Teddi Mellencamp/Instagram Teddi Mellencamp Arroyave and daughter Dove
Teddi Mellencamp Arroyave is happy being a mother of three.
"The plan is no," she said on an Instagram Story Thursday, according to Us Weekly. "I didn't think I could get pregnant naturally, so Dove was a miracle baby."
"So now, to prevent the miracle baby, I am back on birth control," Mellencamp Arroyave added.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Mellencamp Arroyave has been open in the past about the challenges she experienced conceiving her oldest children.
"With Slate, I got pregnant via [intrauterine] insemination and with Cruz, it was through [in vitro fertilization], and it was multiple failed rounds of IVF. With both kids, I was on and off bed rest," she previously told PEOPLE. "There was a lot of stress."
Given her past experiences, the television personality — who had previously said she likely would not have another child — was surprised to be able to conceive naturally.
"I had no idea. I didn't even know I was pregnant until I was nine weeks pregnant," she said during a 2019 episode of her podcast, Teddi Tea Pod.
RELATED VIDEO: Teddi Mellencamp Arroyave Recalls How Daughter Slate, 7½, "Amputated the Tip of Her Finger" in a Door
Teddi Mellencamp Recalls How Daughter Slate, 7½, 'Amputated the Tip of Her Finger' in a Door
"I learned that you're not supposed to put a finger on ice," Teddi Mellencamp Arroyave says in her latest podcast episode
"We are so grateful to have an amazing team of doctors and surgeons who have caught this early and will be working on her," Mellencamp Arroyave shared in July. "The recovery is about a week in the hospital and a couple weeks at home with a very high success rate."
"Please keep baby Dove in your prayers," she added.
Fortunately, Dove's surgery was a success. In an update early last month, the daughter of singer John Mellencamp reflected on her youngest child's tremendous strength.
"It's crazy how resilient kids are. Dove is going into Day 4 post neurosurgery with both eyes open. The swelling went down, she passed all her markers and we have been sent home much earlier than expected," Mellencamp Arroyave said.
"I am so grateful for so many things and feeling really blessed. We love you so much baby Dove and know you are going to live whatever life you dream of," she added.