1. Cinderella's gorgeous, delicate dress from Cinderella (2015). I would wear this gown in a heartbeat. The way it's both effortless and detailed is, in the words of Lorraine Baines McFly from Back to the Future , "an absolute dream."
Walt Disney Pictures A yes. Walt Disney Pictures
2. Juliet's quite strange wedding dress in Love Actually . The back is lovely, but good god do I detest the front. Why is it kind of a cape? Why is there feather-y stuff at the top? Nope.
Universal Pictures A no. Universal Pictures
3. Zooey's simple stunner in I Love You, Man . Though normally I don't enjoy bows and belts on wedding dresses, the casual, calm confidence here makes the makes the belt/bow work. It's like the outfit doesn't give a shit about the wedding but definitely gives a shit about the marriage, which I find stellar.
Dreamworks Pictures A yes. Dreamworks Pictures
4. This confusing dress from Runaway Bride . I don't understand the fabric situation on the bottom. It's as if this was originally two different dresses, and the top part isn't sufficiently beautiful to make up for it.
Paramount Pictures A no. Paramount Pictures
5. Katniss's sneaky wedding dress from The Hunger Games: Catching Fire . When I'd forgotten this turned into a Mockingjay dress, I didn't appreciate it because I thought it had too much going on while also being kind of predictably boring. But two dresses in one, via flames? A winner.
Lionsgate A yes. Lionsgate
6. Ariel's somehow tame dress in The Little Mermaid . The sleeves are nothing short of ooooooof, but despite how noteworthy they are in a negative way, the dress, all together, is pretty much a nothing. I don't know how.
Walt Disney Pictures A no. Paramount Pictures
7. Maria's elegant dress in The Sound of Music . The collar is too high, but that's okay. It don't care all that much because this wedding dress is simple, traditionally classy, and cool. If only I could say the same about me.
Twentieth Century Fox A yes. Twentieth Century Fox
8. Sophie's Free People-esque wedding dress from Mamma Mia! . I love the vibe it's going for, but the execution is not good. It feels like the dress wants to be like Zooey's from I Love You, Man (#3), but there's too much fabric in the way.
Universal Pictures A no. Universal Pictures
9. Grace's phenomenal dress from Ready or Not . I fucking love it. This is the exact mood, comfortability, and dance-ability I would want in a wedding dress. If the bodice were slightly higher, it would be 100% perfect.
Fox Searchlight Pictures A yes. Fox Searchlight Pictures
10. Mia's forgettable dress in The Best Man . The best part about it is the sheer sleeves, but other than that, I feel so little about this that it circles back around to being bad. Plus, no to the flowers on the back.
40 Acres & A Mule Filmworks A no. 40 Acres & A Mule Filmworks
11. This large dress from Runaway Bride . I'm not a fan of the tiny little ruffly sleeves, but it's not a large enough issue to overpower the fact that I'm fond of everything else. Big skirts are super fun.
Paramount Pictures A yes. Paramount Pictures
12. Mary's red wedding dress in About Time . There is only one single reason this gown isn't a yes: the little ruffly sleeves. Unlike with the last one, these little ruffly sleeves are too much ruffle for me to get past.
Working Title Films A no. Working Title Films
13. Cinderella's fairy tale-y dress in Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella . It's not my style – I wouldn't wear it because of those sleeve things and the sparkles on the top – but it's so right for Cinderella that this has to be a yes.
Walt Disney Television A yes. Walt Disney Television
14. Toula's big wedding dress in My Big Fat Greek Wedding . There's too much going on by 125%. I'm positive about the overlay stuff and the skirt is solid, but I think the rest of it should go find another gown to be with.
Gold Circle Films A no. Gold Circle Films
15. Giselle's gigantic wedding dress in Enchanted . True, it's extremely big and poofy, and that's why the dress from My Big Fat Greek Wedding was a no, but this one sinks its teeth into the princess-ness so well that it's great. A flawless parody.
Walt Disney Pictures A yes. Walt Disney Pictures
16. Margaret's dated dress from The Proposal . The fabric and color are wonderful, and I really like wedding dresses with long sleeves, but, look, the chest part makes this look like what the ghost who's haunting you is wearing.
Touchstone Pictures A no. Touchstone Pictures
17. The tea length wedding dress Jo wears in Funny Face . The low waist isn't my taste, but I can see that the dress is outstanding if it's your kind of thing, so it's a victory.
Paramount Pictures A yes. Paramount Pictures
18. This dress Buttercup wears in The Princess Bride . There's something magical about a light blue, old-timey dress, and the crown is aces. I almost like it all. But, alas, it's simply too nightgown-y for me.
Act III Communications A no. Act III Communications
19. Bella's timeless dress in The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn — Part 1 . She's, what, 18, and she's marrying an old, old vampire man, but cast that aside and the dress is exquisite! The back is fancy in such a fun way and the front is unique without being too much.
Summit Entertainment A yes. Summit Entertainment
20. Jane's uninteresting wedding dress at the end of 27 Dresses . Something about the combination of the fabric and the neckline makes me feel a strong eh. My apologies if you love this gown, but I find it dull.
Fox 2000 Pictures A no. Fox 2000 Pictures
21. Araminta's gold wedding dress in Crazy Rich Asians . Ruffles and that transparent mesh stuff on a bodice aren't usually my cup of tea, but this is undeniably awesome. It's the kind of dress a secret agent would wear.
Warner Bros. A yes. Warner Bros.
22. Mia's dress from the seminal film The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement . OK, so I would like it fine if the embroidery-esque part were over the whole gown, but as it is, I make an ew face every time I look at it for too long.
Walt Disney Pictures A no. Walt Disney Pictures
23. Cinderella's classic wedding dress in Cinderella (1950). If you prefer your wedding dresses ornate, I understand why this one might be a hard pass, but I adore it. It's so pretty and easy-breezy while still having a big, dance-y skirt. The dress rocks. (Do people actually say "rocks"?)
Walt Disney Productions A yes. Walt Disney Productions
24. This bubble-esque dress from Runaway Bride . The stripe thing at the bottom is fun, but the shape of the dress and the collar are fine-to-bad. Basically, this is a whatever I don't have any malice toward.
Paramount Pictures A no. Paramount Pictures
25. Kay's very, very elaborate dress in Father of the Bride (1950). I'm sure you know by now that, generally, I favor fairly relaxed wedding dresses, but that doesn't apply at the moment because oh my god, what a dress. Would I wear it? No, probably not. Would I gasp, utterly thrilled if my friend wore it? No question.
Transcendental Graphics / Getty Images A yes. Fpg / Getty Images
26. And finally, Lillian's canonically awful dress in Bridesmaids . The whole point of this gown is that it's terrible, so it's a compliment to the Bridesmaids costume designer to say that the only non-ransom context in which I would wear this dress to my actual wedding is if it were a joke. Which, honestly, I would do.
Universal Pictures A no. Universal Pictures
View comments