even so, none of us had any idea just how radically different 2020 would shape up to be. “It’s been a crazy year so far and it took a turn no one had expected,” co-founder and creative director, Ditte Reffstrup, told me ahead of today’s show. “I think everyone has been doubtful of whether they were in the right place or doing the right thing — I know I have.” Ganni, though, has always championed optimism. In the face of a terrifying start to the year, the fall ’20 show was a defiant and hopeful look to the 12 months ahead. Calling upon its community of creatives and teaming up with 20 artists across assorted mediums, deadstock fabrics were turned into exclusive products and pop-ups brought a slice of Copenhagen Fashion Week to the brand’s flagships in London and New York. Where fashion feels turgid with unnecessary and uninspiring brand collaborations, Ganni’s approach always feels fresh, in part because they’re never about slapping two names on an item and hoping their customer takes the bait. Instead, Ditte and Nicolaj (her partner in business and in life) invite people from their network to look at things with a fresh pair of eyes. “It’s not about a brand moment for me; I love the synergy and new ideas that come from working together — it takes two! When you collaborate you don’t stand still, you keep evolving.” Evolution is surely what we’re all hoping will be the silver lining of this dark, uncertain year. Searching for answers to the question posed last season, Ganni 202020 brings together a cast of creators — “a mix of old and new friends from near and far” — to launch a three-day exhibition exploring the decade ahead. The exhibition unites Ganni’s community — from Berlin and Stockholm to Montreal and London — through a five-piece multimedia installation (or Gesamtkunstwerk) brought to life by seven collaborators. Those unable to visit IRL can immerse themselves online, too. You can listen to journalist Marjon Carlos narrate her essay on the strange intimacy and catharsis of community under COVID, and watch the new collection float and fly around a video orchestrated by Maria “Decida” Wahlberg (also known as Robyn’s choreographer) in lieu of a catwalk show. Unable to congregate in person, the artist Rosie Marks has made cut-outs of Ganni’s gang to populate the exhibition space, while elsewhere, Hayley Blomquist has created a larger than life, hand-knitted installation using vintage Levi’s and repurposed Ganni denim. Recreating the idea of a museum gift shop, merch is available to buy, too: all the KIOSK products, from long-sleeved slogan tees to customized denim jackets, are upcycled from past collections, keeping the minimum waste ethos in line with the brand’s eco-conscious approach. “It’s like when you go to a concert and you love it so much, you just have to buy the shirt,” Ditte says of the capsule. “A little memory from this bubble, this moment in time.” For Ganni, eschewing a runway show this season has “been like hitting the refresh button.” Copenhagen Fashion Week was the first to announce a radical rethink of the way it presents fashion to consumers, with brands having to meet a set of sustainability requirements in order to show on schedule, aiming to reduce its carbon footprint by 50% over the next three years, and minimizing travel to and during the shows. In offering a community-first, long-form “happening,” Ganni is giving itself the time to slow down, reassess, and breathe. “We have to do things more responsibly,” says Ditte. “If you don’t, there won’t be a spot for you in the industry in years to come.” The brand has long been working behind the scenes on impressive sustainability initiatives and practices but transparency is a new priority for 2020. “Is it relevant to do four main collections a year and produce 13 to 15 sample collections? Do we need a physical showroom and teams flying around the world? Honesty is something we really have to hold on to,” Ditte muses. Over 50% of the brand’s collections are already made from recycled, certified, or organic materials, and this season’s “healthy pause” has only strengthened their goals. Once again proving that collaborations aren’t dead, this season Ganni has teamed up with Levi’s on an ingenious circular capsule collection of rental denim. “Designed to be worn by many, owned by none,” with the premise that denim only gets better with age, Ditte and the team handpicked every pair of 501s from the Levi’s archives and upcycled and repurposed them to create a collection brimming with blouses featuring XXL collars, Western-style shirt dresses and, of course, jeans. With the aim of “sharing your denim and passing it on,” you can sign up to Ganni Repeat to wear pieces before sending them on their way for another person to rent in the future.While we’re savvy to bigger labels’ boasts and greenwashing, Ganni has always conceded that the road to a circular brand takes time and lots of small victories. It’s this quiet commitment and candid transparency that has cultivated its loyal following. Of course, you buy Ganni for the design — Ditte’s inherent positivity translates into sunny prints and playful silhouettes suitable for any and all occasions, lockdown or not — but also to be a part of the community. Whether it’s seeing how people around the world style their blouses with XXL collars, leopard-print sports shorts, and cross-body utility bags, or absorbing the diverse perspectives from their global network through an immersive exhibition, community is and has always been at the heart of Ganni. And if 2020 has taught us anything, there’s nothing more important than that.Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?Ganni & Richie Shazam Support The Black CommunityFound: 12 Deals You Can Score On Ganni TodayGanni’s Archive Sale Is What Dreams Are Made Of