Why Bachelor’s Zach Shallcross and Rachel Recchia Split After Their ‘Inauthentic’ Fantasy Suite Date

Water under the bridge! Zach Shallcross became the Bachelor for season 27 after her and Bachelorette alum Rachel Recchia broke up following an “inauthentic” fantasy suite date. Keep reading to learn more about what happened.

 Why Did Zach Shallcross and Rachel Recchia Split?

Zach, 26, and Rachel, 26, had a strong relationship all season, and he seemed like a major frontrunner during the final week. However, things took a fast turn after they spent a night in the fantasy suite together without the cameras. 

Zach opened up about the two feeling like “strangers” together and that he was “blindsided” by Rachel asking if he was ready for marriage.

“I don’t know what it could be, but Rachel’s concern came out of nowhere," he said during a confessional interview at the time. "I think it’s bulls—t, to be honest. She was putting on a front. That scares me. That scares me a lot." 

Zach Shallcross The Bachelorette
Zach Shallcross The Bachelorette

He then said he was “not feeling it at all” with Rachel after their night together, claiming that he had “the most inauthentic conversation” with the pilot. 

"I was more than ready to get on one knee. The Rachel that I was falling in love with, I trusted her enough at least to show me her real self and I don’t think I got that. And I still don’t know why or how," he said. "What was that Rachel I was getting? That’s the biggest concern to me."

What Happened During Zach Shallcross, Rachel Recchia’s Fantasy Suite Date?

Zach opened up about what went down during their fantasy suite date during an appearance on Ashley Iaconetti and Ben Higgins' "Almost Famous" podcast.

"There was a total lack of communication ... She treated me like I was a complete stranger," the leading man explained during the January 23 episode, adding that Rachel gave him "rapid fire" questions.

He felt like nothing he said was "good enough" and he couldn't "give the right answer" to her concerns. Their uncomfortable date took both of them by surprise after their amazing chemistry throughout the season.

"We were both sitting there next to each other and just like, this can't be true," he continued. "Like does she even care about me in like the same way I feel for her or even at all? ... It was tough.

Fans watched Zach pull Rachel aside during the rose ceremony to air his grievances after not quite seeing eye-to-eye during their overnight date,

“I thought what I was seeing wasn't the real Rachel, what I was seeing was Bachelorette Rachel,” he told the leading lady, adding that he was “upset and disappointed” that he “wasn’t able” to get true feelings from her. 

However, Rachel thought he was attacking her character and assured that she “did find” clarity about her contestant. "I was trying to find that missing piece for me," she explained. "I did think if we spent the night talking I could find it."

The two ended their relationship then and there, with Zach calling her goodbye “cold” and Rachel acknowledging the situation was “disappointing.” 

The leading lady went on to get engaged to Tino Franco during the finale, but they split weeks later after the finalist cheated on her. 

What Did Rachel Say About Zach Being the Bachelor?

Although Rachel and Zach left things on an awkward note, they cleared the air during After the Final Rose and apologized to each other. The Illinois native had nothing but kind words to say when she found out her ex would be taking the reins of his own season. 

"I'm really excited for him. I think Zach's a great guy," Rachel told Entertainment Tonight in September. "It's a lot of pressure, but I think he'll step up to the plate. We wish him the best of luck. We can’t wait to watch him and not be part of a season for once."

Can’t wait until the finale for more Bachelor spoilers? No worries, we’ve got you covered. See if Zach Shallcross gets engaged, who his final two women are and who his top four contestants are. You can also check out Life & Style’s Bachelor page for more updates on the drama throughout the season!