70 Nostalgic Stocking Stuffers Grown-Up '90s Kids Will Love Even More Than Ring Pops

Test your '90s knowledge with this That's So '90s Team Trivia Game ($29).

This Hatching Virtual Pet Candle ($28) is like a Tamagotchi in candle form - it hides a surprise pet inside!

Channel Clueless's Cher with this pink "As If" Baseball Hat ($16).

This You're a Virgin Who Can't Drive Keychain ($8) is way harsh - but totally '90s.

Stick-On Earrings ($7 for 72-day pack) are a '90s beauty must have.

Who doesn't remember writing their crush's name over and over again with this Sakura 6-Piece Gelly Roll Assorted Colors Stardust Meteor Pen Set ($12)?

Give the original virtual-reality pet, Tamagotchi V5 Game ($25), for someone who's been hankering for a cuddly companion.

Buy a grown-up version of the friendship bracelets we wore as kids with this Badass Beaded Stretch Bracelet ($20).

So many gems in this set of Fresh Prince Nail Decals ($7).

Relive the days of binge-reading The Baby-Sitters Club books with these adorable The Baby-Sitters Club Earrings ($12).

Does it get any cooler than this tiger-print 35B By Lisa Frank Artistry Palette ($30)??

Start your morning on the wild side with this Jurassic Park Park Ranger Mug ($15).

This Aaliyah Ombre T-Shirt Dress ($39) is perfect for a friend who memorized the dance moves to "We Need a Resolution."

This World's Smallest UO Exclusive Tie-Dye Magic 8 Ball ($8) will bring back the days of vague fortune telling.

Put a smile on a friend's face with this Friends Photo Frame Mug ($18).

Give this Loungefly Disney A Goofy Movie Max and Roxanne Enamel Pin ($8) to the Max to your Roxanne.

This Sanrio Hello Kitty Wireless Earbuds Case ($20) is both cute and practical!

Gamers will be obsessed with this Video Game Trivia ($13).

Give this Blockbuster Party Game ($28) to a lucky friend who has a soft spot for renting movies.

Pizza and Pixar fans alike will be all about these Disney Pixar Toy Story Pizza Planet Cozy Slipper Socks ($15).

See just how big of a '90s fan they are when you give them this Totally '90s Board Game ($28).

This Olivia Rubin Connie Scrunchie Set ($50 for two) is perfect for a hairdo inspired by Kimmy Gibbler.

Be kind and rewind the Toy Story "VHS Case" Clutch ($28).

This Nintendo NES Controller Cardholder ($17) will delight a gamer who has a sweet spot for their old Nintendo NES.

Throw it back to the days of sticker-covered notebooks with this Wildflower UO Exclusive Sticker Book iPhone Case ($35).

Don't forget to include some yummy treats like Bubble Tape and Warheads, which come in this fun 1990s Nancy Adams Nostalgic Candy Mix Gift Box ($15).

Don't forget to find the original '90s Littlest Pet Shop! We love this Littlest Pet Shop Cutesy Kittens With Kitten Playhouse Cat Playset 1992 ($27).

Mmm, smells like Lip Smacker Coca-Cola Party Pack Lip Glosses ($11 for eight)!

A '90s hairstyle wasn't complete without a Butterfly Hair Clip Set ($6 for six).

Give someone the gift of retro gaming with this Boardwalk Arcade Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Electronic Pinball ($20).

Remember how fun it was collecting Happy Meal toys like these mini 1991 Barbie McDonald's Happy Meal Dolls ($7 each)?

Kids of the '90s loved Polly Pockets. So give them a vintage Polly Pocket Kozy Kitten 1993 ($65)!

Fans of the TV show will love this Friends Purple Door iPhone 12 Pro Case ($49)!

This addictive Handheld Tetris Arcade Game ($20) will be a hit!

This Kodak FunSaver Disposable Camera ($16) is an ode to the old school, pre-iPhone days of taking photos with a real camera.

Get classy with your '90s jewelry by donning this Smiley Face Necklace ($15).

No Christmas is complete without tiger-adorned Lisa Frank Headphones ($125).

Find '90s Beanie Babies on eBay, like these 1999 Beanie Babies
($6 each), for a trip down memory lane.

Give the It doll of the '90s, a 1998 Furby ($80), to a lucky loved one with a sweet spot for the furry creatures.

Bright green Gak ($14) is sure to transform anyone back into their '90s self.

They'll be able to rock out to Backstreet Boys with this Lisa Frank Husky Dog Pup Compact Star Speaker ($25).

For the friend who's always rollin' with the homies, give them this Clueless Minimalist Movie Poster ($25).

Collectors are serious about their Cupcake Dolls ($31), but if you can snag one of these Tonka dolls, you'll make a grown-up '90s kid's day!

You can't give just any Barbie; it has to be something iconic to the '80s and '90s like Totally Hair Barbie (price varies)!

Does it get any cuter than these Polly Pocket Earrings ($10)? I think not.

A cute World's Smallest My Little Pony ($10) will brighten a '90s pal's day!

Throw it way back to recess Pog games with these 1990s Pog Slammers ($31 for three) from the early '90s.

There's nothing like a scent memory, so give the ultimate nostalgic gift with an awesome '90s perfume like Sunflowers by Elizabeth Arden ($29).

Most '90s babies remember the endless crafting possibilities made with Pepperell Polyester Loops ($7).

Harken back to the good ol' days of floppys with a funky Floppy Disk Notebook ($8).

Go for a Lanyard Keychain ($10) that's already made, or give a lanyard-making kit for a DIY project.

They can have a totally grown-up sticker trading party with this Lisa Frank Sticker Book ($15).

Get nostalgic with this World's Smallest Lite Brite ($11).

These retro Daria and Jane Necklaces ($20 for set of two) would make the best gift for your BFF.

Bring on the Roll-On Body Glitter ($8); you can never be too sparkly.

Santa, if you're listening, we need this Aladdin Tiger Handheld Game ($53) ASAP.

Remember playing this game as kids? Now there's the World's Smallest Rock 'Em Sock 'Em Robots ($11), perfect for a stocking stuffer!

Girls from the '90s know that Hard Candy Nail Polish ($4) was the best - it came with a ring!

Hellooo, you gotta have Mad Libs ($4); it's a sleepover must!

Show some love to the hair-raising toys of the '90s with this Troll Bank ($20).

Give these Scented Glitter Jelly Bracelets ($25 for 144) to a stylin' friend.

Purses nowadays are so . . . adult. Take it back a few years with this Hologram Purse ($20).

You know you gotta rock these New Kids on the Block Hoops ($10) on a night out.

Remember when it was all about round colored sunglasses like these Rayanne Metal Round Sunglasses ($18)?

The ultimate in '90s jewelry: a Tattoo Chokers Set ($15 for 12).

The '90s are so cool these days. There's even a cool Furry Black Slap Bracelet Set ($20, originally $34) available to buy. Slap it on!

These yellow Smiley Face Earrings ($13) are chic and cute!

Flash your retro Yin Yang Earrings ($14) to fellow '90s-lovers. They know where it's at.

How hilarious is this "Don't Be a Brenda" Shirt ($14-$35)?

Totally '90s Coloring Book ($11) is alllll that.