*Warning: Spoilers ahead*

Last night on The Bachelor, Colton Underwood (finally!) jumped the fence after Cassie voluntarily left the show. And now, the 26-year-old star came face-to-face with the eliminated contestants for the very first time.

Here’s what went down on The Bachelor: The Women Tell All.

Welcome to ‘The Women Tell All’

The episode opens with Chris Harrison recapping last night’s episode. (You know, when Underwood’s “greatest fear” came true.)

Without further adieu, the host introduces the 20 returning contestants, including Alex B., Demi, Caelynn, Bri, Tahzjuan, Kirpa, Jane, Hannah B., Alex D., Onyeka, Nina, Heather, Angelique, Courtney, Tracy, Sydney, Katie, Nicole, Caitlin and Catherine.

In a surprising twist, Hannah B. receives the loudest applause from the live studio audience. We wouldn’t be surprised if she paid them…

After Harrison plays a video featuring the most “memorable breakups and breakdowns” in Bachelor history, he resumes his position on-stage and kicks off the show.

The Feuds

When Harrison asks the women how they feel about Underwood’s virginity, Demi confirms that she hasn’t changed one bit.

She says, “Is it weird that I was a little bit turned on?”

After playing a video highlighting this season’s feuds, Courtney immediately starts screaming at Demi, asking what she did to her. When Onyeka and Nicole chime in, Harrison interrupts the cat fight and demands they begin with Onyeka and Nicole.

Although Nicole claims she was “bullied,” Onyeka dismisses her accusations before saying, “thank you, next.” Nicole reminds her that she called her “emotionally unstable,” and Sydney backs her up, claiming Onyeka went out of her way to belittle Nicole.

Onyeka says she stands by her side of the story, and we don’t know who to believe.

Katie vs. Caelynn

Next, Harrison presses Katie about when she told Underwood that some of the women aren’t ready for marriage. She reveals that she was mainly talking about Cassie and Caelynn, who apparently had a conversation about becoming the next Bachelorette after the show.

This prompts the Miss Carolina queen to confront Katie for “throwing everyone under the bus.” When Katie says that Hannah B. was right about Caelynn’s “manipulative” personality, all hell breaks loose.

Harrison chimes in and gives Caelynn the floor. “You cannot tell another woman whether or not they’re ready for marriage,” she tells Katie. “I’m sorry.”

When Harrison asks for Hannah B.’s opinion, she sides with Katie (surprise, surprise) before revealing that she’s in a “good place” with her former roommate. *Eye roll*

Demi, Demi, Demi

Harrison transitions the conversation to Demi, who refuses to apologize for her actions on the show. When Courtney chimes in, she goes on a rant about Demi’s childish behavior—like when she called her the “cancer of the house.”

Demi’s response? “It’s 2019, and you still haven’t talked to Colton,” she says before adding, “I need a shot now.” Gotta love her.

When the host invites her to the hot seat, Demi seems proud of her controversial season. Not only does she admit that the virginity angle “excited” her, but she also smiles uncontrollably when Harrison compliments her, er, creativity during the show.

Although Demi gets emotional while talking about her departure in episode six, she reveals that she’s happier than ever, despite the fact that she lost her strongest relationship to date. (Which is saying a lot…)

Nicole Gets Rewarded

When Nicole trades places with Demi, Harrison recaps her journey, which consisted of lots and lots of tears. Nicole reveals that she grew up with her heart on her sleeve, and since she takes care of her disabled brother, she has a soft spot for sentimental life events.

To “help process her emotions,” Harrison reveals that Halo Top Creamery is giving her a year’s supply of ice cream. Nicole responds by crying. (Natch.)

“This made all the tears worth it,” she says.

Hannah B.'s Comeback

Next in the hot seat is Hannah B. Although she still has “mixed emotions” about getting sent home in episode seven, she’s proud of herself for opening up as much as she did, considering she’s always felt pressure to be perfect.

Since she refuses to settle, Hannah B. wants to use her experience with Underwood to be more vulnerable in future relationships.

Right on cue, Harrison whips out a bottle of Champagne and asks her to redo her botched toast from episode two. After stalling for time, Hannah B. gets through the entire toast without giggling, and all we have to say is…progress.

The Group Confronts Colton

Last (but not least), Caelynn joins Harrison on-stage. She’s in tears after watching a video recapping her time on the show, claiming “it’s not easy to see.”

You see, she thought she had “met her person.” So, she’s been overanalyzing every episode trying to find evidence that he did, in fact, love her. She doesn’t understand how they can go from meeting her family to “nothing.”

When Caelynn returns to the group, Underwood comes out and takes a seat next to Harrison. Caelynn asks when he knew that she wasn’t the one, and Underwood reveals that it all came down to the rose ceremony.

He apologizes to the group for hurting anyone’s feelings, which prompts Sydney to address the elephant in the room.

“Are you still a virgin?” she asks.

He doesn’t answer. In fact, he beats around the bush and asks Sydney a question instead. Sketchy, indeed.

When Harrison presses him about the infamous fence jump, Underwood reveals that it was a result of Cassie not reciprocating his feelings.

At long last, the host brings us to our favorite part of The Women Tell All: the bloopers. After playing a clip featuring behind-the-scenes fails (“nailed it!”), the host teases a sneak peek of next week’s finale that proves yesterday’s drama is only the beginning.

The Bachelor returns to ABC for a two-night finale beginning Monday, March 11, at 8 p.m.

RELATED: Here’s What Colton Underwood Had to Say About Who Should Be the Next Bachelorette