The Other Two exclusive after-show: Molly Shannon reveals the celebrity who leaves her starstruck

“I get nervous as myself if I do a talk shows,” Shannon explains to show creators Chris Kelly and Sarah Schneider on the series’ after show The Other Show. However, costar Drew Tarver was likely even more anxious for his character’s WWHL guest appearance, having been a bartender on the Andy Cohen show for real previously. “I could not remember that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern line,” says Tarver. “It was just like sense memory of being behind the bartender thing again.”

The Other Two airs Thursdays at 10:30 p.m. ET on Comedy Central.