We Asked People To Tell Us About Their Absolute Dream Movie Castings, And The Answers Are Incredible

We recently asked members of our BuzzFeed Community, "What's your absolute ultimate dream movie casting? Whether it's an actor for a specific character, a specific movie, or even just a specific genre?" and you better believe they came through with some absolutely incredible answers!

A man yelling "WHY CAN'T I HAVE THE THINGS THAT I WANT?"
A man yelling "WHY CAN'T I HAVE THE THINGS THAT I WANT?"

Fox

So, with that in mind, here are just a few of the most popular responses shared! Let's start with specific characters and/or specific movies:

1.Ke Huy Quan as the lead in a new Indiana Jones franchise

Ke Huy Quan on the Oscars red carpet smiling and pointing at the camera
Frederic J. Brown / AFP via Getty Images, Paramount Pictures / Getty Images

"I want Ke Huy Quan as the new Indiana Jones. He could come back as a grown-up Short Round and take over the role from Harrison Ford! Bonus: He’s worked as a stunt coordinator on previous movies!"

rachelc43

2.Caleb McLaughlin as Miles Morales in the Marvel Cinematic Universe

Caleb McLaughlin attends the premiere of Netflix's
Amy Sussman / Getty Images, Sony Pictures Animation / ©Columbia Pictures/courtesy Everett Co / Everett Collection

"Caleb Mclaughlin as Miles Morales would be AMAZING!"

isabelabn

3.Claudia Jessie as Jane Porter in Disney's Tarzan

Claudia Jessie attends the Pride Of Birmingham Awards 2018 at University of Birmingham
Stuart C. Wilson / Getty Images, Buena Vista Pictures / ©Buena Vista Pictures/Courtesy Everett Collection

"Claudia Jessie was born to play Jane Porter in a live-action version of Disney's Tarzan. She's British, looks like the character, would kill in a yellow dress, and she's witty and funny. Plus, she's already got a fanbase from her work in Bridgerton!"

zoecatherinegrant

4.Oscar Isaac as Harvey Dent in The Batman franchise

Oscar Isaac on the red carpet of the movie
Mondadori Portfolio / Mondadori Portfolio via Getty Images, Warner Bros / ©Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection

"I really want Oscar Isaac as Harvey Dent in the Robert Pattinson Batman universe."

niallh459ac7a2b

5.Jared Keeso as Logan (aka Wolverine) in a new X-Men franchise

Jared Keeso of 19-2 attends the CTV 2014 Upfront at Sony Centre for the Performing Arts
George Pimentel / Getty Images, 20thcentfox / ©20thCentFox/Courtesy Everett Collection

"Jared Keeso (Wayne from Letterkenny) would make a GREAT Logan/Wolverine. He has the build, he is Canadian, the scowl is perfect, and he is the toughest guy in Letterkenny. He ticks all the right boxes."

maggisaarb

6.Rami Malek as the lead in a Knives Out film

Rami Malek attends the 2020 Vanity Fair Oscar Party hosted by Radhika Jones at Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts
Rich Fury / Getty Images for Vanity Fair, / ©Lions Gate/Courtesy Everett Collection

"Rami Malek as a new Knives Out protagonist — a character like Marta and Helen! Plus, his chemistry was so good with Daniel Craig in No Time to Die, it would be good seeing them go from on-screen enemies to on-screen friends."

tanyam44ab2253d

7.Josh Brolin and Charlize Theron as Rourke and Helga in Disney's Atlantis: The Lost Empire

Josh Brolin and Charlize Theron pose together on a red carpet
Donato Sardella / WireImage / Getty Images, Walt Disney Co. / ©Walt Disney Co./Courtesy Everett Collection

"We all know Atlantis: The Lost Empire is ignored by Disney and consistently slept on, and — while the original is perfect — a lot of people want a live-action version. Josh Brolin and Charlize Theron were practically made to play Rourke and Helga (the villains)."

monikap6

8.Evan Peters as Alex in A Clockwork Orange

Evan Peters poses on the red carpet
Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images, © Turner Classic Movies /Courtesy Everett Collection

"I think most reboots are bad, but Evan Peters would be perfect as Alex if there was ever a reboot of A Clockwork Orange."

sofiaberdein

9.Andrew Garfield as Remus Lupin in the Harry Potter franchise

Andrew Garfield poses on the red carpet
Jeff Kravitz / FilmMagic / Getty Images, Warner Bros / ©Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection

"ANDREW GARFIELD AS REMUS LUPIN. I WILL DIE ON THIS HILL."

innismaisie

10.Dave Bautista and Gwendolyn Christie as the leads in a remake of Marty

A man holds a woman
Courtesy Everett Collection, Leon Bennett / Getty Images, Rich Polk / Getty Images for IMDb

"Dave Bautista and Gwendolyn Christie in a remake of Paddy Chayefsky's Marty would be great."

ladicair

11.Taylor Swift as Alison Blaire (aka Dazzler) in a new X-Men franchise

Taylor Swift sings on stage during her eras tour
Omar Vega / Getty Images for TAS Rights Management, 20th Century Fox

"I mean, just look at her on the Eras Tour!"

sghuntress

12.Zac Efron as Ryland Grace in an adaptation of Project Hail Mary

Zac Efron smiles on the red carpet
Brendon Thorne / Getty Images, Ballantine Books

"Efron would absolutely crush it as Ryland Grace. The character is smart, attractive, relatively young, and not a little sarcastic. I’d love to see Efron in that role."

micahdr

13.Willem Dafoe as the Joker in The Batman franchise

Willem Dafoe smiles on the red carpet
Axelle / FilmMagic / Getty Images, Niko Tavernise / © Warner Bros. / courtesy Everett Collection

"That's all."

bhs58

14.Idris Elba as James Bond in a new 007 franchise

Closeup of Idris Elba
Emma Mcintyre / Getty Images, Nicola Dove / © MGM / © Danjaq / Courtesy Everett Collection

"My dream James Bond movie cast would be Elba as Bond, Kate Beckinsale as a Bond girl, Gary Oldman as M, and Tilda Swinton as Q. This might be the only time the actor playing Bond wasn't 20 years older than the actress playing the Bond girl."

markh63

15.Sophie Turner as Astrid in an adaptation of The Waterfire Saga

A woman on the red carpet
Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images, Disney-Hyperion

"When I was in middle school, everyone was obsessed with these books called The Waterfire Saga by Jennifer Donnelly, which was about these six mermaids who team up to save the world. I was OBSESSED, so much so that I still have a Google Doc of my dream cast of the entire series, down to the smallest side character. Anyway, it all started the first time I saw a picture of Turner and immediately thought of Astrid, one of the six mermaids."

bettyjames

And finally, a few non-specific roles people just want to see:

16.Leonardo DiCaprio in a comedy

Leonardo DiCaprio attends the 92nd Annual Academy Awards
Jeff Kravitz / FilmMagic / Getty Images

"I would love to see DiCaprio play a weird main character in a genuine comedy. I think he could pull it off, and it would be a nice change of pace!"

bree-nb

17.Dwayne Johnson, Terry Crews, and Daniel Radcliffe as co-leads in a comedy

Dwayne Johnson of MOANA took part today in
Jesse Grant / Getty Images for Disney, Rodin Eckenroth / FilmMagic / Getty Images, Michael Loccisano / Getty Images

"I want The Rock and Crews to do a comedy together where they’re doing something unexpected like raising someone’s baby. And, of course, a short king like Radcliffe to round it all out."

f4bul0u5

18.Adam Driver as the lead in a queer romantic comedy

Adam Driver walks the red carpet ahead of the "Marriage Story" screening during during the 76th Venice Film Festival
Theo Wargo / Getty Images

"I want Driver in a queer rom-com just so I can watch him be a himbo for 90-120 minutes. Even better if his love interest is also some type of action hero actor you wouldn’t expect in a movie like that."

enbyviking

19.Chicha Amatayakul and Daniel Kaluuya as co-leads in a romantic comedy

Chicha Amatayakul attends the Saint Laurent Womenswear Fall Winter 2023-2024 show as part of Paris Fashion Week
Pascal Le Segretain / Getty Images, Abc / ABC via Getty Images

"I want to see Amatayakul and Kaluuya in a relatable, messy rom-com together. Something in vein of Netflix's Love or Fleabag."

tanyam44ab2253d

And finally:

20.Sebastian Stan as the lead in a romantic comedy

WATCH WHAT HAPPENS LIVE WITH ANDY COHEN -- Pictured: Sebastian Stan
Charles Sykes/Bravo / NBCU Photo Bank / NBCUniversal via Getty Images

"I just want to see Sebastian Stan in a rom-com. He plays mentally-unhinged characters so well, but I want to see him in a cheesy '90s-style rom-com. I just feel like he’d be really good because the first half of Fresh had that vibe...emphasis on FIRST HALF."

lalalace1640

All right, you've read theirs, but now, it's your turn! What's your absolute dream movie casting? Share in the comments below!

Some responses were edited for length and/or clarity.