Since deleted, the post was part of a series in which celebrities like Mindy Kaling, Ina Garten and Seth Meyers choose their favorite New Yorker cartoons. Lakshmi’s food-humor pick depicted a street hot dog vendor with the caption, “They’re marinated in hot water for six hours.”
Teasing the outlet for the identification error, Lakshmi posted a screenshot and reciprocated the mistagging by thanking the New York Daily News account instead of the New Yorker‘s.
“Thank you to the illustrious “@nydailynews” for the shoutout 😉 I know to some we all look alike, but 🤷🏾♀️…,” she wrote on Instagram, including hashtags of “Desi Life” and “Just Indian Things.”
Representatives from The New Yorker did not immediately respond to PEOPLE’s request for comment.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free weekly newsletter to get the biggest news of the week delivered to your inbox every Friday
Natalie Portman, who “liked” the post prior to the mishap making headlines, commented on Lakshmi’s retort, writing, “Oh no.”
Perhaps unaware of the mix-up, Chopra posted a photo of herself with husband Nick Jonas on Sunday, as they curled up on a boat with a picturesque sunset bathing the two of them.
“Life as it should be. 🌊 ❤️,” she captioned the romantic post.
In 2016, Lakshmi opened up to PEOPLE about being bullied in high school for her cultural background, even going so far as temporarily changing her name to Angelique.
“You can ask anybody who went to high school with me, they didn’t call me Padma,” she said. “I didn’t feel any different, I didn’t feel any less American, even though I ate rice and curry or even though my name was Padma or I spoke to my mother in a different language, I felt as American as anybody else in my classroom.”
She added: “But they didn’t feel I was as American.”