Nutritionists Rank America’s Favorite Candy Bars

Abigail Abesamis
Updated
(Photo: Nehru Sulejmanovski / EyeEm via Getty Images)
(Photo: Nehru Sulejmanovski / EyeEm via Getty Images)

Sure, fancy chocolate is great and dark chocolate contains beneficial minerals and antioxidants, but there’s something so wonderfully nostalgic about a drugstore candy bar.

There’s nothing wrong with occasionally enjoying a treat just because it’s sweet. Even registered dietitians agree. Meredith Price, founder of Priceless Nutrition & Wellness, told HuffPost, “I am a self-proclaimed chocoholic and absolutely believe there is room in a healthy diet for chocolate and other sweets. I’d prefer to choose healthier options like dark chocolate. However, if someone enjoys a Snickers bar every now and then, that is 100 percent OK.”

Price added that the important thing is to focus on incorporating beneficial foods into your diet (fruits, vegetables, whole grains, etc.) rather than getting caught up in which foods to limit.

But back to chocolate: Do the peanuts in a Snickers bar somewhat make up for the 25 grams of added sugar (a whopping 50 percent of your recommended daily value)? Do the almonds and coconut in an Almond Joy offer significant nutritional value? Is there a “healthier” candy bar that stands above the rest of America’s favorites?

We asked three nutritionists to rank the nation’s most popular candy bars (according to retail sales data from IRI, a Chicago-based market research firm) from healthiest to least healthy. They each came up with their own drastically different guidelines.

These were the 10 top-selling candy bars in the U.S. last year (in the category of chocolate candy box/bag/bar less than 3.5 ounces):

  1. Snickers

  2. Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar

  3. Kit Kat

  4. Twix

  5. 3 Musketeers

  6. Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme

  7. Reese’s Sticks

  8. Almond Joy

  9. Milky Way

  10. Hershey’s Gold

Meredith Price’s Ranking

(Photo: Snickers)
(Photo: Snickers)

Price ranked the candy bars based on saturated fat and sugar content, and those with trans fats automatically went to the bottom of her list.

She noted that calories weren’t a consideration as the bars all fell within the same range (210 to 250 calories). But trans fats, or partially hydrogenated oils, were a red flag. Trans fats “should be completely avoided in the diet due to their ability to increase risk of heart disease,” she said.

“To choose the healthiest candy bar, you want one with the least amount of sugar and saturated fat and absolutely no trans fats,” Price said. “If you were to choose any candy bar [including those not on this list], the best option is to go for a dark chocolate version as they tend to have less sugar and even some beneficial properties like antioxidants and trace minerals.”

Price’s ranking (with links to the nutrition facts for each bar):

  1. Snickers

  2. Twix

  3. Kit Kat

  4. Hershey’s Gold

  5. Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme

  6. Almond Joy

  7. Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar

  8. Reese’s Sticks

  9. Milky Way

  10. 3 Musketeers

Snickers, the “healthiest” option, has the lowest amount of saturated fat (23 percent) in the group, according to Price. “It is a bit higher in sugar than most of the others,” she added. “Therefore, if you’re enjoying a Snickers bar, try to have this be your one sweet treat of the day.”

Twix came in second for its moderate saturated fat (30 percent) and sugar (22 grams) content.

The worst of the lot, 3 Musketeers, has both trans fats and the highest amount of sugar (36 grams). “That’s a whopping 9 teaspoons of sugar in one candy bar, which is higher than the American Heart Association’s upper recommendation of daily sugar intake,” Price said.

Natalie Rizzo’s Ranking

(Photo: Hershey's)
(Photo: Hershey's)

Rizzo, a registered dietitian and author of The No-Brainer Nutrition Guide for Every Runner, looked for recognizable ingredients.

While she didn’t consider any of the candy bars to be healthy, she said she favored those with “some sort of healthy ingredients, like nuts or chocolate, as the first ingredients on the list.” Among bars with similar ingredients, the one with less sugar won out, and candy bars containing unrecognizable ingredients went to the bottom of the list.

On the group as a whole, Rizzo said, “They are all an indulgence to have once in a while. I suggest opting for the one that satisfies your sweet tooth, since they all have very similar nutrition facts.”

Rizzo’s ranking:

  1. Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar

  2. Reese’s Sticks

  3. Snickers

  4. Twix

  5. Milky Way

  6. 3 Musketeers

  7. Almond Joy

  8. Kit Kat

  9. Hershey’s Gold

  10. Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme

Her top pick, Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar, “has the most pure ingredients, made from just milk chocolate without many additives.” Reese’s Sticks top Rizzo’s list because milk chocolate and peanuts lead their ingredients. Rizzo also pointed out that Reese’s Sticks have less sugar than the others and 4 grams of protein.

The other Hershey’s bars didn’t fare as well in her ranking, with the Gold and Cookies ‘n’ Creme bars coming in at the bottom of the list. Rizzo described Hershey’s Gold as a “sugar-forward bar made with other additives like vegetable oil” and its “only redeeming quality” being the peanuts. Sugar is also the first ingredient in Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme, and Rizzo noted that she didn’t recognize most of the other ingredients.

Jonathan Valdez’s Ranking

(Photo: Reese's)
(Photo: Reese's)

Valdez, owner of Genki Nutrition and media spokesperson for the New York State Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, took note of serving size, saturated fat, trans fat, sodium and calories.

“If there is more than 20 percent of your daily value of these nutrients per serving, that raises a flag in terms of health impacts,” Valdez said. “It is also important to look at the fiber, protein and mineral content.”

Valdez’s ranking:

  1. Reese’s Sticks

  2. Kit Kat

  3. Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme

  4. Hershey’s Gold

  5. Almond Joy

  6. Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar

  7. 3 Musketeers

  8. Milky Way

  9. Snickers

  10. Twix

He put Reese’s Sticks at the top of his list in part because, “compared to the other bars, this has the lowest amount of saturated fat,” Valdez said. Kit Kat, in second place, has “higher traces of vitamin D, iron, calcium and potassium” compared to Reese’s Sticks and a relatively lower fat content compared to the others.

Snickers just avoided the last slot because it has less saturated fat than Twix, which Valdez deemed “the worst candy of the choices.”

The lack of consensus among the three experts, who valiantly scraped to find redeeming nutritional qualities, indicates that there isn’t a truly healthy option here. But then you already knew that about candy bars.

“Everything in moderation,” Valdez said. “Ultimately, if it doesn’t exceed your caloric needs, it will not lead to weight gain. [But] eat too much of these treats, and they can replace other nutritional foods such as fruits, dairy and lean proteins.”

In short, if you choose to indulge, you could just pick the one you like best.

Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

Related Coverage

50 Of The Best Dessert Recipes Of All Time

These 5 Discontinued Candy Bars Have The Most Rabid Cult Followings

S'mores Recipes That'd Make Any Marshmallow Proud

Also on HuffPost

Homemade Snickers

<strong>Get the <a href="http://www.howsweeteats.com/2012/01/homemade-snickers-bars/" target="_hplink">Homemade Snickers recipe from How Sweet It Is</a></strong> The secret to making these Snickers-style bars is lots of layers. Two chocolate layers envelop a nougat layer made of evaporated milk and marshmallow fluff, a layer of salted peanuts, and a rich caramel layer.

Homemade Almond Joy

<strong>Get the <a href="http://www.greensnchocolate.com/2011/03/homemade-almond-joys.html" target="_hplink">Homemade Almond Joy recipe from Greens and Chocolate</a></strong> Almond Joys are easy to make at home. The coconut centers are made with sweetened condensed milk and shredded coconut. Whole almonds make the characteristic bump on top of each bar.

Homemade Twix

<strong>Get the <a href="http://www.bakersroyale.com/candy/er-homemade-twix-bars/" target="_hplink">Homemade Twix recipe from Bakers Royale</a></strong> Three layers make up these homemade twix. First a rich shortbread studded with toffee chips. Then a thin caramel layer. And finally the chocolate.

Homemade Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

<strong>Get the <a href="http://www.onegoodthingbyjillee.com/2012/04/homemade-reeses-peanut-butter-cups.html" target="_hplink">Homemade Reese's Peanut Butter Cups recipe from One Good Thing By Jillee</a></strong> This easy recipe uses natural peanut butter for the creamy filling. The recipe is just a matter of enveloping dollops of it in melted chocolate in mini cupcake papers.

Homemade Butterfingers

<strong>Get the <a href="http://bunsinmyoven.com/2011/10/25/homemade-butterfinger-candy-bars/" target="_hplink">Homemade Butterfingers recipe from Buns In My Oven</a></strong> With just three ingredients, this candy bar recipe couldn't be any easier. The filling is made with a combination of melted candy corn and peanut butter. Then it's dipped in melted chocolate.

Homemade Kit Kats

<strong>Get the <a href="http://melssweetlife.com/2011/01/27/homemade-kit-kats/" target="_hplink">Homemade Kit Kats recipe from The Sweet Life</a></strong> Gimme a break ... of that Kit Kat bar. Use store-bought crackers to use as the wafer layers in this homemade creation. A buttery brown sugar mixture is used for the layers. Then it's topped with a melted mixture of peanut butter, chocolate chips and butterscotch chips.

Homemade Three Musketeers

<strong>Get the <a href="http://www.namelymarly.com/2010/09/vegan-3-muskteers-bars/" target="_hplink">Three Musketeers recipe from Namely Mary</a></strong> The secret to recreating the fluffy filling of a Three Musketeers bar is whipping together non-dairy whipped topping with chocolate. After you freeze the mix and cut it into squares, it's time to dip in melted chocolate.

Homemade Crunch Bars

<strong>Get the <a href="http://chocolatecoveredkatie.com/2012/07/01/healthy-homemade-chocolate-crunch-bars/" target="_hplink">Homemade Crunch Bars recipe from Chocolate Covered Katie</a></strong> This darker version of the Crunch bar uses dark chocolate, rice cereal and coconut oil to create, what could be called, an even better version. Freeze before cutting into squares.

Homemade York Peppermint Patties

<strong>Get the <a href="http://www.petitekitchenesse.com/2011/12/14/holiday-giveaway-peppermint-patties-cow-tales/" target="_hplink">Homemade York Peppermint Patties recipe from Petite Kitchenesse</a></strong> Sweetened condensed milk and powdered sugar with a few drops of peppermint extract create the refreshing filling in these peppermint patties. After dipping the rounds in chocolate, top with crushed peppermint candies.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.