Looks Like Elizabeth Warren's Consumer Watchdog Is Headed For A Court Victory

WASHINGTON — If the firing of FBI Director James Comey has taught the country anything, it’s that a president has broad constitutional powers to dismiss the head of just about any federal agency he’d like.

One independent agency that’s bucking the trend is the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, long championed by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) before it was created by Congress in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis to rein in abusive Wall Street practices. Since President Donald Trump took office, its director, Richard Cordray, has kept doing his job as if Trump didn’t exist.

And if the bureau and its defenders get their way, the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit may agree that, under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, there’s little Trump can do to get rid of him — other than just wait until his five-year term expires in July 2018.

The appeals court on Wednesday reconsidered a high-stakes challenge to the consumer watchdog’s constitutional structure, which vests its director with significant enforcement power and largely insulates him from the White House. Under the law, the president may fire the CFPB director only “for cause,” which means Trump can’t just make up a pretext and fire Cordray.

Theodore Olson, a high-powered attorney representing PHH Corp., a company targeted by the CFPB that is leading the charge against it, told the court that the agency’s structure is “manifestly unconstitutional.”

“This wolf comes as a wolf,” Olson said, quoting from a widely cited dissent by the late Justice Antonin Scalia warning against violating the separation of powers.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) talks with Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Director Richard Cordray after he testified on Capitol Hill on Wall Street reform in 2014. Warren pushed for the creation of the bureau. (Photo: Jonathan Ernst / Reuters)
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) talks with Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Director Richard Cordray after he testified on Capitol Hill on Wall Street reform in 2014. Warren pushed for the creation of the bureau. (Photo: Jonathan Ernst / Reuters)

Last year, a three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit issued a divided ruling that concluded that the for-cause removal provision of Dodd-Frank is unconstitutional. Days after the election but before Trump was sworn in, the CFPB implored the appeals court to rehear the case — perhaps an acknowledgment that Cordray was now at Trump’s mercy.

Maybe not for long. During a hearing Wednesday, 11 judges on the D.C. Circuit, the majority Democratic appointees, leaned heavily in favor of the CFPB. There was skepticism from some members of the court that the agency’s single-director setup somehow weakens the presidency and empowers an unaccountable bureaucracy.

“What’s the power of the presidency that’s uniquely diminished in this instance?” asked U.S. Circuit Judge Thomas Griffith, who repeatedly pointed to a 1939 Supreme Court precedent that upheld a virtually identical for-cause provision shielding members of the Federal Trade Commission. Under that provision, commission members could only be fired by the president for “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office.”

That case and another one the Supreme Court decided in 1988 — which upheld an independent counsel statute allowing the Department of Justice to prosecute high-ranking federal officials — were cited in court as though the case against the CFPB and Cordray were open and shut.

The independent counsel law “was much more threatening to the president of the United States than the bureau,” said U.S. Circuit Judge David Tatel, who added that the D.C. Circuit was bound by these prior precedents and didn’t have much room to go beyond them.

“I don’t see where this court gets that flexibility,” Tatel said.

Other judges likewise appeared to reject the argument that the existence of one person with vast enforcement powers over the financial industry and strong job protections was an affront to the office of the president. (PHH Corp., the company fighting the CFPB in the case, is on the hook for more than $100 million in fines over a mortgage kickback scheme if it loses its appeal.)

U.S. Circuit Judge Patricia Millet noted that the Social Security Administration is led by a single person who oversees 25 percent of the federal budget. That alone doesn’t make the position of the CFPB head “less accountable, less removable, less appointable,” she suggested.

Fellow Barack Obama appointee Nina Pillard observed that the CFPB, like other financial regulators that must remain above partisan politics, was set up in an attempt “to avoid cronyism in favor of faithful execution of the laws.”

“No two agencies are exactly alike,” said Lawrence DeMille-Wagman, a veteran government lawyer who argued on behalf of the CFPB. He noted, for example, that the chairman of the Federal Reserve, which oversees the entire economy, is not subject to politics and that members of the Fed’s board of governors are also selected based on nonpartisan considerations.

Perhaps the biggest booster of nixing the CFPB’s current structure was U.S. Circuit Judge Brett Kavanaugh, a conservative who wrote the original ruling that found the director usurps authority that belongs to the president.

In a moment of candor, Kavanaugh posed a curious scenario: What if “the person that created the consumer protection agency” — a reference to Warren — ran for president on a pro-CFPB platform and won?

If the D.C. Circuit were to rule that the law protects Cordray, then when his term is up, Trump would get to appoint his replacement, who would then serve until 2023 — well into President Warren’s first term. Kavanaugh called that a “bizarre situation.”

“I look at that reality and say, ‘That’s crazy,’” Kavanaugh said.

There’s no telling if the D.C. Circuit will rule before the end of Cordray’s term. But the case is almost certain to land before the Supreme Court.

Also on HuffPost

Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

President Donald Trump arrives to participate in a wreath-laying at the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial in Jerusalem.
President Donald Trump arrives to participate in a wreath-laying at the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial in Jerusalem.
Trump and his wife Melania Trump are seen as they visit the Sistine Chapel in Vatican City.
Trump and his wife Melania Trump are seen as they visit the Sistine Chapel in Vatican City.
U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, Trump and national security adviser H.R. McMaster eat Belgian chocolate during their meeting with Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel in Brussels, Belgium.
U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, Trump and national security adviser H.R. McMaster eat Belgian chocolate during their meeting with Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel in Brussels, Belgium.
Trump salutes as he arrives at the Leonardo da Vinci-Fiumicino Airport in Rome, Italy.
Trump salutes as he arrives at the Leonardo da Vinci-Fiumicino Airport in Rome, Italy.
First lady Melania Trump Visits the Pediatric Hospital Bambin Gesï.
First lady Melania Trump Visits the Pediatric Hospital Bambin Gesï.
The Trump family meets Pope Francis.
The Trump family meets Pope Francis.
Trump is welcomed by Saudi Arabia's King Salman bin Abdul-Aziz Al Saud Salman (far right) as he arrives at King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on May 20, 2017.
Trump is welcomed by Saudi Arabia's King Salman bin Abdul-Aziz Al Saud Salman (far right) as he arrives at King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on May 20, 2017.
Trump waves from a car during the reception ceremony in Riyadh on May 20, 2017.
Trump waves from a car during the reception ceremony in Riyadh on May 20, 2017.
Trump and King Salman walk together during the welcome ceremony prior to their meeting at Al-Yamamah Palace in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on May 20, 2017.
Trump and King Salman walk together during the welcome ceremony prior to their meeting at Al-Yamamah Palace in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on May 20, 2017.
Trump receives the Order of Abdul-Aziz Al Saud medal from King Salman at the Saudi Royal Court in Riyadh on May 20, 2017.
Trump receives the Order of Abdul-Aziz Al Saud medal from King Salman at the Saudi Royal Court in Riyadh on May 20, 2017.
Trump, Tillerson (third from right) and other members of the U.S. delegation take part in a bilateral meeting with Saudi Crown Prince Muhammad bin Nayef bin Abdul-Aziz Al Saud at a hotel in Riyadh on May 20, 2017.
Trump, Tillerson (third from right) and other members of the U.S. delegation take part in a bilateral meeting with Saudi Crown Prince Muhammad bin Nayef bin Abdul-Aziz Al Saud at a hotel in Riyadh on May 20, 2017.
Ivanka Trump is seen at the ceremony where her father received the Order of Abdul-Aziz Al Saud medal at the Saudi Royal Court on May 20, 2017.
Ivanka Trump is seen at the ceremony where her father received the Order of Abdul-Aziz Al Saud medal at the Saudi Royal Court on May 20, 2017.
King Salman (right) welcomes the Trumps ahead of a dinner at Murabba Palace in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on May 20, 2017.
King Salman (right) welcomes the Trumps ahead of a dinner at Murabba Palace in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on May 20, 2017.
Trump joins dancers with swords at a welcome ceremony ahead of a banquet at the Murabba Palace on May 20, 2017.
Trump joins dancers with swords at a welcome ceremony ahead of a banquet at the Murabba Palace on May 20, 2017.
Trump looks on as Secretary of State Tillerson (left) and Crown Prince Muhammad bin Nayef (right) exchange a memorandum of understanding, in which the Gulf states commit not to finance militant organizations, at the Gulf Cooperation Council leaders summit in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Trump looks on as Secretary of State Tillerson (left) and Crown Prince Muhammad bin Nayef (right) exchange a memorandum of understanding, in which the Gulf states commit not to finance militant organizations, at the Gulf Cooperation Council leaders summit in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Melania Trump walks alongside Saudi Commerce and Investment Minister Majed al-Qasabi (center), as she visits the GE All-Women Business Process Services and IT Centre on May 21, 2017, in Riyadh.
Melania Trump walks alongside Saudi Commerce and Investment Minister Majed al-Qasabi (center), as she visits the GE All-Women Business Process Services and IT Centre on May 21, 2017, in Riyadh.
Trump (fifth from left); King Salman (fifth from right); Gen. Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan (third from left), the crown prince of Abu Dhabi; King of Bahrain Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa (fourth from right); Kuwaiti Emir Sheikh Jaber al-Ahmad al-Sabah (fourth from left); Emir of Qatar Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani (second from right); and Sayyid Fahd bin Mahmoud al Said (third from right), deputy prime minister of the Sultanate of Oman, are seen during the U.S.-Gulf Summit at King Abdul Aziz International Conference Center in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Trump (fifth from left); King Salman (fifth from right); Gen. Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan (third from left), the crown prince of Abu Dhabi; King of Bahrain Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa (fourth from right); Kuwaiti Emir Sheikh Jaber al-Ahmad al-Sabah (fourth from left); Emir of Qatar Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani (second from right); and Sayyid Fahd bin Mahmoud al Said (third from right), deputy prime minister of the Sultanate of Oman, are seen during the U.S.-Gulf Summit at King Abdul Aziz International Conference Center in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Trump and Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sissi take part in a bilateral meeting at a hotel in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Trump and Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sissi take part in a bilateral meeting at a hotel in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Melania Trump, Ivanka Trump and her husband, White House senior adviser Jared Kushner, sit behind the president shortly before he delivered his remarks to the Arab Islamic American Summit in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Melania Trump, Ivanka Trump and her husband, White House senior adviser Jared Kushner, sit behind the president shortly before he delivered his remarks to the Arab Islamic American Summit in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
The first lady chats with students during a visit to the American International School in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
The first lady chats with students during a visit to the American International School in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Donald Trump, Melania Trump, Saudi King Salman (second from left) and Egyptian President el-Sissi (far left) put their hands on an illuminated globe during the inauguration ceremony of the Global Center for Combating Extremist Ideology in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Donald Trump, Melania Trump, Saudi King Salman (second from left) and Egyptian President el-Sissi (far left) put their hands on an illuminated globe during the inauguration ceremony of the Global Center for Combating Extremist Ideology in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Trump and Israeli President Reuven Rivlin speak during a welcome ceremony at Ben Gurion International Airport on May 22, 2017, near Tel Aviv.
Trump and Israeli President Reuven Rivlin speak during a welcome ceremony at Ben Gurion International Airport on May 22, 2017, near Tel Aviv.
Melania Trump arrives at the President's Residence in Jerusalem on May 22, 2017.
Melania Trump arrives at the President's Residence in Jerusalem on May 22, 2017.
Melania and Donald Trump stand next to members of the Christian clergy during their visit to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
Melania and Donald Trump stand next to members of the Christian clergy during their visit to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
Ivanka Trump attends a press conference at the President's Residence in Jerusalem on May 22, 2017.
Ivanka Trump attends a press conference at the President's Residence in Jerusalem on May 22, 2017.
Donald Trump walks with the first lady in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
Donald Trump walks with the first lady in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
Donald Trump visits the Western Wall, the holiest site where Jews can pray, in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
Donald Trump visits the Western Wall, the holiest site where Jews can pray, in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
(From left to right) U.S. President Donald Trump, French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Theresa May, European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni watch an Italian flying squadron as part of activities at the G7 Summit in Taormina, Sicily, on May 26, 2017.
(From left to right) U.S. President Donald Trump, French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Theresa May, European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni watch an Italian flying squadron as part of activities at the G7 Summit in Taormina, Sicily, on May 26, 2017.
U.S. President Donald Trump greets French President Emmanuel Macron before a lunch ahead of a NATO summit in Brussels, Belgium, on May 25, 2017.
U.S. President Donald Trump greets French President Emmanuel Macron before a lunch ahead of a NATO summit in Brussels, Belgium, on May 25, 2017.
(Left to right) European Council President Donald Tusk, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, U.S. President Donald Trump, Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni, French President Emmanuel Macron, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, British Prime Minister Theresa May and European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker pose for a family photo during the G7 Summit in Taormina, Sicily, on May 26, 2017.
(Left to right) European Council President Donald Tusk, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, U.S. President Donald Trump, Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni, French President Emmanuel Macron, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, British Prime Minister Theresa May and European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker pose for a family photo during the G7 Summit in Taormina, Sicily, on May 26, 2017.
(From left to right) Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras, U.S. President Donald Trump, Hungarian Prime Minister Voktor Orban and British Prime Minister Theresa May pose at the start of NATO summit at the organization's new headquarters in Brussels, Belgium, on May 25, 2017.
(From left to right) Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras, U.S. President Donald Trump, Hungarian Prime Minister Voktor Orban and British Prime Minister Theresa May pose at the start of NATO summit at the organization's new headquarters in Brussels, Belgium, on May 25, 2017.
U.S. President Donald Trump gathers with (from left to right) European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, European Council President Donald Tusk, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni, French President Emmanuel Macron, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and British Prime Minister Theresa May as they attend the G7 summit in Taormina, Sicily, on May 26, 2017.
U.S. President Donald Trump gathers with (from left to right) European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, European Council President Donald Tusk, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Italian Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni, French President Emmanuel Macron, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and British Prime Minister Theresa May as they attend the G7 summit in Taormina, Sicily, on May 26, 2017.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting