No court action to seek HS2 Wales cash

Adrian Browne - BBC Wales political reporter
2 min read
0
HS2 train
[PA Media]

Welsh ministers have confirmed that they will not go to court to seek billions of pounds extra to spend off the back of high speed rail investment in England.

Last year the then first minister, Mark Drakeford, said legal action was being considered over his government not receiving additional cash due to spending on HS2 in England.

But the Welsh government's top legal adviser, the Counsel General Mick Antoniw has said a challenge is "unlikely to succeed".

Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth said that was "tantamount to waving the white flag".

The HS2 project was designated an "England and Wales" scheme by the UK Treasury.

That means it did not trigger the mechanism that would usually send money to the Welsh government, when UK government spends money on projects in England that Cardiff ministers have powers over in Wales.

That mechanism is known as the Barnett formula.

In October the prime minister announced the cancellation of the parts of HS2 linking England's West Midlands to Manchester and the East Midlands.

Rishi Sunak also unveiled a plan to electrify the north Wales rail mainline, using £1bn previously earmarked for HS2.

What remains of HS2 is the London to Birmingham stretch, estimated to cost as much as £66.6bn, according to the project's executive chairman.

There have been cross-party calls for that first leg of the project to be reclassified so Wales can benefit from "consequential" funds.

Plaid Cymru says it could be worth as much as £4bn.

But Mr Antoniw has confirmed that going to court to try to secure such funding for Wales is not going to happen.

"Further consideration has been given and it has been concluded that the wide discretion the Treasury has would make any challenge unlikely to succeed," he said, in a written answer to Mr ap Iorwerth.

'Silent treatment'

Plaid Cymru's leader called the reply a "worrying signal of things to come, should Keir Starmer become the next prime minister, and giving Wales the silent treatment on HS2 speaks volumes about Labour’s attitude to fair funding".

“The absence of resolve shown by the counsel general is tantamount to waving the white flag," he said.

Mr ap Iorwerth urged the new Labour First Minister, Vaughan Gething, to "reconsider" the decision to "let the UK government off the hook”.

The UK government has previously said that it is responsible for "heavy rail investment across England and Wales, so spends money in Wales rather than funding the Welsh government to do so".

UK ministers have said the Barnett formula will apply as they focus on "local transport alternatives" to HS2 in England, meaning there will then be knock-on funding for the Welsh government.

Welsh ministers have been asked to comment.

Advertisement

Recommended Stories

  • Fed holds interest rates at 23-year high, citing 'lack of further progress' on inflation

    The Fed is expected to keep interest rates at a 23-year high Wednesday, but investors will be listening for any signs of how long they will have to wait before cuts can begin.

  • Fed holds rates steady, hints rate cuts on hold until year-end

    The Fed, which signaled three rate cuts as recently as March, now suggests we may not get one until late in the year.

  • Fed holds rates as it warns fight against inflation has hit a bump

    The world’s largest central bank has warned that its fight against inflation has hit a bump in the road, forcing it to keep interest rates at a 23-year-high.

  • The Treasury Will Keep Bond Sales Steady, Gets Ready to Boost Liquidity

    The U.S. Treasury held back on increasing long-term debt in the coming months, offering good news for a bond market reeling under pressure, while launching a program to buy back billions of dollars in government debts for the first time in over two decades. Despite higher net borrowing estimates shared earlier in the week, the Treasury, in its debt sale plan released Wednesday, said it would issue the same amount of 10-, 20-, and 30-year bonds from May to July as it did from February to April. The debt managers have a commitment to be “regular and predictable,” an approach aimed at avoiding volatility.

  • Fed Meeting: Rate Cuts Will Wait, But QT Relief Offers Stealth Easing; S&P 500 Gains

    The Federal Reserve will scale back its quantitative tightening (QT). Wall Street will take its cue from chair Jerome Powell.

  • Euro Area Sovereign Credit: Some Ratings Under Pressure as Fiscal Challenges Mount

    Euro area governments unable to put in place consistent medium-term fiscal plans face credit-rating pressure even though reducing public borrowing is possible including for highly indebted countries, says Scope Ratings.

  • FOMC holds rates in place and will slow balance sheet drawdown

    The Fed said that starting on June 1 it was reducing the cap on Treasury securities it allows to mature and not be replaced to $25 billion from its current cap of up to $60 billion per month. The Fed left the cap on how many mortgage-backed securities it will allow to roll off its books at $35 billion per month, and it will reinvest any excess MBS principal payments into Treasuries. The announcements came at the end of its two-day Federal Open Market Committee meeting.

  • Anglo takeover attempt triggers corruption claims against South Africa’s ruling party

    BHP’s attempt to buy Anglo American has triggered corruption claims against South Africa’s ruling African National Congress (ANC).

  • Trump raises stake in his media firm to nearly 65%

    The former U.S. president and Republican presidential candidate secured 36 million shares of Trump Media & Technology Group (TMTG), increasing his stake from 57.6% as of March. Reuters reported last week that Trump would secure a stock bonus worth $1.3 billion from TMTG, equivalent to about half the majority stake he already owns in it, thanks to the wild rally in its shares. The bonus also reflects the exuberant trading in TMTG's shares, which have been on a roller coaster ride since the company listed on Nasdaq last month through a merger with a special purpose acquisition company (SPAC) and was snapped up by Trump supporters and speculators.

  • US job openings fall to 8.5 million in March, the lowest level in more than 3 years

    U.S. jobs openings slid in March to the lowest level in more than three years, but stayed at historically high levels in a sign that the job market remains resilient in the face of higher interest rates. The Labor Department reported Wednesday that employers posted 8.5 million vacancies in March, down from 8.8 million in February and the fewest since February 2021. When the Federal Reserve began raising interest rates in March 2022 to combat a resurgence in inflation, the higher borrowing costs were expected to tip the economy into recession and push up unemployment.