21 Completely Brutal TV Deaths That Never End Up On These Kinds Of Lists

·5 min read

A while back, we asked the BuzzFeed Community to share the saddest underrated TV scenes, and we got a lot of great responses — with a ton of nominations for sad TV deaths that get overlooked!

MTV

Here are 23 super-sad TV deaths that deserve more attention.

🚨🚨WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD!🚨🚨

1.On Criminal Minds, when Hotch's wife, Haley, was murdered as she said her last words to him over the phone and everyone listened in:

Haley asks Hotch to promise to tell their son how they met and how he made her laugh so he knows Hotch wasn't always this serious and believes in love, as it's the most important thing
CBS

2.On ER, when Carter read the letter from Mark and everyone found out he was dead:

Carter reads the letter, where Mark writes about his day, and then reveals there's an addition from Dr. Corday saying he died the next morning and she sent the letter so they'd know he was thinking of them

"What a soul crusher."

jima23

NBC

3.On The Haunting of Hill House, when Olivia was manipulated into thinking her kids were in danger and then killing herself:

Olivia looking down then smiling, saying she wants to wake up

"That scene absolutely destroyed me."

misaamaneyagami

Netflix

4.On The Magicians, when Quentin sacrificed himself and his friends sang "Take on Me" to mourn him:

Quentin says "wow" as he watches his friends sing for him

"That song gets me every time."

spidsmcc79

SyFy

5.When Laverne died on Scrubs — especially when Carla said goodbye:

Carla says Laverne has been her role model for 15 years and also her friend, and she's not ready for this, and will really miss Laverne

"[It] kills me every time."

sanarabellalal

NBC

6.On Call the Midwife, when Barbara died after giving birth:

Carla on her death bed

"The Christmas specials are almost always brutal to watch. The worst, of course, being the one when Barbara dies. I remember my mom watching that one at like midnight one night, and I woke up to the sound of her sobbing. I didn't understand until I watched the show."

fillionfan4002

PBS

7.On Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., when Mack's daughter faded out of existence in his arms:

Mack's daughter Hope cries and says she doesn't want to die, and Mack says he'll always love her, and then she disappears
ABC

8.On One Tree Hill, when Quentin was killed in a gas station break-in:

Xavier shoots Quentin, then Lucas is woken up by a phone call saying he's dead
The CW

9.On Downton Abbey, when Sibyl died after it seemed she might pull through:

Sibyl dying as the others beg her not to

"I openly sobbed, which I never have for a show before, and for days felt like I was actually mourning someone and would think about the scene. It felt like an angel had left the world. [I] had to stop watching for a while."

arianad414f377b3

PBS

10.On Rizzoli & Isles, when Detective Frost died after the actor died in real life:

<div><p>"The episode of <i>Rizzoli & Isles</i> after Detective Frost dies. It has a moment where each character finally broke down and grieved. I lost it each time a character did. ... It was even more heartbreaking knowing that the actor, Lee Thompson Young, had died in real life."</p><p>—<a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/jennylamb" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank" data-ylk="slk:jennylamb" class="link rapid-noclick-resp">jennylamb</a></p></div><span> TNT</span>

"The episode of Rizzoli & Isles after Detective Frost dies. It has a moment where each character finally broke down and grieved. I lost it each time a character did. ... It was even more heartbreaking knowing that the actor, Lee Thompson Young, had died in real life."

jennylamb

TNT

11.On Supernatural, when Kevin died suddenly and Dean couldn't save him:

Dean asking &quot;Kevin?&quot; as he looks as Kevin with burned out eyes
The CW

12.And also on Supernatural, when Sam died in Season 2:

Dean tells Sam he&#39;s got him as that&#39;s what a big brother does, then cries and says &quot;no&quot; as Sam dies

"Sam's first death in Season 2 gets me every time. Dean babbling about taking care of his pain-in-the-ass little brother is where I break."

a4bf93d1e5

The CW

13.On Money Heist, when Gandia shockingly shot Nairobi:

Nairobi being shot and falling to the ground dead

"I cried like a baby. She died so horribly."

viribavi

Netflix

14.On Stranger Things, when fan favorite character Alexei was shot at the carnival after winning a stuffed animal:

Alexei drops his stuffed animal after he gets shot
Netflix

15.On Shameless, when Frank found Monica dead after renewing their vows:

&#x002014;angelinasarov97
SHOWTIME

16.On ER, when Lucy died after being attacked by a patient:

Ray pushes the operating tray as Lucy flatlines and Corday looks shocked at her bloody hands

"While there are lots of heart-wrenching moments in 15 seasons of ER, one that sticks out to me is in Season 6, after Carter and Lucy are stabbed...Lucy seems to be pulling through, just to get a lung embolism shortly after. All of that is sad enough on its own, but it's Romano's reaction that really does me in. He's always cold, rude, arrogant, and a huge ass, and you think he's just going to shrug it off like, 'well, these things happen, patients die' after he tells Corday to stop shocking Lucy's heart, but then he flips the instrument tray over and starts again because he doesn't want to believe it's the end."

sass2511

NBC

17.On The West Wing, when Leo died right before he was elected vice president after the actor died in real life:

Annabeth tells Josh that Leo is dead

"How about the real-life death of Leo (John Spencer) on The West Wing? I found out for his funeral in real life, [Kristen] Chenoweth sang 'For Good' from Wicked; knowing that and her raw emotion of knowing he passed in the episode gets me every time."

stephaniec4808025c8

NBC

18.On The 100, when Clarke finds Madi essentially dead:

Clarke holding Madi&#39;s face begging her to look at her or say something, saying &quot;my baby&quot;

"I also want to add the scene from Season 7 of The 100 when Clarke realizes Madi is gone and she's holding her paralyzed body, crying 'my baby, my baby.'"

lara_ma

The CW

19.On NYPD Blue, when Bobby died after his heart transplant:

Diane tells Bobby to look, but his eyes close on the hospital bed

"[I] cried my eyes out."

jjjwhite532

ABC

20.On Dance Academy, when Sammy died suddenly:

everyone crying after it&#39;s revealed Sammy is dead

"Nothing breaks my heart quite like when Sammy in Dance Academy dies. He was doing so well and got everything he was working toward. But all of their reactions, especially after the next few episodes, hurt so bad."

dontbedaft01

ABC1

21.And finally, on Farscape, when Aeryn died:

everyone saying goodbye to Aeryn

"I just have to mention Farscape. The scenes where Aeryn died, and her funeral immediately following. Legitimately the only times I've shed tears over a fictional character. The whole sequence was so incredibly sudden and impactful. I applaud the entire team working on the show. Writers, directors, editors, and especially the actors. It was just...wow."

fauna_joy

Sci-Fi Channel

Which rarely talked-about TV deaths did we miss? Let us know in the comments!