SCARLETT JOHANSSON ACTION: The Spirit, The Island ROMANCE: Vicky Cristina Barcelona, He's Just Not That Into You Though she began in more dramatic movies, Ryan Reynold's better half has also played both sides of the action/romance field. She's done a Michael Bay movie and a comic book adaptation, but both were box office duds. She's had better luck lately with love stories, including getting great reviews in her third Woody Allen movie, "Vicky Cristina Barcelona." That seems to be the best place for Scarlett, but the photos of her as Black Widow in next year's "Iron Man 2" make a pretty persuasive argument for the other side. VERDICT: Romance (until "Iron Man 2" changes our minds)
The Verdict: Action or Romance
We decide which stars ought to stick to action flicks, and which ones should only do romantic movies.