When the camera panned to Swift, the superstar (sandwiched between her pals Shawn Mendes and Camila Cabello) was seen rolling her eyes, glancing at her nails and casually singing along before breaking out into laughter.
Her Swifties took to Twitter to voice their appreciation for the star, who hasn’t attended an awards show since the 64th Annual BMI Pop Awards in 2016.
Check out PEOPLE’s full Billboard Music Awards coverage to get the latest news on music’s big night.
THE WAY SHE JUST LOOKED AT HER NAILS SO FLIPPANTLY IM JUST @taylorswift13 ARE U TRYING TO KILL ME SWEETIE IM ON THE FLOOR CACKLING AHAHAHA— jenna???? (@jennafaithm13) May 21, 2018
@taylorswift13 ATTITUDE DURING LOOK WHAT YOU MADE ME DO IS EVERYTHING ??????????????— So it goes... (@alltoowell68) May 21, 2018
The “Delicate” singer, 28, opted for an ethereal pink gown with a thigh-high slit and embellished silver details on the bodice by Versace for the annual show. She topped off her look with Casadei heels, Hueb earrings and rings by Fernando Jorge, Sara Weinstock Jewelry and Maxior.
- Want to keep up with the latest from PEOPLE? Sign up for our daily newsletter to get our best stories of the day delivered straight to your inbox.
She ended up taking home top female artist and top-selling album categories.
RELATED VIDEO: Taylor Swift Kicks Off Her Reputation Stadium Tour with Lots and Lots of Snakes (and Joe Alwyn!) — All the Details
The entertainer’s surprise appearance at the BBMAs comes one day after she performed two sold-out shows in the Los Angeles-area as part of her Reputation Stadium tour.
She surprised 60,000 fans at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, California, by bringing out Shawn Mendes on Friday and shocked the crowds on Saturday when she shared the stage with another very special guest: Selena Gomez.
Swift will be back on the road on Tuesday when she performs at CenturyLink Field in Seattle.
Her Reputation Stadium Tour will see her play dates across North America, Europe and Oceania through November.
The 2018 Billboard Music Awards will broadcast live from the MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas on Sunday, May 20 on NBC.