Billie Eilish is the latest celebrity accused of 'queerbaiting.' What does that mean?
The release of Billie Eilish’s latest video — "Lost Cause," in which she has a raucous slumber party with a bunch of her girlfriends who dance, strike sexy poses, eat snacks and basically goof around — has prompted some fans to call her out on social media with a very specific charge: "queerbaiting."
"Hey can Billie Eilish stop queerbaiting please. She knows what she's doing," noted one tweet.
Another asked, "Is Billie Eilish bi? Or did I just watch four minutes of queerbaiting done by a straight person."
And another: "Is it just me that feels like Billie Eilish's new music video is just straight-up queerbaiting?"
In the comments section of her video, the majority of which were overwhelmingly positive, some had doubts: "I loooveee billie but this kinda seems a bit like she's queer baiting yk what i mean??"
The discussion was even more robust on TikTok, where many fans and critics posted videos wading in, with one declaring, "Acting sexual with girls to draw in more audience is gross."
First of all, what is queerbaiting?
"In media, queerbaiting often manifests in the form of a coded romance or other type of representation that alludes to being LGBTQ, but never actually confirms or depicts that representation," Rich Ferraro, chief communications officer at GLAAD, the watchdog for fair and accurate LGBTQ media representation, tells Yahoo Life about the idea, sometimes called "gaybaiting." "We often see it from brands or talent who are trying to market products or projects to the community and have a goal not to create change, but to profit from LGBTQ dollars."
Further, he adds, "For a community that has historically been underrepresented in media and continues to lack enough visibility in film, television, advertising and more, queerbaiting has been called out time and again by our community and flies in the face of how to authentically and meaningfully engage with LGBTQ people."
Queerbaiting used to mean "these characters express queerness in the text, but the creators deny it."
People are now using it to mean "these characters didn't perform queerness accedptably, even though the creators said they were," which is.... literally the opposite of that.
— Ace in your face (@HippieGeekGirl) June 5, 2021
For additional context, Ferraro points to GLAAD's most recent research with Proctor & Gamble, which found that 81 percent of advertisers are concerned about being perceived as authentic when creating LGBTQ campaigns — prompting GLAAD to launch the Visibility Project to work with brands "to avoid queerbaiting and use their reach to create content that drives impact."
That's because the idea of using allusions to LGBTQ romance in order to gain fans or viewers can come in any form of media, including advertising, social media, TV shows, film and pop music.
Who else has prompted queerbaiting accusations?
Television shows are often called out for teasing LGBTQ sex or romance and not following through — with the relationship between Kara and Lena on Supergirl an example, just for starters, along with that of Betty and Veronica on Riverdale — not to mention the originals, Xena and Gabrielle on Xena. And then there's Killing Eve. "A trickier but often-cited example is the relationship between Eve (Sandra Oh) and Villanelle (Jodie Comer) on Killing Eve," noted PureWow. "Villanelle is an openly queer character…but the relentless suggestion of a relationship between Villanelle and the supposedly straight Eve is what's raised fans' eyebrows. But when Oh and Comer gave an interview to Gay Times, Oh dismissed the idea of a relationship, saying, 'You guys are tricky because you want to make it into something… but it just isn’t.'"
That was the trailer for the episode in which Kara went above and beyond to keep Lena safe and promised to always protect her. The episode in which Lena chose to save Kara's life over her ex's. I guess that's how far they would go for love. Stop the queerbaiting. Make them canon. pic.twitter.com/AcKdlPq9eJ
— Myrto (@kaleluvers) June 6, 2021
According to Pink News, "By adding homoerotic subtext or erotic tension between two characters, usually leads, LGBTQ audiences are enticed to tune in, unaware that there was never an intention to elevate the subtext to an actual relationship. Bleugh." The story continues, "The powers that be use LGBTQ characters and relationships as bait, in order to appeal to the gay dollar and the queer views, without actually following through. It’s just enough to keep LGBT people interested, without having to really represent us."
Billie Eilish isn't the only pop star or celebrity to have faced the accusation — Taylor Swift, Nick Jonas, Harry Styles, Ariana Grande, Tyler Posey and James Franco have all been accused of the same at different points in their careers, with Jonas addressing the charges back in 2014 by saying, "Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion. I think it's unfortunate that some people have to find a negative in every situation. Clearly my heart is in the right place, and more than anything, if they just looked at my life and my gay friends and the authentic nature of where my heart is, they’d just see that they’re kind of ignorant." He later told Out that the accusations were "really quite sad."
Ariana Grande Dropped A New Music Video And It's Sparked A Huge Debate About Queerbaiting https://t.co/BPh9o1VHgv
— BuzzFeed (@BuzzFeed) February 8, 2019
Still, this is not the first time Eilish has faced this accusation, as fans first cried queerbaiting in 2019, in response to the song "Wish You Were Gay." She responded, saying, "First off I want to be so clear that it's so not supposed to be an insult. I feel like it's been a little bit misinterpreted. I tried so hard to not make it in any way offensive. The whole idea of the song is, it's kind of a joke. It's kind of like 'I'm an ass and you don't love me.' And you don't love me because you don't love me and that's the only reason and I wish you didn't love me because you didn't love girls… It's just supposed to be ‘I'm selfish and an ass.’
Though she's not commented on the current discourse, she recently told British Vogue, "My thing is that I can do whatever I want… It's all about what makes you feel good. If you want to get surgery, go get surgery. If you want to wear a dress that somebody thinks that you look too big wearing, f**k it – if you feel like you look good, you look good."
Still, some TikTokers are going to great pains to explain why they believe her "Lost Cause" video is problematic.
"If you've seen the video, it's very clearly like sexual…they're twerking on each other," noted one user. "And I've had people say to me that they're just like being good friends, but…she could have shown that they were good friends in any other way."
Another breaks it down with many explanations of what she sees as the problem, including, "Acting sexual with girls to draw in more audience is gross…lgbtq people barely have any representation in the media so when any exists we cling to it, we are so desperate to feel seen. Queerbaiting is dangerous because it unravels this scenario. It invalidates it."
"She says that she's straight…" another user says, adding, "The only reason Billie's not really getting s**t for it is because everyone just thinks she gay."
Plenty, of course, disagree with the criticism, noting that Billie is possibly "hinting towards her sexuality since it's pride month," and pointing out, "we don't know her sexuality nor are we obligated to."
Unpopular opinion probably idk. Billie Eilish is not queerbaiting. She's said in her same interview one year later that she's trying to figure out who she is identity wise and sexuality wise. In her new mv I understand why people think she is queerbaiting but I also feel (1/2)
— JodieisLemon (@_Jodieislemon_) June 4, 2021
(2/2) like people see she is being "cancelled" and jump on the bandwagon with little knowledge. The same thing happened with 'wish you were gay'. In my opinion she is hinting towards her sexuality since it's pride month. No one did it when Harry released lights up mv so why now?
— JodieisLemon (@_Jodieislemon_) June 4, 2021
maybe we shouldn’t say that billie eilish is queerbaiting considering the fact that we don’t know her sexuality and aren’t obligated to 😄
— 𝖘𝖔𝖋𝖎𝖆⛓🖤 (dilf wife arc) (@edgydad666) June 8, 2021
In the comments section of her video, Eilish fans were overwhelmingly approving, with one writing: "SHE'S FEELING HERSELF AS SHE SHOULD‼️ Looking stunning as ever‼️"
Read more from Yahoo Life:
Dyllón Burnside of 'Pose' on being queer: 'News flash! I sleep with who I want'
Tan France and confidence and becoming a dad: 'I've had to wait a very long time to make this happen'
The Teletubbies embrace Pride, more than two decades after 'gay' Tinky Winky scandal
Want lifestyle and wellness news delivered to your inbox? Sign up here for Yahoo Life’s newsletter.