Bionic Arm Means One Less Battle for Wounded Warrior
The first grenade bounced off the hood of Glen Lehman's Humvee as it patrolled the streets of Baghdad. But the second grenade tore through the door, shredding Lehman's thigh and filleting his arm.
Lehman survived, thanks to his quick-thinking comrades and a helicopter evacuation to a nearby air base for emergency medical care. But a new battle was just beginning for the sergeant first class and father of two, who fought excruciating phantom limb pain where his right arm used to be.
"It felt like my hand kept getting slammed in a car door," said Lehman, 34, whose right arm was amputated above the elbow.
On top of the pain, Lehman struggled to control his prosthetic arm, which ended with a pincer in place of a hand.
"It was hard to even get the prosthetic in the right position," he said, describing how the cumbersome limb turned simple tasks into impossible missions. "I could move the elbow, wrist or hand but only one at a time and in that order. If the elbow was in the wrong position, and I was using the wrist, I had to remember to switch from wrist to hand and then to elbow before I could reposition."
Suddenly, the soldier who once led his platoon was unable to make his sons' peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwiches.
That's when Lehman met Dr. Todd Kuiken, director of the Center for Bionic Medicine and Amputee Services at the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago. Kuiken and his plastic surgeon colleague Dr. Gregory Dumanian had been busy co-developing a bionic limb technology known as targeted muscle reinnervation, or TMR for short.
With TMR, surgeons reroute the nerve stumps left over after an amputation to muscles in the chest and upper arm so they can control a prosthetic arm by simply imagining the movement.
"I didn't know what to expect," said Lehman, recalling the decision to undergo the experimental operation. "But I wasn't really worried about any drawbacks at the time."
Lehman's severed nerves sent shooting pain through his phantom limb. The white, rubbery fibers, about the thickness of a pinky finger, continued to carry messages from his brain but had nowhere to send them. Dumanian gave these fibers a new purpose, stitching them to smaller nerves so that the electrical signals they carried could be used to control a bionic arm. But reconnecting the nerves was just the beginning.
"When we want to use our hands, we don't think, 'OK, I'm going to move my elbow, then my shoulder and then my hand.' No, we just think about it and it goes," Dumanian said. And achieving this level of intuitive control is where the science gets closer to science fiction.
Lehman was one of the first amputees to use groundbreaking pattern recognition technology to control his prosthetic arm. It works like speech recognition, according to its creator, neural engineer Levi Hargrove, and relies on a tiny computer the size of a quarter in the bionic arm.
"When we first worked with Glen, we taught him that he needs to think of making repeatable patterns," said Hargrove, director of the Neural Engineering for Prosthetics and Orthotics Laboratory at the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago. "Next, we taught the computer what those patterns look like."
Over time, the computer learned to translate Lehman's thoughts into coordinated movements at multiple joints.
"I just think of moving my phantom limb, and my prosthesis moves instead," he said. "I would say it's at least 75 percent better and more intuitive."
And how's that peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwich coming along?
"I'm not sure how I'd compare to someone with two working arms -- but I'd be willing to race," he said.
Bionic Arm Eases Phantom Limb Pain
As Lehman improved the control of his prosthetic, he noticed his phantom pain started to wane – a finding his doctors plan to explore as a cure for the debilitating syndrome.
"It was unexpected but a happy accident," Lehman said.
But people shouldn't expect miracles right away, cautions Kuiken.
"Patients need to know it takes about six months for the nerves to grow in," he said. "It's OK to wear a regular prosthesis in the meantime, so they're not left frustrated feeling like they're chasing their tail."
Since his surgery in August 2009, Lehman said he'd seen big improvements.
"It's like the difference between driving a 1970s Yugo versus a new Ford Mustang," he said. "Performance-wise, they are in two completely different categories."
"Everything just feels more natural," he added. "Imagine you're playing a crane game and trying to grab a stuffed bear with a claw, then instead imagine just reaching in and grabbing what you want with your arm – it's incredibly different."
Scientists are trying to learn just how much better this new technology really might be. At last week's meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Sciences, Hargrove and Kuiken reported results of a new study that patients using pattern recognition to control their bionic arms consistently performed better and faster at common tasks -- such as stacking blocks and manipulating clothespins -- than those using conventional controls. The researchers plan to build on this small study with a larger clinical trial.
"That's when it gets really exciting," said Kuiken of the possibility of improving the standard of care for people with prosthetic limbs. "Until it reaches commercial market it's just academic. I'd expect private companies to get this kind of thing on the market within a year."
The cost of surgery and a standard prosthetic run upwards of $150,000 including rehabilitation, according to Dumanian. The bionic arm and pattern recognition technology would increase the cost, Dumanian said, but it might be more cost effective than hand transplantation.
In the meantime, Lehman continues to work with scientists to help them improve the technology for wounded warriors coming home.
"Not everyone is willing to accept going through an additional elective surgery," he said, adding that soldiers should speak to a specialist who can help them understand their options. "It's the next step to getting your arm back."