Second time’s the charm for Tony Shalhoub.
On Sunday, the Marvelous Mrs. Maisel star, 66, took home the award for outstanding performance by a male actor in a comedy series at the 2020 SAG Awards, his second consecutive win at the awards show.
“It’s kind of shocking because you don’t really think that it can happen two years in a row,” Shalhoub said at PEOPLE’s SAG Awards Gala. “… I guess it’s different because the second time, it just feels less likely.
He added to PEOPLE: “You feel like it’s a fluke the first time and then the second time — it can’t be two flukes in a row.”
In the series, Shalhoub — who said he’ll display his trophy on his fireplace at home — plays Abe Weissman, the father of the titular comedian Midge Maisel, played by Rachel Brosnahan.
“We’re all such big fans of Fleabag. They were having such an amazing year in terms of accolades and awards, and we just figured that this was their year,” Shalhoub told PEOPLE. “We were all fond of that because they’re still part of the Amazon family. But here we are.”
“I voted for Fleabag! This is really weird,” she said. “This makes no sense. I don’t know what to say. … This makes no sense, Fleabag is brilliant.”
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories
“I share this actor with my fellow Maisel castmates,” Shalhoub said. “It is a joy to know you. It is a privilege to work alongside you. And so with your blessings, I will dedicate this to one of our family who we lost this year and who we miss terribly, the most marvelous Brian Tarantina, our brother. Here’s to you.”
This is Shalhoub’s fourth SAG Award after winning last year for outstanding performance by a male actor in a comedy series, also for Maisel. He’s won previously in 2005 and 2004 for his performance in the comedy series Monk.
Season 3 of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is now streaming on Amazon Prime and a fourth season was ordered by the streaming service last year.