Stars Ask Stars Winter 2016 Edition: Felicity Huffman Tells Matt McGorry Not to Quit His Day Job

Sometimes journalists have to ask the hard questions, and in doing so, lives are saved and policies are changed. (See last weekend’s SAG Award-winner Spotlight.)

This is not one of those times.

This is just us, the journalists, yielding the power of the pen, a Sharpie to be exact, to a bunch of TV stars including Josh Duhamel, Oscar-winner Timothy Hutton, a Bachelor, a rapper turned primetime dad, and a couple of adorable Muppets. To break up a very long winter TV season press day, Yahoo TV challenged actors from ABC, Freeform, and Hulu shows to come up with a question for our next unknown victim, er, interviewee.

Related: Kerry Washington, Nathan Fillion, and Kermit the Frog Are in the Hot Seat When the Stars of ABC Interview Each Other

As you will see from this exclusive video, the conversation quickly turned from best on-set experiences and rainy-day activities to underwear, date-night bowel movements, and marine life fetishes. Fortunately, the stars were good sports, even when the game turned to so-obvious-you-miss-it riddles and utter nonsense about woodchucks. And we’re thinking Matt McGorry (How to Get Away With Murder) shouldn’t hold his breath for that game-night invite to Felicity Huffman’s house.