Pelosi Gives In To McConnell, Passes Senate Version Of Border Aid Bill

Matt Fuller
Pelosi Gives In To McConnell, Passes Senate Version Of Border Aid Bill
Pelosi Gives In To McConnell, Passes Senate Version Of Border Aid Bill

WASHINGTON — In the end, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi had to cave.

Faced with a rebellion from moderates in her own party — as well as Republicans in both chambers who wouldn’t give in to a single provision — Pelosi pulled a border aid bill on Thursday that many House Democrats preferred and passed the Senate version of the legislation 305-102, with 95 Democrats and seven Republicans voting no.

On Tuesday, the House passed a bill aimed at addressing the humanitarian crisis involving undocumented immigrants detained at the border. The vote was mostly along party lines, 234-195. The next day, the Senate passed its own bipartisan version of the bill, drafted by Sens. Richard Shelby (R-Ala.) and Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), in an overwhelmingly bipartisan vote, 84-8.

In retrospect, that was the moment when Pelosi lost. The California Democrat said there was no chance the House would simply pass the Senate bill. Instead, she said Democrats would pass a new bill with only a few changes to the Senate legislation. Those changes would have put additional restrictions on how the administration could spend the about $4.5 billion in the bill and would mandate basic conditions for border detention facilities ― provisions that progressives fought earlier this week to make sure were in the House legislation.

But about a dozen and a half moderates in the so-called Problem Solvers Caucus said they would vote no on the new Democratic bill. Republicans in the House had also shown a resolve to not go along with anything but the Senate bill, which President Donald Trump said was the only border aid measure he would sign.

That left Pelosi without the votes to pass even her compromise legislation, and she was forced to pull the bill from floor consideration. From there, the only thing the speaker could do — if she wanted to pass a border bill before the July Fourth recess — was put the Senate bill up for a vote.

“We will not engage in the same disrespectful behavior that the Senate did in ignoring our priorities,” Pelosi wrote in a letter to House Democrats on Thursday. “In order to get resources to the children fastest, we will reluctantly pass the Senate bill.”

“The children come first,” Pelosi added. “At the end of the day, we have to make sure that the resources needed to protect the children are available.”

Democrats were adamant that the children should come first, but not everyone was in agreement that Democrats should give in to Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) and other Republicans.

Progressive Caucus Co-Chairman Mark Pocan (D-Wis.) asked in a tweet Thursday when the Problem Solvers Caucus had become “the Child Abuse Caucus.”

“Wouldn’t they want to at least fight against contractors who run deplorable facilities? Kids are the only ones who could lose today,” Pocan said.

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) also criticized the decision to pass the Senate bill, tweeting that “under no circumstances” should the House vote on the Senate bill without negotiations. “Hell no,” Ocasio-Cortez said. “That’s an abdication of power we should refuse to accept. They will keep hurting kids if we do.”

But Pelosi’s decision to pass the Senate bill was an acknowledgment that no amount of time was going to make McConnell give in. The Senate majority leader was adamant that Republicans would not negotiate.

“We did not, in the end, continue to play political games over this,” McConnell said. “They did. And it’s their problem to solve.”

He noted that Pelosi had spent time on Thursday talking to Vice President Mike Pence about ensuring that at least some of the Democratic requests could be handled administratively. It’s unclear whether Pelosi received any assurances in that regard, but the guardrails to stop the administration from transferring funds to other border purposes or to establish standards for treating children detained at the border aren’t in the Senate bill.

Related Coverage

House Democrats In A Bind Over Border Aid

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Puts Kellyanne Conway On Notice: 'You're Getting A Subpoena!'

Damning Mueller Report In Hand, Democrats Punt To Robert Mueller

Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

Latest Stories

  • Biden bids to placate the left as he builds centrist transition team

    The president-elect has brought in a mix of experience and diversity – but more telling is who Biden hasn’t appointedSo far, Joe Biden has avoided one of the biggest potential pitfalls of the transition process that will end with him moving into the White House: infuriating the left wing of the Democratic party.Yet Biden’s transition has also yielded the results he wanted in terms of ushering in a team of experienced figures drawn mostly from his own circle of friends and advisers who have given a decidedly centrist tone to the incoming administration.Biden has so far named his senior staff, who don’t require confirmation from the Senate, to a generally positive response. As he’s begun unveiling his nominations for cabinet secretary positions, the reaction from leftist quarters of the Democratic party – and its cadre of often young activists primed to attack – has mostly turned out to be be a mix of yawning and marginal grumbling.There has also been applause for naming women and people of color to top posts in an administration that also includes Kamala Harris as vice-president.“I appreciate that the Biden transition is trying to make an argument for diversity of its selections, but if we’re being honest, what we’re seeing is a valuing of experience in people who have served in key important posts and [who] understand what it’s going to take to try to be effective bureaucrats in those posts,” said Faiz Shakir, the manager for Bernie Sanders’ 2020 presidential campaign.“As a progressive, I care deeply about vision and what you want to do when you hold those posts. However, that is not to dismiss or downplay the value of experience. So they are selecting for their experience and that has its upshots.”So far, Biden has avoided nominating ostentatious prospects to cabinet posts, opting instead to bring in veterans of the agencies they are set to run.Biden picked Antony Blinken, a former deputy secretary of state, to run the state department. Biden picked former secretary of state John Kerry to a new high-ranking post as climate tsar. Biden named Jake Sullivan, a longtime national security aide to the former vice-president to be national security adviser. To serve as director of national intelligence Biden picked Avril Haines, a former deputy director of the CIA. For the treasury department, Biden plans to appoint the former Federal Reserve chairwoman, Janet Yellen.More telling is who Biden hasn’t appointed. He hasn’t brought on a liberal standard-bearer like Elizabeth Warren. And the president-elect passed over Democrats with a national profile who campaigned for him, like the former South Bend mayor Pete Buttigieg whose name had been floated for ambassador to the UN. He picked Linda Thomas-Greenfield, a former ambassador and state department official. The former Obama administration national security adviser Susan Rice was seen as a frontrunner for that job.Yet the progressive groups most eager to bash top agency picks from such an establishment Democrat like Biden are somewhat satisfied.“We are encouraged by Joe Biden making one of his first major appointments John Kerry, as it demonstrates the urgency of taking bold, global action on the climate crisis,” Alexandra Rojas, the executive director of the Justice Democrats political action committee said in a statement.“But America also needs a domestically focused climate tsar who directly reports to the president and will oversee an Office of Climate Mobilization agreed to in the Biden-Sanders taskforces.”> We are encouraged by Joe Biden making one of his first major appointments John Kerry> > Alexandra RojasShakir called the Blinken pick “a solid choice”. When Ron Klain was announced as chief of staff, Warren even tweeted that he was a “a superb choice”. The liberal outside group Democracy for America called Yellen a “historic, progressive choice for Fed Chair in 2013. If selected, she’ll be a historic, progressive choice for treasury secretary.”There are signs, though, that the Biden administration and liberals are just enjoying a perhaps temporary detente as the Trump era winds down and before Biden has even occupied the Oval Office. Not all appointments have been without grumbling.Liberal groups have expressed opposition to the longtime Biden adviser Bruce Reed, possibly running the Office of Management and Budget, an agency charged with producing the administration’s budget. Leftwing congresswomen Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ilhan Omar have signed a petition against Reed, calling him a “deficit hawk” and criticizing his past support for benefit cuts, like social security.There have also been rumblings that the transition could meet turbulence if Biden decides to install Brian Deese, a former OMB official, at the head of the national economic council. Some of the strongest ire from liberals has been directed at the idea of the former Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel becoming secretary of transportation.The constellation of progressive activists and groups that form the left of the party also have preferred candidates. The Progressive Change Campaign Committee and the Bernie Sanders-aligned Our Revolution group want New Mexico congresswoman – and Native American – Deb Haaland to run the Department of the Interior.The importance of progressives battling with Biden over nominees is that it could complicate his ability to set up a functional cabinet and retain the broad electoral coalition that elevated him to office.But the real sticking point to Biden’s choices is likely to be confirming these nominees with a Senate where Democrats either have a slim majority or are still stuck in the minority with Republicans in control. That issue will be decided by two Georgia run-off Senate races that will go to the polls in early January, with both parties pouring huge amounts of cash and manpower into the contests.“It is a tremendous dark cloud over the personnel process,” said Bill Dauster, a former deputy chief of staff to then Democratic-Senate leader, Harry Reid. Dauster added that “it’s clear from statements Republicans have made that they intend to ration out their Senate confirmations in a stingy way”.Part of Biden’s argument to placate senators – like Sanders and Warren – who had been angling for influential administration posts is that their current position is essential in the powerful upper chamber of American government.“We already have significant representation among progressives in our administration,” Biden said in an interview with NBC’s Lester Holt. “One thing is really critical: taking someone out of the Senate, taking someone out of the House – particularly a person of consequence – is a really difficult decision that would have to be made. I have a very ambitious, very progressive agenda. And it’s gonna take really strong leaders in the House and Senate to get it done.”Justice Democrats shot back that Biden’s picks could have been better, and in that response statement offered a list of non-white male progressives for the remaining cabinet positions.Biden so far has avoided naming any senator to a cabinet position, and instead prioritized agency experience above all else. Reinforcing that priority, there are signs that Sally Yates, a former acting attorney general, is the heavy favorite to run the Department of Justice. Outgoing Alabama senator Doug Jones, a longtime friend of Biden’s who has kept in contact with him, is another potential candidate, although Yates appears more likely.

  • Suicide car bomb kills 26 Afghan security personnel

    A suicide car bomber struck an army base in Afghanistan on Sunday killing at least 26 security personnel, officials said, in one of the bloodiest attacks in recent months.

  • AP PHOTOS: Pandemic calls off Christmas markets in Europe

    The European plazas where people would usually gather at crowded stalls to partake in hot mulled wine, gingerbread, sausages and other delicacies are just empty squares. Christmas markets, a cherished tradition in Germany and neighboring countries, have joined the long list of annual traditions that were canceled or diminished this year because of the coronavirus pandemic. November saw many European countries impose partial or tougher lockdowns as new virus cases soared.

  • Poland's 'revolution that we cannot stop'

    For Klementyna Suchanow, one of the leaders of Poland's protest movement, mass demonstrations against a tightening of abortion laws have turned into "a real revolution" against the current government.

  • What you need to know if you’re getting tested for Covid-19 before seeing family

    With the holidays season in full swing testing negative for coronavirus does not necessarily mean you’re in the clear * Coronavirus – latest updates * See all our coronavirus coverageIf you’re getting tested for Covid-19 before gathering with family and friends during the holidays season, even if your result was negative, you may not actually be in the clear.Given that a negative Covid-19 test has become a ticket to skipping quarantine when traveling across many state lines, it is easy to believe that a negative test means you are risk-free of carrying the virus.But the reality is much more complicated. A negative test does not mean you do not carry the virus, rather it means you did not have the virus during a specific snapshot of time, experts say. Covid-19 tests are not sensitive enough to pick up traces of the virus the day after someone is infected, and sometimes, it can take more than a week for a test to detect the virus after infection.Amanda Simanek, an associate professor of epidemiology at the University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee and a member of Dear Pandemic, a social media public health campaign run by a cohort of female public health and economic experts, spoke to the Guardian about the main things people should know when relying on testing as a strategy to prevent the spread of Covid-19. You may be getting tested too earlyCovid-19 has an incubation period of between two to 14 days. About half of people who contract Covid-19 will develop symptoms within five days of exposure. But for some people, it could take up to two weeks.“If up until the day you got tested, or even a few days before you got tested, you’re just going about your life as normal and not taking other precautions to prevent exposure to Covid-19, that negative test is really telling you you don’t have a detectable virus on that day,” Simanek said.“You could be exposed, get tested on day two or three after that exposure, be negative, and then on day eight develop symptoms.”Simanek cited fellow public health expert Megan Ranney, an emergency room physician and researcher based in Rhode Island, who compared the sensitivity of a Covid-19 to that of a pregnancy test. “Just like a pregnancy test cannot take the place of birth control, Covid-19 tests should not be seen as a substitute for robust strategies to reduce community transmission,” Ranney wrote in an opinion for NBC News.That does not mean you should avoid getting tested, but means that testing alone cannot guarantee you will not transmit the virus. A Covid-19 test taken after five days of quarantining is much more informative about whether you have the virus than one taken without quarantining. “Then you know there’s a certain date at which a last known exposure could have occurred,” Simanek said. How you quarantine mattersIf you want your Covid-19 test to be useful, you have to take your quarantine seriously.It means you should be avoiding the grocery store and opting to get your groceries delivered. Parents of children who are going to school while quarantining are technically not quarantining. You, or anyone in your household, should not be interacting with anyone outside your household in-person. “It doesn’t mean running errands but avoiding everything else,” Simanek said.If you are traveling, it means you should not be making contact with people en route to your destination. Airplanes, buses and trains are no exception.“You should be isolating yourself from others, just do what you can to rule out any exposure.”Simanek acknowledges that there are logistical challenges to carrying out such a strict quarantine. “That’s challenging for families that aren’t able to work from home or whose kids are in in-person school or are going to childcare because they themselves are an essential worker.”But this type of quarantine is the best way to ensure that a negative test is not false. Testing is most informative on a larger – rather than individual – scaleCovid-19 tests are most useful for community-level action and monitoring the spread of the virus on a wide scale.A handful of states have allowed travelers to bypass a mandated quarantine period for people who have tested negative for the virus, usually no more than 72 hours before their arrival. While that can be helpful to public officials trying to mitigate the spread on a broader scale, the same strategy is not so useful on an individual level.“Testing is a vital component to the broader strategy to contain Covid-19 in your community,” Simanek said. But for people who want to visit family, a negative test “is not particularly informative and doesn’t necessarily change the course of action you should take”.“If you’re talking about visiting your grandparents, you don’t know if you’re that 50% [of people] who get symptoms by day five. Getting a negative test and assuming you’re in the clear, that’s a risk that you’re going to transmit to your family members. That’s a risk I wouldn’t take, personally.” Bottom line: Tested negative? You still should be practicing other safety measuresThis does not mean you should cancel all holiday plans, but underscores the need for additional safety precautions if seeing at-risk family and friends, even if you get a negative test and especially if you have not been properly quarantining amid potential exposure.As guidelines from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) say, an outdoor celebration is much safer than indoors, where the virus is most likely to spread. Masks and social distancing are essential. When eating, try to stay far apart and use separate utensils.Or have a virtual gathering, a guaranteed risk-free way to celebrate the holidays.“The nature of this virus is such that you can have it and you don’t know it yet, you don’t have symptoms, [but] you can pass it to other people,” Simanek said. “It behooves us all to basically assume we have been exposed and act accordingly.”

  • Iran newspaper: Strike Haifa if Israel killed scientist

    An opinion piece published by a hard-line Iranian newspaper on Sunday suggested Iran should attack the Israeli port city of Haifa if Israel carried out the killing of a scientist linked to its disbanded military nuclear program. Israel, suspected of killing Iranian nuclear scientists over the past decade, has not commented on Friday's slaying of Mohsen Fakhrizadeh.

  • Turkey's new virus figures confirm experts' worst fears

    When Turkey changed the way it reports daily COVID-19 infections, it confirmed what medical groups and opposition parties have long suspected — that the country is faced with an alarming surge of cases that is fast exhausting the Turkish health system. In an about-face, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s government this week resumed reporting all positive coronavirus tests — not just the number of patients being treated for symptoms — pushing the number of daily cases to above 30,000. No country can report exact numbers on the spread of the disease since many asymptomatic cases go undetected, but the previous way of counting made Turkey look relatively well-off in international comparisons, with daily new cases far below those reported in European countries including Italy, Britain and France.

  • US reports several explosions heard in Eritrea's capital

    The U.S. Embassy in Eritrea says six explosions were heard Saturday night in the capital, Asmara. It follows an embassy report of another “loud noise, possibly an explosion” in the city on Friday, nearly two weeks after the government of neighboring Ethiopia’s defiant Tigray region confirmed firing missiles at the city during its war with Ethiopian federal forces. The latest explosions came just hours after Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed declared victory in his government’s fighting against forces of the Tigray People’s Liberation Front, which runs the northern Tigray region bordering Eritrea.

  • Asia Today: Cambodia tracks contacts after family infected

    Cambodian officials say a family of six and another man tested positive for the coronavirus in a rare case of local infection, and Prime Minister Hun Sen expressed concern that the woman believed to be the source had traveled extensively in the country, including the capital. Hun Sen, who himself just emerged from isolation after he was exposed to the infected Hungarian foreign minister, said his three Cabinet ministers will get tested and self-quarantine. The Health Ministry said in a statement that the woman tested positive three days after becoming feverish.

  • Darth Vader actor Dave Prowse dies aged 85

    British actor David "Dave" Prowse, who played Darth Vader in all three of the original Star Wars movies, has died aged 85. The weightlifter-turned-actor, who also earned an MBE for playing the Green Cross Code Man to promote road safety, died after a short illness, his agent Thomas Bowington said in a Facebook post. "May the force be with him, always!" Mr Bowington wrote. "Though famous for playing many monsters - for myself, and all who knew Dave and worked with him, he was a hero in our lives." Mr Bowington called the actor's death "a truly and deeply heart-wrenching loss for us and millions of fans all over the world". Prowse represented England in weightlifting at the Commonwealth Games in the early 1960s before embarking on an acting career.

  • 'Do you believe': Pakistan elephant set for flight after Cher campaign

    Following years of public outcry and campaigning by American pop star Cher, the "world's loneliest elephant" was poised Sunday to embark on a mammoth journey from Pakistan to a sanctuary in Cambodia.

  • Beware going 'back to normal' thoughts – normal gave us Trump

    Fatigued by the coronavirus and Trump, the idea of going back to normal is seductive – we must guard against it“Life is going to return to normal,” Joe Biden promised on Thursday in a Thanksgiving address to the nation. He was talking about life after Covid-19, but you could be forgiven if you thought he was also making a promise about life after Trump.It is almost impossible to separate the two. To the extent voters gave Biden a mandate, it was to end both scourges and make America normal again.Despite Covid’s grim resurgence, Dr Anthony Fauci – the public health official whom Trump ignored and then muzzled, with whom Biden’s staff is now conferring – sounded guardedly optimistic last week. Vaccines will allow “a gradual accrual of more normality as the weeks and the months go by as we get well into 2021”.Normal. You could almost hear America’s giant sigh of relief, similar to that felt when Trump implicitly conceded the election by allowing the transition to begin.It is comforting to think of both Covid and Trump as intrusions into normality, aberrations from routines that prevailed before.When Biden entered the presidential race last year, he said history would look back on Trump as an “aberrant moment in time”.The end of both aberrations conjures up a former America that, by contrast, might appear quiet and safe, even boring.Trump called Biden “the most boring human being I’ve ever seen”, and Americans seem to be just fine with that.Biden’s early choices for his cabinet and senior staff fit the same mold – “boring picks”, tweeted the Atlantic’s Graeme Wood (referring to Biden’s foreign policy team), “who, if you shook them awake and appointed them in the middle of the night at any time in the last decade, could have reported to their new jobs and started work competently by dawn”. Hallelujah.All his designees, including Janet Yellen for Treasury and Anthony Blinken for secretary of state, are experienced and competent – refreshing, especially after Trump’s goon squads. And they’re acceptable both to mainstream Democrats and to progressives.They also stand out for their abilities not to stand out. There is no firebrand among them, no Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders (at least not so far).> Boring, reassuring, normal – these are Biden’s great strengths. But they could also be his great weaknessesFor the same reasons, they’re unlikely to stir strong opposition from Republicans, a necessity for Senate confirmation, particularly if Democrats fail to win the two Senate runoffs in Georgia on 5 January.And they’re unlikely to demand much attention from an exhausted and divided public.Boring, reassuring, normal – these are Biden’s great strengths. But he needs to be careful. They could also be his great weaknesses.That’s because any return to “normal” would be disastrous for America.Normal led to Trump. Normal led to the coronavirus.Normal is four decades of stagnant wages and widening inequality when almost all economic gains went to the top. Normal is 40 years of shredded safety nets, and the most expensive but least adequate healthcare system in the modern world.Normal is also growing corruption of politics by big money – an economic system rigged by and for the wealthy.Normal is worsening police brutality.Normal is climate change now verging on catastrophe.Normal is a GOP that for years has been actively suppressing minority votes and embracing white supremacists. Normal is a Democratic party that for years has been abandoning the working class.Given the road we were on, Trump and Covid were not aberrations. They were inevitabilities. The moment we are now in – with Trump virtually gone, Biden assembling his cabinet, and most of the nation starting to feel a bit of relief – is a temporary reprieve.If the underlying trends don’t change, after Biden we could have Trumps as far as the eye can see. And health and environmental crises that make the coronavirus another step toward Armageddon.Hence the paradox. America wants to return to a reassuring normal, but Biden can’t allow it. Complacency would be deadly. He has to both calm the waters and stir the pot.It’s a mistake to see this challenge as placating the progressive wing of the Democratic party. It’s about dealing with problems that have worsened for decades and if left unattended much longer will be enormously destructive.So the question is: in an exhausted and divided America that desperately wants a return to normal, where will Biden find the energy and political will for bold changes that are imperative?

  • Handmade with love: Nepali takes grandma's socks to the world

    Every winter, Lorina Sthapit and her cousins would warm their feet in woollen socks freshly knitted by their grandmother.

  • Mysterious monolith in US desert reportedly disappears

    A mysterious metal monolith found in the remote desert of the western United States, sparking a national guessing game over how it got there, has apparently disappeared, officials said.

  • Ethiopian military operation in Tigray complete, PM says, but explosions reported in Eritrean capital

    Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed said on Saturday that military operations in the restive region of Tigray are complete and federal troops control the regional capital, a major development in a three-week-old war that has shaken the Horn of Africa. But six explosions were reported in the Eritrean capital, Asmara, late on Saturday, the US State Department said on Twitter although the cause and location were not clear. "At 10:13 p.m. on Nov 28 there were six explosions in Asmara," the State Department said in the post on Sunday. Tigrayan forces fighting Ethiopian soldiers have previously fired rockets at Eritrea, and the post urged Americans to "remain situationally aware of the ongoing conflict in the Tigray Region of Ethiopia". Reuters was not immediately able to reach the Eritrean government or Tigrayan forces for comment. On Saturday, Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed announced that federal forces had taken control of Mekelle, Tigray's capital, within hours of launching an offensive there. Mr Abiy's government has been trying to quell a rebellion by a powerful ethnic faction that dominated the central government for decades before he came to power in 2018. Thousands of people are believed to have been killed, and nearly 44,000 have fled to Sudan, in a conflict that has called into question whether Mr Abiy can hold together fractious ethnic groups in Ethiopia, Africa's second most populous country. "I am pleased to share that we have completed and ceased the military operations in the Tigray region," the prime minister said in a tweet. Less than an hour earlier, he said in a statement, "The federal government is now fully in control of the city of Mekelle".

  • 'Catastrophic': Balkan healthcare overwhelmed by virus surge

    Not enough beds and not enough doctors: a skyrocketing coronavirus caseload is pushing hospitals in the Balkans to the cusp of collapse, in chaotic scenes reminding some medics of the region's 1990s wars.

  • North Korea toughens rules of entry to sea to fight virus

    North Korea is further toughening restrictions on entering seawaters as part of elevated steps to fight the coronavirus pandemic, state media said Sunday, two days after South Korea said the North had banned sea fishing. The Korean Central News Agency reported the country is mobilizing more anti-virus units and establishing strong steps to “completely remove uncivilized and unhygienic elements that could help make room for the spread of an epidemic” at winter. KCNA said officials were building firm anti-epidemic measures along border areas to prevent the coronavirus from entering the country.

  • Award-winning photojournalist wounded covering Paris protest

    A press freedom group has denounced the "unacceptable" injury of an award-winning Syrian photojournalist during a Paris protest against police brutality.

  • 'Calling an election unfair does not make it so': Appeals court denies Trump campaign's effort to overturn Biden's win in Pennsylvania

    In rejecting Trump's appeal, a judge wrote, "calling an election unfair does not make it so," and said Trump offered no evidence of wrongdoing.

  • Can new info help solve the case of missing college student Kristin Smart?

    More than two decades after her disappearance, a podcaster turns up the heat to help solve the case.