Zachary Levi Makes Red Carpet Debut with 'Special Lady Friend' Caroline Tyler at ESPY Awards

Michael Loccisano/Getty Caroline Tyler and Zachary Levi

New couple alert?

Zachary Levi attended the 2021 ESPY Awards on Saturday alongside rumored girlfriend Caroline Tyler, sharing photos from the event to his Instagram account Monday.

In the third image, Levi, 40, and Tyler are shown posing for the camera, with the Shazam! actor looking dapper in a brown suit and his date in a fitted white lace dress with an open back.

"Thank you @dzojchen for another banger of a suit, and @warrenalfiebaker for stylin up such a fine lewks for me and my special lady friend," Levi captioned the post, in part.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.

Kevin Mazur/Getty Caroline Tyler and Zachary Levi

RELATED GALLERY: New Celebrity Couples of 2021

The following day, Levi and Tyler were snapped out and about in New York City, holding hands, as shown in photos obtained by Extra and Just Jared.

The pair was dressed casually for their stroll in the Big Apple, with Tyler rocking a pair of wide-legged jeans and a long-sleeved green top. Levi, meanwhile, wore camo-print shorts and a navy-blue windbreaker jacket.

The Tangled voice actor previously shared a group photo on Instagram that included Tyler, wishing friend David Coleman a happy birthday.

"Honored to be able to call you a friend, and brother, and so grateful for you and your wonderful family being in my life," he addressed Coleman in the caption. "May 50 be just the beginning of something new and wonderful."

RELATED VIDEO: Zachary Levi Gives a Backstage Tour of First Date

Levi was previously married to actress Missy Peregrym. After tying the knot in 2014, the former couple split less than a year later.

The Chuck alum touched on his love life during a chat with Access back in April 2019, confirming at the time that he was single.

"I've been in this very good, healthy moment of just, I don't know, being with me — loving myself, working on myself. Getting stronger and healthier and waiting for that right woman to enter my life," he said.

"I don't know where she is, but I'm trusting that that's all gonna time out the way it's supposed to," Levi added.