• Home
  • Mail
  • Flickr
  • Tumblr
  • News
  • Sports
  • Finance
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Answers
  • Groups
  • More
Yahoo
    • Skip to Navigation
    • Skip to Main Content
    • Skip to Related Content
    Entertainment Home
    Follow Us
    • TV
    • Movies
    • Celebrity
    • Music
    • Videos
    • Reviews
    • Movie Showtimes

    Trump Court Pick Rated 'Not Qualified' Sits Through Humiliating Senate Hearing

    Jennifer Bendery
    HuffPostNovember 1, 2017
    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share
    Welp! (NICHOLAS KAMM via Getty Images)
    View photos
    Welp! (NICHOLAS KAMM via Getty Images)

    WASHINGTON ― Two days after the American Bar Association rated Leonard Steven Grasz “not qualified” to be a judge, the Senate Judiciary Committee held a confirmation hearing Wednesday for Grasz’s nomination to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit. 

    It was brutal.

    With Grasz sitting in front of the committee, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) read aloud passages from the ABA’s eight-page statement outlining why Grasz earned such a terrible and rarely designated rating by the nation’s premier legal society.

    “I assume you’re keenly aware that you are the first Circuit Court nominee since 2006 to receive a unanimous ‘not qualified’ rating from the ABA?” Whitehouse asked Grasz. “And that the last nominee who had such a rating was withdrawn?”

    “That is my understanding, senator,” replied Grasz.

    Awkward! It only got worse.

    “Do you think that this is a matter as to which the committee should have no concern?” asked Whitehouse.

    “I have great respect for the amount of time and effort the American Bar Association put into the process,” said Grasz. “I respectfully disagree with the result.”

    The Rhode Island senator noted that the ABA rated Grasz “not qualified’ in a unanimous 14-0 vote. He asked Grasz if he knew that was the tally.

    “I’m not keenly aware of that,” said Grasz. “I believe there was one abstention.”

    “That’s why it’s 14,” Whitehouse replied. “There are 15 of them.... It’s the full panel of 14 non-abstaining lawyers.”

    Here's Leonard Steven Grasz in his confirmation hearing, listening to Democratic senators read aloud all the reasons why he was deemed "not qualified" to be a judge. (CSPAN)
    View photos
    Here's Leonard Steven Grasz in his confirmation hearing, listening to Democratic senators read aloud all the reasons why he was deemed "not qualified" to be a judge. (CSPAN)

    The ABA interviewed several colleagues of Grasz, who was Nebraska’s chief deputy attorney general for 11 years, as part of its evaluation of his fitness to be a judge. Some described him as “gratuitously rude.” Others expressed an “unusual fear” of consequences if they said anything bad about him because of his “deep connection and allegiance” to powerful politicians in Nebraska.

    ABA members also raised concerns that Grasz would be “unable to separate his role as an advocate from that of a judge,” given his record on such issues as abortion. Among other things, he defended Nebraska’s ban on partial-birth abortion, and, in a 1999 article, he argued that lower courts should be able to overrule Supreme Court decisions on abortion rights because “abortion jurisprudence is, to a significant extent, a word game.”

    “In sum, the evaluators and the Committee found that temperament issues, particularly bias and lack of open-mindedness, were problematic,” reads the statement submitted by Pam Bresnahan, the chair of the ABA’s standing committee that reviews nominees. “The evaluators found that the people interviewed believed that the nominee’s bias and the lens through which he viewed his role as a judge colored his ability to judge fairly.”

    White House deputy press secretary Hogan Gidley defended Grasz’s nomination.

    “Steve Grasz is an outstanding lawyer, who has the full-throated support of the President, both U.S. Senators from Nebraska, and lawyers on each side of the political spectrum,” Gidley told HuffPost in a Wednesday statement. “The ABA claims to be non-partisan, but the facts show it cannot be trusted to fairly evaluate exceptional nominees.”

    Sen. Deb Fischer (R-Neb.), who recommended Grasz to Trump, told the Senate committee she was “shocked” by the ABA rating. She said she didn’t come across “one single temperament issue” when she talked to Nebraskans about Grasz.

    “I am sad to say that, after thoroughly examining the substance of the ABA’s report, it is evident to me the ABA evaluation of Mr. Grasz was a baseless political character assassination,” Fischer said.

    But Whitehouse pointed out that 40 of the 42 judicial nominees Trump has put forward so far have gotten “qualified” or well qualified” ratings by the ABA. (Charles Goodwin, Trump’s pick for a district court in Oklahoma, was the other nominee rated “not qualified.”)

    “It would be hard for the committee to ascribe the outcome in this case to a general partisanship of the ABA process,” said the Democratic senator. “It would not be consistent with the facts.”

    It’s up to the White House to decide if it wants to plow ahead with Grasz. If the president doesn’t withdraw his nomination, the Judiciary Committee could vote to advance him to the full Senate in a matter of weeks.

    Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), who chairs the committee, said Wednesday that he invited ABA representatives to testify at a Nov. 15 hearing about their Grasz rating. They accepted, he said, so that hearing will happen before Grasz is scheduled for his committee vote.

    This story has been updated to include Grassley’s comments.

    Related:

    For more news videos visit Yahoo View.

    • This article originally appeared on HuffPost.
    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share

    What to Read Next

    • Yo! ‘Idol’ raps: Jurnee makes history on top 14 show

      Yahoo Music
    • Shania Twain revealed she would have voted for Trump, and that don't impress some fans much

      Yahoo Music
    • Kellyanne Conway clashes with CNN: 'You went there'

      Yahoo View
    • Bradley Cooper on His Secret Pact With Lady Gaga for ‘A Star is Born’

      Variety
    • Eminem Celebrates 10 Years of Sobriety

      Complex
    • Coachella 2018: Beyoncé fell on stage with sister Solange and then laughed it off

      AOL.com
    • Hannity’s relationship to Trump called ‘parasitic, co-dependent’

      Yahoo View
    • Kevin Feige Sees the Bright Side of James Cameron’s ‘Avenger Fatigue’ Comments

      Vulture
    • Beyonce Tries to Pick Up Solange, Falls During Her Coachella Set

      Variety
    • ‘A Quiet Place’ Roars Back to Top Box Office Spot With $21 Million

    • Sherlock's Benedict Cumberbatch Calls Co-Star's Fan Complaints 'Pathetic'

      TVLine.com
    • Brie Bella Opens Up About Twin Nikki and John Cena’s Doomed Engagement: 'I Want to Protect Her'

      People
    • ‘Trump may throw children under bus to protect himself’

      Yahoo View
    • What Are Prince William and Kate Middleton Naming the Royal Baby? The Top Predictions Are in!

      People
    • Eminem Is 10 Years Sober — See How He Celebrated the Landmark

      People
    • 'Austin Powers' Actor Verne Troyer Dead At 49

      HuffPost

    Trump Campaign Pays Lawyer Who’s Trying To Make Stormy Daniels Shut Up

    Banned: Is that legal?

    Join the Conversation
    1 / 5

    1.5k

    • Avenatti: Cohen ‘is going to be charged with serious crimes’

      Yahoo View
    • Pippa Middleton Reportedly Pregnant With First Child

      Entertainment Tonight Videos
    • Beyoncé Brought Out J Balvin for “Mi Gente” at Coachella

      Complex
    • Beyoncé and Solange Fell With Grace at Coachella and Fans Loved It

      Complex
    • Beyonce Cements 'Queen of Coachella' Status With Masterful Second Show

      Rolling Stone
    • Jenna Dewan Steps Out for First Red Carpet Appearance After Channing Tatum Split

      People
    • Ron Howard reveals brother Clint Howard's Solo: A Star Wars Story character

      Entertainment Weekly
    • Ben Affleck Throws Cast and Crew of New Movie a Hawaiian Luau — and Lindsay Shookus Was There

      People
    • Beyoncé Brings the Glam Again for Second Coachella Performance — All About Her New Balmain Looks

      People
    • The Complete Timeline of Marvel Cinematic Universe Movies, From ‘Iron Man’ to ‘Infinity War’

      The Wrap
    • The Walking Dead EP: Season 9 Brings 'Sophistication' as Survivors Attempt to Realize 'a Very Ambitious Dream'

      TVLine.com
    • Ewan McGregor Walks the Red Carpet With 'Playboy' Model Daughter Clara

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Barack and Michelle Obama, Melania Trump & More Attend Barbara Bush's Funeral

      Entertainment Tonight
    • Who’s Going to Die in ‘Avengers: Infinity War’? We Put Odds on Every Major Hero Biting the Dust

      The Wrap
    • The SCOTUS Travel Ban Case Could Have Implications Well Beyond Trump

      Yahoo View
    • Kate Middleton's Role in Harry & Meghan's Wedding

      Marie Claire