40 Unique First Mother's Day Gift Ideas That Are Extra Thoughtful

"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."

There’s something extra special about a mom's very first Mother’s Day. A new baby is in the house turning her life upside down in the best way possible. So it’s only fitting that the new mom in your life is presented with the best when it comes to gifts this May. To celebrate this special milestone of motherhood, we've rounded up a list of the best first Mother’s Day gifts, full of thoughtful, personalized presents beyond the typical card or sentimental Mother’s Day poem.

Finding the right gift for Mother’s Day can be tricky, but once you narrow down your options, things get a whole lot easier. Perhaps, it's a collage of photos of the new family or a cozy pair of slippers to wear around the house. Whatever mom's wishes are this year, our list has you covered with last-minute gifts you can buy on Amazon, Mother's Day gifts on a budget, push presents for the mother who just gave birth, and unique gift ideas for the mom who has everything. You might even find something you want for yourself!

Just remember, her first Mother’s Day is a once in a lifetime experience, so make sure to pick out something special for her.

Best First Mother's Day Gifts of 2024:

• Most Unique Gift: Fourth Trimester Mama New Mama Affirmation Cards

• Gift Idea from Husband: Olukai Women’s Cozy Slipper Sandals

• Gift Idea from Baby: Baby Mushroom Handprint & Footprint Keepsake Photo Kit

• Amazon Gift: Willow Tree Mother and Baby Figure

• Personalized Gift: Minted Personalized Heart Picture Collage

New Mama Affirmation Cards

Assure the new mom in your life that she's doing a great job with this 20-pack of affirmation cards made specifically for first time mothers.

Moonlight Eco Short Pajamas

According to the r/NewParents reddit thread, something as simple as a luxury pair of pajamas can mean so much to a new mom, especially when the top buttons up for easy breast-feeding.

CozyChic Feathered Arrows Throw Blanket

Barefoot Dreams produces some of the softest slippers, cardigans, and joggers out there, so it only makes sense that their blankets feel the same.

Weighted Silk Eye Pillow

If she has trouble sleeping, especially with a new baby around, she will love this weighted sleep mask infused with lavender and flax seeds. Besides sleep, it's also great to wear during headaches and migraines.

Mama and Mini Matching T-Shirts

Adorable on its own or with a matching t-shirt for her little one, this 'Mama' tee is the perfect Mother's Day gift. Make sure she opens her present in the morning, so she can sport the tee throughout the day.

Strawberry Sunset Bouquet

Gift her a one time assortment of beautiful spring flowers or sign her up for a monthly flower subscription to receive a fresh bouquet every month.

RELATED: The Flower Meanings You Need to Know Before Ordering a Bouquet

Handprint & Footprint Keepsake Photo Kit

The hardest part of this gift is going to be sneaking the baby away long enough to take some prints without momma noticing. Paired with a couple of her favorite photos, this keepsake box will be her favorite piece of decor for years to come.

RELATED: Gifts for the Mom Who Has Everything

Self Care Box

For a gift that keeps on giving, check out TheraBox's Self Care Box. This is one of Cratejoy's most popular boxes, topping their list for 2023. You can choose to gift a one-time box or a recurring box for three months, six months, or 12 months.

RELATED: Best Mother's Day Gift Baskets for Every Type of Mom

Personalized Heart Picture Collage

How many pictures do you have of the new baby? Hundreds, if not thousands, right? You definitely have enough to make a collage of Mom's first year with her little one.

Bed Tray Table

Yes, gifting a bed tray table means you need to make her breakfast in bed too. After Mother's Day, though, she can use this for light snacking, reading, or working.

Furry Feet Baby Footprint Kit

This cute take on the traditional baby footprint keepsake will bring a huge smile to her face. Choose from a bear cub, duckling, penguin, rabbit, or dinosaur.

Mother and Baby Figure

Willow Tree figurines have a way of making you tear up just by looking at them. This mother and baby figurine is the perfect symbol of Mom's close bond with her firstborn.

Tiny Baby Feet Necklace

Tiny feet on a necklace has to be the cutest thing we've ever seen! This small business has a variety of sweet jewelry pieces for new moms, but these itty-bitty feet have to be the most precious.

Mama Bear Sweatshirt

If she's ultra protective of her baby, as all great moms are, gift her this 'Mama Bear' sweatshirt that's available in 12 colors to match her style.

Women’s Cozy Slipper Sandals

Show your wife the appreciation she deserves, and splurge a bit on these cozy shearling-lined Olukai slippers. The sandal style ensures mom can wear them even in the warmer months, and the no-slip bottoms are perfect for middle-of-the-night feedings.

Personalized Nameplate Necklace

Did you know you can get personalized items through Nordstrom? This sterling silver necklace can be customized with the name of her baby. Just remember to order in advance, so it arrives in time for Mother's Day!

RELATED: Gorgeous Pieces of Mother's Day Jewelry

Mom Charm Bracelet

Out of all the pieces Alex and Ani make for moms, this is one of the simplest — and prettiest — options. The minimalistic band will be stylish for years to come, as she wears it while her little one grows.

Personalized Family Print

Immortalize your new family in art form with a personalized illustration that you can hang up anywhere. Don't forget to include your pets!

Luxurious Silk Pillowcase

Sleeping on satin is luxurious, but it also helps keep skin crease-free and hair frizz-free. Buy two so mom always has on hand.

Gift Card

If none of these options seem quite right, let her buy her own gift with an Amazon gift card. You can choose any amount. If you're sticking to a gift card, include a heartfelt card to make things a little more personal.

Foldable Bathtub Tray

If this mom is lucky enough to have a bathtub, take her bath time to the next level. She can fit snacks, wine (or tea), a candle, book or tablet, and more, on this natural wood tray.

Scent Memory Stuffable Sloth

A mother's first night away from her baby can be hard on both parties. Gift Mom reassurance and baby comfort with this stuffable sloth that can be filled with Mom's favorite item of clothing. That way, the cute sloth will smell just like Mom.

Calming Shower Steamers Gift Set

Help the brand-new mom in your life unwind with a spa-like experience at home using aromatic shower steamers. Choose from a box of five or 12 with scents such as lemongrass and lavender.

7-in-1 Electric Pressure Cooker

Make mealtime easy for mom with a pressure cooker. Instant Pot claims the machine can cook just about anything, (including yogurt!), 70% faster than other one pot meals.

New Baby Scented Candle

There's nothing better than that new baby smell, but the second best might be this fresh, baby-powder-scented candle, with undertones of geranium and vanilla, from Homesick Candle Company.

Self-Watering Plant

With a new baby in the house, the mom in your life may forget to water her plants, but that doesn't mean she needs to forego greenery all together. Gift her this self-watering plant from EasyPlant that soaks up whatever water it may need from the planter reservoir. All Mom needs to do is water it once a month.

Original Wearable Blanket

After nine months of discomfort, mom deserves a cozy, wearable blanket that she can curl up on the couch or bed with while watching her favorite show.

Linen Bedding Set

Normalize gifting good sheets! Linen sheets are a coveted item, and something she might not think to buy for herself. If her bed is her sanctuary, this is the way to go.

Modern One Line a Day Journal

One line a day might be all the time Mom has during her first year of motherhood, making this single line journal a low stakes way to track her favorite memories and notable moments throughout a five year period.

RELATED: How to Start Bible Journaling

AirTag 4 Pack

Help her fight off the effects of "Mom brain" with a pack of AirTags that will help her keep track of important items such as her keys, wallet, and diaper bag. All she has to do is connect the AirTag to her Apple device and stick them in or near the items she doesn't want to lose.

Heating Pad for Neck and Shoulders

Carrying a new baby, plus all the gear that's required for their care, can put a strain on her neck, shoulder, and back muscles. This weighted heating pad will target those places giving her the gift of comfort and relaxation.

Temperature Control Smart Mug

Make sure mom's morning (or afternoon) brew is always at the perfect temperature. The Ember Smart Mug can be easily controlled via the Ember app or with a touch of the mug, so her coffee stays at her ideal temp all day long.

Compressive Pocket Legging

While on the road of post-partum recovery, these compression leggings from Girlfriend Collective will be her new best friend. They fit snug to her body but are still comfortable for lounging and taking care of baby.

Mighty Patch for Tired Eyes

Fake the awake look with Hero Cosmetics' tired eye patches. Each pair is infused with eye-soothing ingredients for a plumping, brightening effect.

24-Ounce Wide Mouth Water Bottle

Hydration is important for everyone but especially new moms who are still recovering from birth. Make sure she's hydrated with this 24 ounce insulated water bottle from Hydro Flask.

Mobile Photo Mini Printer

The average new mom snaps thousands of photos during her baby's first year of life. Create keepsakes in seconds with a portable photo printer.

Essential Oil Diffuser with Remote Control

Essential oils can create a calm atmosphere in any room — even one with a fussy baby. Gift mom a set of relaxing scents with a new essential oil diffuser. This one features a handy remote control for easy programming.

In My Mama Era Mug

Fans of Taylor Swift and beyond will appreciate this colorful mug printed with the perfect Mother's Day slogan. She can use it for her morning cup of Joe or for her bedtime tea.

Mama Shopping Tote

Help mom stay organized with this cute 'Mama' tote. She can use it as a diaper bag, purse, or catch-all for errands and groceries. It's stylish, versatile, and Mom-themed.

Gift Card

In terms of usefulness, it doesn't get much better than a gift card for food. With a Goldbelly card, Mom can try dishes from her favorite Food Network stars, such as Guy Fieri and Ina Garten, and bites from famous restaurants, such as Pink's Hot Dogs, Junior's Cheesecake, and more.

You Might Also Like

• Oprah’s Favorite Things Of 2022 Is Here—Gift These 20 Amazing Finds This Year

• 40 Best Sentimental Gift Ideas for Loved Ones

• Jennifer Aniston‘s Secret to Glowy Skin On-Screen