Patrick Mahomes is celebrating quite a few firsts this year.
Matthews, 25, paid tribute to the NFL star by sharing photos of some sweet father/daughter moments between Mahomes and their baby girl, who turned 4 months old on Sunday. "Happy 1st Fathers Day!!! We love you," the proud mom wrote in the caption.
Earlier this month, Mahomes enjoyed some quality time with his little girl as the two snuggled together.
Matthews shared a sweet picture to her Instagram Story that showed the quarterback cuddling with their daughter. In the snap, baby Sterling can be seen tucked up against her dad's side, wearing "xoxo" footie pajamas while Mahomes wraps his arm around her.
Never miss a story - sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Matthews celebrated the big day with her own heartfelt tribute to their baby girl. "Dear Sterling, thank you for making me a mommy and being the biggest blessing EVER, Mommy & Daddy love you more then [sic] you will ever understand," Matthews wrote.
Mahomes and Matthews welcomed their first child on February 20. The high school sweethearts got engaged in September 2020, the same day he received his Super Bowl ring.